4 ms·
By this logic, it should be illegal / a breach of contract for you to run an ad blocker, since the company may not make money? Should you also be forced to look
by tsimionescu 4y ago
By this logic, it should be illegal / a breach of contract for you to run an ad blocker, since the company may not make money? Should you also be forced to look at ads and not switch channels while they're on TV, with the channel being free to cut access if they find you haven been looking at the ads they serve?
This logic really bends over backwards to support FB's and similar business models.
- dylan604 4y agoRather than just blocking the request for the ad, if an ad blocker allowed the requesting site to make the request for the ad but then just sent the data to the browser's equivalent of /dev/null, I'd be fine with that as long as I never had to see/hear the ad. This is of course ripe for abuse, but that's just synonymous for digital advertising in general. I don't consider it any different than me hitting mute on the TV during ad breaks or getting up and going to another room during that break.
- tsimionescu 4y agoThis makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. If you don't think sites have a fundamental right to push ads to sustain themselves (as I don't), then blocking the request is the best place to do it for performance reasons. But even if you do believe in that right - the site and advertiser care about a single thing: a human being seeing the ad. Serving the Ad request is not just useless for their purpose, it is actively costing them money, and potentially muddling their data.
- dylan604 4y ago>the site and advertiser care about a single thing I disagree. The site just wants the advertiser's money. The advertiser wants the human to see an ad.
- hedora 4y agoThe user wants to support the site, and doesn't want to see the ad. Why not have the browser /dev/null them, and click a few for the heck of it? It would be in the user's interest.
- LoganDark 4y agoAdNauseam does this, it clicks all or most of the ads that it blocks. It's based on uBlock too. https://adnauseam.io https://adnauseam.io
- dylan604 4y agoIsn't this what I stated in the original comment?
- simiones 4y agoDoing that is borderline fraud - I believe that GP meant to highlight this. If it gets counted as actual clicks, it's actually explicitly defrauding the advertiser.
- hedora 4y agoIs it though? Most people sometimes leave the room while ads play on TV. The advertisers know that and work the percentage of pepole that do that into their pricing, etc. Also, non-organic click fraud is rampant already (and maybe even the majority of clicks). /dev/null + click would at least route ad income to reputable sites that at least have some human readers to view future ad impressions.
- simiones 4y agoThere is a difference between you ignoring ads as a user, or an adblock tool removing the ads entirely, and a tool that explicitly tries to make it look as if the user is interacting with the ads. The last tool is actively malicious and deceptive in a way the others are not.
- LocalH 4y agoThat would still waste bandwidth.
- geysersam 4y agoYes, if a website clearly stated that by accessing the content of the webpage you agree to not use an adblocker while doing so, that could well be legal depending on the circumstances. Enforcing it would of course be difficult. If you found out Netflix actually streams their content from a public endpoint. You would not be legally allowed to take advantage of that.