3 ms·
> Why stop at bone marrow? I would draw a very clear line: Renewable tissue and organs can be sold, non renewable ones can't. Blood, sperm, marrow: All sellab
by ars 15y ago
> Why stop at bone marrow?
I would draw a very clear line: Renewable tissue and organs can be sold, non renewable ones can't.
Blood, sperm, marrow: All sellable.
Kidneys: Nope, donation only.
Liver, skin: On the fence. (They renew, but only with scarring, and can be taken only a limited number of times.)
- carbocation 15y agoLiver is renewable, but living donation is extremely risky to the liver donor.
- ars 15y agoI'm not worried about risk, that's for the donor/seller to decide. Higher risk, higher money. It's no different than hazard pay for dangerous jobs. But my understanding is that someone can only donate a liver once, even though it regenerates. Perhaps that just because doctors are uncomfortable with the risk of a second donation?
- carbocation 15y agoI don't agree that tissue renewability is the correct sole factor in determining whether said tissue should be for sale. I think that donor risk is much more important. I consider this to be a bioethical issue but I think it's also pretty political so I'll probably refrain from making much of an argument here. I don't do liver transplant so I'm at the limit of my knowledge re: number of liver donations, but I would guess that it has to do with the fact that the donated segments do not regrow; the liver regains function, but not form.
- ars 15y ago> I think that donor risk is much more important. It would be important to me certainly, if I was considering donating. But at the end of the day each person much decide for themself. Just like people decide on a level of risk when accepting a job. If people are allowed to risk their life on a job to make money, they should be allowed to risk their life to donate tissue to make money. For donations though, any significant risk is probably not acceptable, which is the current situation.
- wisty 15y agoThis is actually the wrong way round. Blood has a low cost to the donor, so the "feel good" intrinsic reward is high enough to keep the supply going. Adding a price will just make it more expensive for poor people who need transfusions. Because kidneys are so expensive to donate, you can't rely on people's goodwill, so both poor people and rich people miss out. Of course, you would have to ensure that they wouldn't be sold to clear debts.