7 ms·
You guys may be interested in Flynn vs. Holder, which is a court case attempting to strike down the federal prohibition on selling bone marrow. If you could bu
by patio11 15y ago
You guys may be interested in Flynn vs. Holder, which is a court case attempting to strike down the federal prohibition on selling bone marrow.
If you could buy and sell bone marrow, all parties agree that that would happen more frequently than bone marrow donation. The side that believes that would be bad won.
(A brief sketch of the concern: if you allow money into the equation, either a) people who won the marrow lottery could extort money from folks who are dying or b) poor people would be hooked up to machines and have their vital juices sucked out so that rich people could live. A brief sketch of the argument for allowing bone marrow sales: the present law guarantees persistent market undersupply of bone marrow, which, with certainty, kills people.)
- learc83 15y agoThe only way to tell what will happen is to run a trial. That way we can stop conjecturing, and see what actually happens. My guess is it would work pretty well.
- blhack 15y ago<For reference: I'm not making claim one way or another here, just presenting an argument. This doesn't reflect my personal view, I'm just trying to explain the logic behind disallowing people to sell their organs> It's a moral minefield. When people get desperate for money, they're willing to do things that they might later regret. This is why things like loan sharks tend to be illegal (and why, one could argue, auto title loans and the like should be as well. In that case it's a matter of collective versus individual intelligence. Collectively, an auto title loan service is far more intelligent than an individual, and they are thus able to be predatory in their lending practices [to great success]). I'm not equating selling your organs with loan sharking, but I believe it illustrates my point. (Donating your organs to get yourself out of extreme financial hardship could be considered a form of duress. This is one of the classic arguments against prostitution.)
- maxharris 15y agoAs you've pointed out, the alternative for those who need these cells (but can't get them) is death. I agree completely. But the argument for the other side isn't sound. Poor people (with the right haplotype at the right time) could become quite rich if we don't try to interfere with bone marrow sales. Do you know what I'd pay for cells that would save my life if I needed them? Quite a lot more than I paid for my car.
- bentlegen 15y agoI think it is more likely that some company would get quite rich - not the people who initially possessed the marrow.
- uptown 15y agoI'll admit I haven't read the case you references, but once you build a financial marketplace around something, it will get controlled, manipulated and exploited. Why stop at bone marrow? Everybody's got a couple kidneys ... why not let people sell one? What about the donors who regularly give blood donations today? Would they stop doing so without being paid? I believe it's an oversimplification to just say that the current system kills people by design and that adding money will make it operate more effectively.
- ars 15y ago> Why stop at bone marrow? I would draw a very clear line: Renewable tissue and organs can be sold, non renewable ones can't. Blood, sperm, marrow: All sellable. Kidneys: Nope, donation only. Liver, skin: On the fence. (They renew, but only with scarring, and can be taken only a limited number of times.)
- carbocation 15y agoLiver is renewable, but living donation is extremely risky to the liver donor.
- ars 15y agoI'm not worried about risk, that's for the donor/seller to decide. Higher risk, higher money. It's no different than hazard pay for dangerous jobs. But my understanding is that someone can only donate a liver once, even though it regenerates. Perhaps that just because doctors are uncomfortable with the risk of a second donation?
- carbocation 15y agoI don't agree that tissue renewability is the correct sole factor in determining whether said tissue should be for sale. I think that donor risk is much more important. I consider this to be a bioethical issue but I think it's also pretty political so I'll probably refrain from making much of an argument here. I don't do liver transplant so I'm at the limit of my knowledge re: number of liver donations, but I would guess that it has to do with the fact that the donated segments do not regrow; the liver regains function, but not form.
- othermaciej 15y agoNot quite. The recent decision by the Ninth Circuit lets the prohibition stand as to bone marrow directly extracted from bones, but struck it down as to bone-marrow-derived stem cells extracted from blood. This should significantly increase the availability of donated bone marrow: http://volokh.com/2011/12/01/paying-people-for-bone-marrow-derived-stem-cells-extracted-from-blood-not-bone-are-legal-rules-the-ninth-circuit/ http://volokh.com/2011/12/01/paying-people-for-bone-marrow-d...
- patio11 15y agoWhoopsie. I was unaware there was news on that front in the last 48 hours -- when I said "This side won", I meant "When drawing up the legislation twenty years ago."