2 ms·
I do think that intellectual property is currently a societal right This line of thinking misses the point - you cannot talk about a societal right if it
by bad_user 15y ago
I do think that intellectual property is
currently a societal right
This line of thinking misses the point - you cannot talk about a societal right if it goes against human nature.
And it is in human nature to share, much like making sex or having free will. It isn't hard to imagine a society in which your daughter is your property and you can marry her to whomever you want, selling her to the highest bidder. Such societies still exist in 2011. It wouldn't be hard to imagine that if the ration of women to men would get balanced, then some women are going to become independent and get married for free, slowly destroying a perfectly valid business model ... so what should people do in such a case? Push for legislation to fix it?
So if your society gives rights that go against human nature, then your society is broken, really ;-)
The real question is - how can we reward authors in a world where distributing digital works has zero cost?
I can think of many options, including introducing an optional monthly tax for anything you may download without a license to do so, which would at least work for another 5-10 years. Otherwise technology has been invalidating business models since forever, so maybe it's time to grow-up, quit the winning and think of other ways to make money - like doing good old fashioned concerts that can't be cloned or pirated - Michael Jackson understood this simple fact and made a lot of money off concerts, however I could see this not working so well in the long run for the likes of Bieber and Britney Spears.
- rbanffy 15y agoIn the end, it's like trying to save the ice industry from the competition with refrigerators. You will never again be able to sell, or profit from, goods that have zero cost of reproduction. Producers must find ways to sell what cannot be easily reproduced. Crowdfunding is just one of many models that solve this problem. The world has changed. It's about time those "rightsholders" got over it.