3 ms·
The whole cloud provider using FHE usecase always seemed a bit utopian to me. As you say, most of the time they dont want to provide user privacy, they want you
by bawolff 4y ago
The whole cloud provider using FHE usecase always seemed a bit utopian to me. As you say, most of the time they dont want to provide user privacy, they want your data. Maybe i could imagine some sort of B2B case where there are strong requirements working out, but i struggle imagining it for consumer use cases.
Not to mention, if you are outsourcing data computation, presumably its a lot of computation or you would do it yourself, so the overhead seems extra important in that case.
The most convincing case i've heard is blockchain stuff - where everything is distributed to non trusted parties. (Normally i hate bitcoin hype, but maybe FHE would let you do something interesting with it)
- Dunny97 4y ago[dead]
- bawolff 4y agoI dont know what you are doing, but if you are using FHE explicitly for its post quantumness, you are doing something wrong as there are much much better choices if you need post-quantum versions of traditional primitives.
- vesinisa 4y agoYeah, I don't think this will work on commercial scale exactly for the same reasons as blockchain is useless for anything outside the illegal niches where you need to avoid the legal banking system. You may let people store homomorphic data on your servers and even run your algorithms on that data, but you have no way of handling customer complaints or fine-tuning / debugging your service because you can not understand ANY of the customer data you are storing. Similarly, blockchain sounds like a good idea until you need to reverse a transaction: https://www.pcmag.com/news/cryptocom-sues-woman-after-accidentally-sending-her-105-million https://www.pcmag.com/news/cryptocom-sues-woman-after-accide...