3 ms·
"Cheap" has never really delivered. When was the most recent nuclear plant built within its cost estimate? > misinformed, and bad PR from high profile accident
by pjc50 4y ago
"Cheap" has never really delivered. When was the most recent nuclear plant built within its cost estimate?
> misinformed, and bad PR from high profile accidents isn't helping
I'd say that people were fairly informed by the accidents. Nuclear has a "radioactive black swan" problem: the worst-case accidents have contaminated such huge areas that the tolerance for risk of any kind is low. If the Russians blow up Zaporizhzhia while the wind is blowing east-to-west Europe will have to throw away half its dairy production again, possibly for years.
(On the other hand, if Chernobyl had happened while the wind was prevailing west-to-east, would we have even heard about it?)
- hef19898 4y agoThere was no way to keep that secret. Also it kind of indicates the USR only cleaned up under pressure from the West. Chernobyl was evacuated before the West was fully aware of what happened for example. After Chernobyl, a full train load of milk powder, from Eastern Europe, vanished in Bavaria. It was bought by a major dairy producer, when it was decided to destroy it said train was nowhere to be found... Funny coincidence...
- u320 4y ago> If the Russians blow up Zaporizhzhia while the wind is blowing east-to-west Europe Nope. Chernobyl was a different beast altogether.
- gizmo 4y agoWhen will the cancerous dust produced by coal plants finally be considered a cost? Nuclear is more expensive than the optimistic napkin math shows, but so is every other energy source! Europe has invested a trillion or two into intermittent green energy sources in the past 30 years —enough to nuclearize the entire energy grid— and is still totally dependent on coal and gas for survival. The argument has never been that nuclear doesn’t have any downsides. The argument is that without nuclear you’ll freeze. There is no serious alternative. The risks of accidental nuclear contamination are minimal and the risks of nuclear war are greatly underestimated.
- ETH_start 4y agoIronically, no faction has done more to stop the expansion of nuclear power than environmemtal groups and green parties.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoBasically every regulation or idea that benefits renewables benefits nuclear, and every regulation that fights climate change benefits nuclear. So environmental groups have done more than most, possibly tied with the military, for nuclear power.
- ETH_start 4y agoIn Germany, the national Green party is the primary instigator behind the planned closure of the country's nuclear power plants. Greenpeace for its part has lobbied hard against nuclear power for decades. As for regulation, nuclear is governed by a totally separate regulatory structure, that can have its stringency throttled up by anti-nuclear types to prevent new plant approvals.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoOne party in one country that's not been in power for a while is hardly decisive. Especially when they fast tracked coal phase out as soon as they had some power. I can easily name environmentalists who called for more nuclear power. I can even name nuclear PR reps who pretended to be environmentalists (who probably count for this purpose). Meanwhile, the key benefits of nuclear over coal are various reductions in pollution. If you dont care about pollution, then there's no reason to not use coal. So Environmentalists win again.
- ciphol 4y agoEven more ironically, environmemtal groups and green parties have essentially created the problem of climate change. If the whole world had switched to nuclear power starting in the 1970s, a large fraction of carbon emissions so far and a larger fraction of future emissions would never have happened.