4 ms·
Thanks, this doesn't sound quagmirish at all. YouTube is taking a lot of heat for kids viewing videos on its platform. It's unsurprising that they often exceed
by renewiltord 4y ago
Thanks, this doesn't sound quagmirish at all. YouTube is taking a lot of heat for kids viewing videos on its platform. It's unsurprising that they often exceed the boundary. You know the boundary exists and you know that censoring the audio then does the trick. So just do it.
- Ukv 4y agoMarking the video as not-for-kids (under 13) was expected. Age restricting the video to 18+, which heavily suppresses the video and requires watchers in many countries to give ID photo/credit card verification, was not expected. I've never seen that before just for swearing. > You know the boundary exists From the article, the video doesn't appear to break any of the publicly given rules. Likely it breaks some internal rule they use for judgement (X swears in Y seconds). The creator claims they'd be fine adjusting accordingly if Youtube gave some stance to follow - problem is pouring a ton of work into a huge video and only then having it unexpectedly restricted due to uncommunicated rules.
- kevinmchugh 4y agoA pg 13 movie can use the word "fuck" exactly once. More than once and it's an r rating (appropriate for 17+). I believe this has been the case in the almost forty years since pg-13 was introduced.
- Ukv 4y agoRecord for PG-13 movies is apparently Gunner Palace with 42 uses of "fuck". But more to the point, Youtube is not the MPAA. The documentary seems to comply to Youtube's publicly given rules more so than a huge number of other unrestricted videos, which makes the restriction unexpected.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoThe standards for MPAA ratings have changed dramatically with time. PG used to actually mean Parental Guidance, it wasn't just an initialism that meant "family friendly" in effect. Take Logan's Run (1976) for instance, that got a PG rating. It has orgy scenes and frontal nudity, if released today it would get an R rating easily.
- rightbyte 4y ago> It has orgy scenes It was a long time ago I watched it, but weren't the orgies just implied?
- MichaelCollins 4y agoThey're shown but somewhat obscured with psychedelic club lighting. You can see glimpses of naked people writhing around with body paint.
- raydev 4y agoI'll never forget staying at my grandma's house one time, she took me to Blockbuster and allowed me to rent anything that wasn't PG-13 or "worse". I picked up Airplane! because I had seen it on afternoon TV a few times, and it was rated PG. Fun for the whole family! Grandma and I found out that day that TV networks edited out full frontal nudity.
- davesque 4y agoThat's the channel creator's complaint though. He thought his video was below the stated profanity threshold. But YouTube age restricted it anyway. He found other examples of videos that weren't age restricted but had twice as much profanity. He also said he'd have no problem censoring profanity if he had known he had to. The problem is that an opaque moderation and appeals process is causing real harm to creators on the platform who are making good faith efforts to follow the rules.
- sumeno 4y agoFind the documentation on YouTube for that boundary and compare it to the video.