3 ms·
Aren't those upsides and downsides just a direct consequence of using existing self-guiding missiles? AMRAAM, AIM-9x, IRIS-T are all existing, battle tested, re
by mrguyorama 4y ago
Aren't those upsides and downsides just a direct consequence of using existing self-guiding missiles? AMRAAM, AIM-9x, IRIS-T are all existing, battle tested, ready to go systems. My understanding is that the US intends to kill air capacity with its own planes, unlike the russian strategy of huge ground launched missile capacity. The NASAMS is for fellow NATO countries that don't have a substantial air force and need viable shorter range missile based AA.
- PaulHoule 4y agoYep. Those missiles are going to perform less well than they do from the air but that's been addressed by the development of longer ranged derivatives for NASAMS the similar sea sparrow. It's not clear that the US doctrine of air superiority is really correct or that NATO allies agree with it. For one thing, the US has spent 20 years fighting enemies that don't have an air force. If the US air force got involved in Ukraine, for instance, it would have to attack deep into Belarusian and Russian territory to destroy SAM systems which would otherwise make air operations dangerous or impossible. Turkey made the decision to give up the F-35 to get the S-400. Russia has been selling a huge number of S-300 and S-400 systems, one reason for that is that western powers haven't taken the category seriously. (A cynic might say, however, that the US would like to export NASAMS because it wouldn't be terribly effective against high-performance planes dropping this kind of thing from 40 miles away https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GBU-53/B_StormBreaker https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GBU-53/B_StormBreaker ... though Russians have done a lot of work at adapting anti-air weapons to shoot down precision guided munitions without a lot of success so far.)