9 ms·
>For instance, shadow banning, by which a platform renders a user's posts invisible to all but that user, cannot convey a message because no one knows, except t
by mrguyorama 4y ago
>For instance, shadow banning, by which a platform renders a user's posts invisible to all but that user, cannot convey a message because no one knows, except the platform, that it is happening
That's nonsense. Anyone on a heavily moderated forum can see that the "message" produced from proper moderation (things you can't see like behind the scenes spam prevention and banning) have a visible result in a higher quality forum experience. We literally see this here. Moderation is a choice, and by what things you do to moderate, you are making editorial choices that have outward effects. If you decide to shadowban any account not posting from florida, that will have an outwardly visible message that non-floridians are unwelcome. The first amendment makes no mention about the type of speech that congress cannot make a rule against.
Consider a store. If the Gay-Straight Alliance or similar approaches hobby lobby about some promotion, and hobby lobby says no internally, there's no outwardly visible evidence without affidavit from GSA and yet that's still a protected choice of Hobby Lobby over their own speech.