4 ms·
The DMCA is a collection of several laws. What people flipped out over (and are still disgruntled about) are the grotesquely overreaching DRM circumvention prov
by jerf 15y ago
The DMCA is a collection of several laws. What people flipped out over (and are still disgruntled about) are the grotesquely overreaching DRM circumvention provisions and penalties.
Safe harbor was generally ignored at the time the real furor occurred, and subsequently people have tarred the whole law with the same brush, but I've pretty much always thought the safe harbor provisions were reasonable.
And I'd echo rbanffy's basic point. The solution to the problem of SOPA isn't an Overton-window step-2 watered-down SOPA... it's nothing. Society doesn't have a significant problem that so desperately needs solving that we must run the risk of shutting down the growth engine that is the Internet and online economy, which has long since dwarfed the loud-but-much-smaller content industry.
If I had to lay money, I'd bet this passes. But a wise Google and a wise Internet would continue to push back even on the watered down version to make the point. The DMCA safe harbor is just fine as it is.
- nextparadigms 15y agoI agree. I think the solution to SOPA and PIPA is nothing, not a "lesser evil" or a "compromise". The music labels may die, but I don't think it's the Government's job to save them, just like it's not the Government's job to save the print media against Internet bloggers. I also don't think that there will be less music if the current music labels die. Copyright extensions have become ridiculous, and I think the labels have had their way for way too long in influencing the Government against the public and against the new creators. I think it's time to be reminded once again of Larry Lassig's TED video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Q25-S7jzgs http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Q25-S7jzgs Also when you watch it, and see the airplane example, think about it how it could've been if they "compromised" on saying "Airplanes are free to pass over properties, but helicopters not". It would've still been just as ridiculous. Perhaps not the perfect analogy, but something to think about.