3 ms·
What does "steelman" mean in this context?
by globular-toast 4y ago
What does "steelman" mean in this context?
- medstrom 4y agoBasically, it means "explain". The connotation is the opposite of straw-man, so OP wants people to start from the assumption that it's true they need all those 7,400 employees, and explain why this would be the case. OP is not looking for cynical explanations such as that they only have so many employees due to incompetence.
- globular-toast 4y ago"Explain" was the only possibility I came up with and was wondering how on earth OP got an autocomplete error to the word "steelman". What a grossly unnecessary word.
- odysseus 4y agoIt might mean "reinforce this argument/provide evidence for this", per https://constantrenewal.com/steel-man https://constantrenewal.com/steel-man From the context, it might also mean "rebut this as strongly as possible", "criticize this" or "defuse this argument". It's unfamiliar wording to me as well. Does anyone have a rough etymology of "steelman" as a verb?
- chihuahua 4y agoI think steelman is derived as the opposite of strawman. Taken literally, something made from straw is weak, and something made from steel is strong. A strawman is an imaginary opponent who is easy to defeat. Like a scarecrow (a human-like figure stuffed with straw, meant to scare off birds from crops) which would be easy to defeat because it doesn't fight back when attacked.
- gwd 4y agoIt's the opposite of strawman. A strawman argument is a weak argument to justify a position you disagree with; its purpose is rhetorical: It's meant to make your position look strong to onlookers (and perhaps to yourself). A steelman argument is the strongest possible argument you can come up with to justify a position you disagree with; its meant to help you find the truth by taking seriously the people who disagree with you. OP is using the word slightly differently than normal, in that the position OP disagrees with here is, "Docusign needs 7,400 employees". A strawman would be, "Docusign needs 7,400 employees because it needs to show the stock market that it's a serious company" -- weak and easy to demonstrate that it's stupid. A steelman would be, "Docusign actually needs that many sales people and customer service reps."