3 ms·
> ...I think that a more constructive strategy for solving the problem isn't to attack political contributions (which is bound to get into thorny First Amendmen
by Silhouette 15y ago
> ...I think that a more constructive strategy for solving the problem isn't to attack political contributions (which is bound to get into thorny First Amendment questions), but...
If you have reached the point where, at a fundamental constitutional level, you really can't distinguish industrial lobbyists buying laws from the freedom of individual citizens to express themselves, then you've already lost any chance you had of fixing this problem without building a new system of government. You have accepted that artificial entities such as corporations should be treated in a similar way to real people. At that point, you might as well just apportion votes by something like market cap and be done with it.
Personally, as a non-US citizen but part of an international community that is inevitably affected by bad government in the US anyway, I am hoping for a bigger version of what we did to our MPs in the run up to the last election: find a convenient political excuse to remove a substantial proportion of incumbents from the running altogether, and then not give any party outright control of the following Parliament. That should have led to fundamental reform of our voting system, but the campaign in favour of such reform were so incompetent that it was a damp squib in the end. In any case, I think we are being damaged considerably less by the coalition government we have today than we would have been under any one of the major parties alone (which is intentionally a pretty damning indictment of all the major parties). The US is in a much worse state than we are, because the whole deck is stacked so heavily against minor candidates that you're basically locked into a two-party mess until something revolutionary happens, but ruffling enough feathers to remind the public's representatives that lobbyists do not (yet) actually have a vote would be a good start.
- CWuestefeld 15y agoIf you have reached the point ... then you've already lost any chance you had You're probably right. But that doesn't mean we should give up: that would be even worse.
- Silhouette 15y agoOh, I'm not saying you should give up. On the contrary, I wish you all the luck in the world in restoring sanity to your political and legal systems. I just think you're going to need to bring down the whole house of cards and start over to do it. Then again, given the current economic conditions and the kind of idiocy that results in obviously bought-and-paid-for legislation like what we're discussing here, if ever there was a chance to shake things up it's probably over the next cycle of elections.