4 ms·
> I personally can't think of any other logical explication than German politicians having been "bought by Russians" to explain that decision. German here. Rus
by mschuster91 4y ago
> I personally can't think of any other logical explication than German politicians having been "bought by Russians" to explain that decision.
German here. Russian gas was absurdly cheap, I paid 5ct/kWh in 2015 and that included taxes. Large industry which was exempted from at least some of these paid even less. There simply was no economically viable alternative, even renewables today are more expensive than Russian gas was back then.
Yes, there may also have been corruption involved as well (just look at former Chancellor Schröder who started the entire NS1/2 mess, Merkel just ran along with it), but the primary motivation always has been price.
Hell even the primary motivation for NS1/2 was price, as there are no transit fees associated with it, unlike Drushba/Soyuz. The second motivation obviously was to reduce the leverage of Ukraine.
Side note: Assuming a household with 12.000 kWh/a thermal energy consumption, that was 600€ a year/50€ a month back then. At current gas prices, it's ten times that... which is the cause for widespread discontent and outright existential fear in society at the moment. When you only have 200-300€ left after rent and necessities, 50€ for heating is manageable - but 500€ certainly is not, and the new gas prices representing the current future market prices that will hit in next year aren't even priced in.
> I definitely saw this kind of stuff coming like 10+ years ago as they went full steam ahead with energiewende.
Lol what? Energiewende? You mean Mr. Altmaier and his conservative friends sabotaging the wind and solar industry wherever they could, leading to well over 100k lost jobs [1]? Fuck that shit.
[1] https://www.iwr.de/news/erneuerbare-energien-beschaeftigen-ueber-300-000-menschen-in-deutschland-news33964 https://www.iwr.de/news/erneuerbare-energien-beschaeftigen-u...
- lm28469 4y ago> There simply was no economically viable alternative, nucl... ah no that's bad
- mschuster91 4y ago> nucl... ah no that's bad The madness factor of nuclear power - safety, waste, availability factor (France!) - aside, nuclear power is economically even worse than brown coal [1, page 8], once you include externalized costs such as teardown, maintenance of the permanent waste dump sites or the insurance that an NPP would need without the taxpayer guarantee. [1] https://www.bundestag.de/resource/blob/887090/1867659c1d4edcc0e32cb093ab073767/WD-5-005-22-pdf-data.pdf https://www.bundestag.de/resource/blob/887090/1867659c1d4edc...
- qnsi 4y agodoes it take into consideration future emission costs? I speak a bit of german but not enough. I think it says in 2021 prices of everything?
- lostlogin 4y agoOP gave the price - would nuclear have been cheaper than that? And if even if it was, it takes an age to come online. It should have been done, but the reasons it wasn’t aren’t just outright corruption or anti-nuclear sentiment.
- colinmhayes 4y agoNuclear is the opposite of economically viable. It's the most expensive way to generate electricity.
- s_dev 4y ago>There simply was no economically viable alternative This was the lie that German politicians propagated after having been compromised. The obvious reality is Nuclear is economically and environmentally viable.
- mschuster91 4y agoYou can't heat homes with nuclear, that is the problem - you can't build them close enough to dense cities to make district heating viable due to the accident and terrorism risk. Yes, you can use nuclear power for electric heating, but well... France shows at the moment why this is a particularly foolish idea, their complete inability to keep their historic NPPs running and the new ones actually built (Flamanville...) is causing a lot of strain on the entire European electricity and even gas market, because German gas peakers now have to compensate for the lack of French NPPs.