3 ms·
This is a solid article, because certainly some people do identify with the rationalist tribe despite being not very good at it (isn't it true of all tribes?).
by dasil003 15y ago
This is a solid article, because certainly some people do identify with the rationalist tribe despite being not very good at it (isn't it true of all tribes?). But there's something else that bothers me about the rationalist tribe.
Why do people join it? Why does someone self-identify as a rationalist?
For the most part people are rational within the framework they have that allows them to get by in the world. Sure it's important to question beliefs to further the state of science, etc, but why is is it critical that any idea one holds be proven to the best of our abilities? I don't understand why belief in god has to imply there is anything magic or supernatural; it just might be something we don't understand. Certainly it seems possible that the universe exists within frameworks whose workings can never be fully understood from our current physical position. The rationalist view seems to be to let the astrophysicists do their work, but don't you dare believe in something that is outside the realm of what they will eventually discover.
I understand religion has done a lot of awful things in the past, and so it deserves to be torn down as an institution, but most bad things are propagated by extremely rational actors out of greed and self-interest. I don't see the harm in people believing in astrology or not being atheists, I'd rather see the rationalists take their arguments against the people who are actually doing major harm in the world (eg. profiting from massive environmental destruction).
- tensor 15y agoI would argue that a tendency to not recognize the lack of merit in an idea is harmful in itself. Let us take your example of astrology. What harm is there in believing it, despite no evidence nor any reason to suspect it is even a good hypothesis? For one, you might waste resources such as money and time reading about it, or getting readings. A minor thing perhaps. On the other hand, what about people who believe in it so deeply that they give away all their fortunes chasing nothing? What if someone ruins a relationship because they read in their horoscope that they should be wary of their partner? These are just a few example. I would also hypothesis that if one is willing to believe in one thing such as astrology, they are also likely believe in other things. Those other beliefs may also hold hidden dangers. Thus, it is important to always practice undiscriminating scepticism. Always try recognize what you don't know.
- tokenadult 15y agoWhy does someone self-identify as a rationalist? I'll just speak for myself in answering your question. Other people who self-identify as rationalists may have other reasons. I self-identify as a rationalist because, after a lifetime of being curious and wanting to know what is true, I have found rationalism a powerful instrumental means of discovering truth. I have found from observation of my own life that knowledge of truth is itself an instrumental means for pursuing other useful goals (for example, making a living for my family) but anyway I think truth-seeking is part of human nature at its best and something fun and worthy for its own sake. most bad things are propagated by extremely rational actors out of greed and self-interest I might disagree with you about there being very many "extremely rational actors" in the world, http://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/stanovich1/English http://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/stanovich1/Engli... but I agree with you that many bad acts are prompted by greed and self interest. One of the greatest achievements of rational thought has been a deeper understanding of how human moral sentiments http://www.amazon.com/Theory-Moral-Sentiments-Great-Philosophy/dp/1573928003 http://www.amazon.com/Theory-Moral-Sentiments-Great-Philosop... can be motivated by the actions of human beings pursuing their self-interest. http://www.amazon.com/Wealth-Nations-Bantam-Classics/dp/0553585975/ http://www.amazon.com/Wealth-Nations-Bantam-Classics/dp/0553... This discovery has resulted in considerable reduction of violence and other bad things over time, http://www.amazon.com/Better-Angels-Our-Nature-Violence/dp/0670022950/ http://www.amazon.com/Better-Angels-Our-Nature-Violence/dp/0... and promises to provide continued blessings of more peace, prosperity, and freedom as it becomes more widely known to humankind. So I pursue rationalism as a positive good for my family and for my society, after having had a childhood upbringing with more nonrational dogmas than I know adhere to.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- sgoranson 15y agoI think rationality is useful because it is the only reliable path to truth. And truth is required to accomplishing almost everything. Except happiness...which may have been your original point.
- dasil003 15y agoOr more generally, inner truth. This is why I am not a rationalist or an objectivist. Human experience itself is subjective, and even if through supreme rationality we are able to pry apart our psyches and lay it bare as a pile of neurons then what? Do we feel good about that? I choose to believe in a higher consciousness because it makes my life richer, not because I am hiding from rational, physical, objective truth.