4 ms·
That 40% rule seems nuts. Who is making $65k that can truly afford a $500k house?
by giantg2 4y ago
That 40% rule seems nuts. Who is making $65k that can truly afford a $500k house?
- rednerrus 4y agoNo one.
- giantg2 4y agoI've always heard 2.5x-3x your gross annual salary. Which makes sense, but us also would price people out of the big markets.
- mikeyouse 4y agoRight, and it ignores interest rates which is the whole point of comparing actual mortgage costs instead of home prices. Same example, $65k salary x 3x to get a home value would be a $200k house. That's a total annual home cost of $11,750 with 2.75% interest rates and $16,200 with 6.5% rates. If they can afford the $16,200 today based on the 3x rule, then surely they could have afforded a $285k house (4.4x gross) last year considering the monthly cost would be identical?
- giantg2 4y agoMaybe, maybe not. The monthly cost wouldn't be identical due to taxes, difference in down payment (if also following best practices there), insurance, and that ignores potential future repairs (more expensive houses tend to be larger and/or fancier).
- mikeyouse 4y agoActually I should have shared the link I was using - my figures included proportionally higher taxes and insurance per the Smartasset calculator to get to the same monthly payment. Though yes, the down payment would be higher since I assumed 20% down for both. https://smartasset.com/mortgage/mortgage-calculator https://smartasset.com/mortgage/mortgage-calculator
- peteradio 4y agoSame house should net same taxes even after a value increase, cities/counties have a levy and back calculate the necessary tax to raise it. If your home increased in value, so did your neighbors.
- mikeyouse 4y agoLike most rules-of-thumb, they're 'fuzzy' and it's not about the total home value but the actual monthly cost of ownership. Pick a state though, say Missouri. A married couple earning $65k will bring home $50k after tax. In the first example, with a mortgage + tax + insurance house cost of $2,200/month, their home costs will be about $25k/year leaving them about $25k for other spending. Not lavish, but likely doable. The real comparison though, is what they could rent an apartment for as the alternative to buying that house. In most places, they'd be paying nearly that same total in rent so it's basically a wash (assuming they can come up with the down payment).