6 ms·
Crisis pay cut: Consumers prefer firms that prioritize paying employees over CEO
- notch656a 4y agoConsumers also prefer if they get their shit for free. See how long your business lasts if you do that. Satisfying the consumer's every preference is not evidence the consumer, the employee, or the business will be served in the long run.
- wing-_-nuts 4y agoWhat on earth does this comment have to do with the post?
- notch656a 4y ago"consumers prefer firms that prioritize paying employees over CEO" >Satisfying the consumer's every preference is not evidence the consumer, the employee, or the business will be served in the long run.
- happytoexplain 4y agoYou've only quoted the article title and your own post (which seems condescending). You haven't explained why this particular consumer preference is more akin to "getting shit for free" (i.e. not worth consideration) than other consumer preferences, many of course are very much worth considering. Nor have you given some indication of why the opinion you're trying to get out is worthy of such a hostile tone.
- notch656a 4y ago>You haven't explained why this particular consumer preference is more akin to "getting shit for free" (i.e. not worth consideration) than other consumer preference) This would be a straw man. I never claimed that this particular preference is the same as 'getting free shit.' I merely show a customer preference isn't evidence of benefit for the employee or company in the long run. The statement was made to present that mere customer preference is not sufficient to show that the employee, customer, or company will be served in the long run. Whatever emotion you feel ('condescending' / 'hostile') you can talk to your therapist about; I'm not going to address your perceptions of hostility.
- nxm 4y agoQuite a bit. Some wealthy consumers may be privileged enough to be able to pay more for goods from a company that pays employees more. But I feel most consumers want their product for the least amount of cost (sometimes out of necessity) and don’t have time nor care about internal pay structures at company.
- seibelj 4y agoUsing mechanical turk to test consumer purchasing behavior is a meaningless exercise. Consumers care about price and quality, first and foremost. To fully explain the ethical practices of executive pay vs. employee compensation when someone is buying soap or cat food is not easy. However what I love about the free market is that everyone can experiment. If you can find competent executives willing to work way under market-rates to sell your soap and cat food as a for-profit charity, I welcome it!
- klyrs 4y agohttps://www.thefashionlaw.com/visibility-is-central-to-a-successful-supply-chain-heres-what-brands-need-to-know/ https://www.thefashionlaw.com/visibility-is-central-to-a-suc... Only, consumers actually care about ethics and that can actually hit your bottom line.
- willnonya 4y agoThat is an overly simplistic and utterly senseless perspective. The overwhelming majority of consumers could give a sh*t about these things when they're actually shopping for a product. These are the things people care about when being judged by others, not when deciding how to spend their money.
- klyrs 4y ago> That is an overly simplistic and utterly senseless perspective. That's a curious response to an explicit example of consumers not simply optimizing for cost and quality.
- happytoexplain 4y agoYour first sentence is pretty exaggerated (and borders on ad hominem). Regardless, even if I agree with your second sentence, I can still rationally disagree that it has no effect worth considering, either economically, morally, or even just personally. They aren't mutually exclusive, logically.
- notch656a 4y ago
- bhauer 4y agoThis is utterly unsurprising. By the same token, consider the vehicle market which has seen prices balloon in 2022 due to high demand. Consumers are less tolerant of dealer markups (which enrich a low value-add dealership) versus OEM markups (which ostensibly flow to the manufacturer and its employees).
- randomdata 4y agoI find it surprising that people prefer companies that pay their employees poorly as long as the CEO is also paid poorly over companies that pay their employees well and their CEO even better. My assumption would have been that consumers always prefer the employees being paid well over paid poorly. It's especially surprising because, assuming equal revenue, the shareholders "sitting back and doing nothing" derive greater benefit when everyone is paid poorly. Bias towards retirement stocks that the majority of the population (in the US) hold?
- HWR_14 4y agoI disagree with your characterization (or I read it wrong). These are pay cuts, so customers prefer those where the cuts fall on CEOs first and greatest. Your assumption that revenues remain constant seems to be one not shared by customers So, yes, people prefer to patronize companies where the pain is shared regardless of the size of the pain.
- randomdata 4y agoI was referring to the referenced earlier study contained within. It wasn't focused on cuts, although it is assumed in this study that the same would hold true in a cutting situation. My assumption of equal revenue was meant to be across companies. Obviously a company with no money can't pay as well as a company that can print money. But if two companies have equal revenue, but one pays less for its workers, then the net will stay in the company with a disproportionate benefit realized by the shareholders. I was surprised that consumers favour the shareholders getting rich over the workers, but perhaps that is because the odds are they are shareholders themselves.
- jedberg 4y agoEmployees prefer working for those firms too! Perhaps there is a correlation there...
- timmg 4y agoThat's the least of anyone's concern, though. If Google's CEO took a big pay cut and gave raises to his employees: no one would switch from iPhone to Android.
- Apreche 4y agoYou are correct. That certainly will not happen immediately, and not as a direct result of that action. However, it could theoretically result in employees preferring to work for Google instead of Apple. And employees at Google being happier. And happier employees doing better work. And then Android eventually being significantly better than iOS. And then consumers switching. Whether that chain of logic pans out in reality, I can't say.
- SoftTalker 4y agoAlso if Google's CEO took a big pay cut and distributed the cut to all the employees, they might not even notice it. The CEO is one guy, and there are over 100 thousand employees. People wildly overestimate the amount that CEO pay has any bearing on employee pay. It's all just emotional appeals to "fairness."
- HWR_14 4y ago> Also if Google's CEO took a big pay cut and distributed the cut to all the employees, they might not even notice it Google's CEO distributing his bonus would have worked out to an extra $3,000/each in 2018 (the easiest recent numbers to find). That's assuming that all employees got an even share. > emotional appeals to "fairness." There's reasons to want fairness that have nothing to do with emotion.
- SoftTalker 4y ago> There's reasons to want fairness that have nothing to do with emotion. Such as? The whole basis of fairness is emotion, mostly rooted in jealousy and envy. It ignores that people have different skills, abilities, intellect, drive, tenacity, etc. and says that everyone deserves the same outcomes.
- mkl95 4y agoAs always it depends. At a small startup the CEO may actually be worse off than their employees. As company_size grows the number of CEOs living paycheck to paycheck approaches zero.
- jmyeet 4y agoThis mentions the phrase "positive consumer reactions" but it's not clear what that means. Are they asked about their sentiments to the company? If so, this is meaningless. When asked, people virtue signal what they'd like others to believe about them. The true test is consumer behaviour and here there are legion examples of consumers basing their purchasing behaviour solely on lowest headline price. I mean the airline industry is a case study of this. The only thing that matters is the advertised seat price. Checked bags, which were once free/included, are now an extra to lower the advertised price. Air travel largely sucks because of consumer preferences. There are two lessons I'd like people to take away from this: 1. You can't rely on companies to police themselves be it based on consumer sentiment or anything else. This is the why libertarianism is so laughably flawed. Markets rely on government action and restrictions; and 2. Consumer sentiment or even consumer behaviour is not an effective way to police company behaviour because everything is so inextricably intertwined. Take the recently averted rail strike. This was to give essential workers paid sick leave where taking unpaid sick leave could lead to consequences to their job. What action can consumers take to communicate this to the companies involved?
- minraws 4y agoI would have liked to say "No shit, Sherlock!". But then again I didn't have any faith left in consumers so good to know. Thanks for the hopium.
- darth_avocado 4y agoThis is unsurprising considering majority of the population struggles with pay and even if they don’t, have struggled at some point in life. The problem though, is that often, this information is not available at the time of purchase to influence your decisions. When you’re buying a can of beans, you know nothing about how the company treats your employees to be able to make an impact in your behavior regardless of your opinions.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ouid 4y agocorporate leaders prefer to implement policies that benefit corporate leaders.
- YeBanKo 4y agoThe design of the studies is garbage: imaginary intention to make an imaginary purchase of an imaginary headphones from imaginary companies. Participants paid and recruited through mechanical turk. > Participants (N = 383; 52% female; age: M = 43.28 years, SD = 14.93) were recruited through an Amazon Mechanical Turk Prime Panel and paid a flat rate for compensation. This study used a 2 (employee type: retail employee vs. CEO) × 2 (salary: paid fully vs. cut fully) between-subject design. Participants were asked to imagine that they were looking to buy a new set of headphones from a well-known retailer. I bet that many people once they were done with the survey and paid went to Amazon and bought something, and did not care once about the pay of workers or conditions, when making an actual purchase.
- olliej 4y agoHaha, I just scanned for the sample size, I didn’t look at where it was taken from. Truly that is amazing.
- robbie-c 4y agoIf you scroll down to the details about the studies, you'll see that they just asked consumers what their stated preferences were, rather than observed what their actual behaviour was. Anyone who's ever priced anything before will tell you this is pointless at best and misleading at worst. We shouldn't spend any more time discussing such a bad study.
- olliej 4y agoI mean they say this, but let’s say it’s true (this study is small, and this is the kind of question where people “know” how they meant to answer to be a Good Person (tm)), lots of people can think that, but will still go for the best option from an overall consumer view. E.g I’ve recently being redoing a chunk of my kitchen, and issues with things from Home Depot and Amazon have been handled better in every case. Like I got a dishwasher from home depot that was clearly dropped (and delivered upside down), and they sent ups to pick it up for the return the next day. Similarly Amazon with damaged goods. The smaller firms have been the ones where I had more problems - so I paid more, it took longer, and I had more difficulty getting responses to a few of the missing parts. Every small/local business is like a lottery, and if there are other things involved (like when your contractors are going to be working) that just becomes too risky. So yeah, I’d prefer a company that lowered CEO pay, but preferring something doesn’t make it a realistic choice. (In a similar vein, I’d prefer to have an electric car, but that’s a lot of money and my current car works, so my current car remains)