3 ms·
Every company has a certain threshold revenue size for new BU initiatives -- for a company Google's size it's going to be measured in the billions, which probab
by HillRat 4y ago
Every company has a certain threshold revenue size for new BU initiatives -- for a company Google's size it's going to be measured in the billions, which probably didn't seem unreasonable if they assumed game streaming would be a $5bn+ market by 2024 and they'd have a major piece of that. Instead, looks like Stadia was earning a bit south of $100mm/year (with likely unfavorable marginal economics), so well below where they would have wanted this to land.
The problem, of course, is that doing this is going to have downstream impacts if Google wants to stay in the gaming tech market (and some ancillary impacts on the perception of their stability as a tech partner in general). Whether that's worth the burn rate on the BU is a question that presumably was asked and answered, and led to this shutdown.
By contrast, of course, AWS is willing to keep solutions going essentially forever, even if they're on life support; while players like Microsoft or Intel are a lot more cautious about new BU initiatives in the first place. Google seems to be in a questionable middle ground of aggressively greenlighting new initiatives, but being unwilling to take the financial hit of sustaining them even if they don't pan out as desired.
- xwowsersx 4y agoWhat I don't understand then is why exactly people are upset with Google here. Is the expectation that when you launch a platform that people build on top of and involves partnerships with external partners that you should be hesitant to shut down given the investment that others have made based on your representations? I hear that, but has to have a limit. People can't expect Google to keep stuff around that really doesn't make sense for them. Is the issue that Google cheerleads these products and gets partners riled up, but is so quick to shutter them and demonstrates no concern for their partners? Like, what precisely is the critique?