6 ms·
The whole idea that since they have economies of scale, they must pass those savings on to you is a misunderstanding of how companies work. Realistically, a co
by pclmulqdq 4y ago
The whole idea that since they have economies of scale, they must pass those savings on to you is a misunderstanding of how companies work.
Realistically, a company will charge slightly less than whatever your alternative is, and they will provide products that restrict the number of alternatives you have.
AWS, GCP, and Azure provide several differentiated products that lock you in to higher prices on everything else. Effectively, these three have an oligopoly on "highly differentiated cloud services." They are only competing with each other on those services, and they are competing with "servers plus ingress/egress costs to our differentiated services" on their commodity products. That is the real reason why AWS egress costs are so high. It prevents you from picking and choosing where to buy each part of your cloud footprint, and locks you into buying AWS. Bandwidth costs are what keep you inside the AWS/GCP/Azure walled garden.
Lower-end providers like Linode, DigitalOcean, Vultr, and Cloudflare have parts of the differentiated offering, but not all of it. These people will have lower prices than AWS/GCP/Azure since their offering is less differentiated, but they will still charge you more than you would pay by renting a server, since they offer more products.
Finally, hardware rental providers like Hetzner and other operators are competing directly with you buying the hardware and paying for datacenter space and bandwidth. Datacenters typically charge a premium for power, even when they are in areas with low-cost power.
Notice that none of these companies are competing with large-scale server buyers who have the same hardware/bandwidth/power costs that they do. As such, they do not need to pass the savings they get onto you. That is where they get their profit.
- pessimizer 4y ago> The whole idea that since they have economies of scale, they must pass those savings on to you is a misunderstanding of how companies work. That idea was not expressed in the comment that you replied to. The comment you replied to was in response to a strong claim that ignored the existence of economies of scale, and therefore concluded that it's so obvious that cloud providers must always be more expensive than self-hosting.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoAt this point, it should be pretty clear that self-hosting is cheaper, given all of the examples we have seen. AWS's economies of scale have as much to do with its pricing as the phases of the moon, and citing them as a reason why AWS could be cheaper than self-hosting is pretty ignorant in itself.
- pwinnski 4y agoOn the contrary, self-hosting is only cheaper under some circumstances, which is why when those circumstances are met, it becomes a story worth a post on HN. Whether economies of scale, or the efficiency of managed services at scale, or use-based loss leaders, there are many ways in which AWS services could be, and often are, cheaper than self-hosting. Of course, not always.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoIn my experience, it is almost always not cheaper to use AWS services, unless your workload is exceptionally bursty in an unpredictable way or fits entirely in the free tier. Pretty much nothing at AWS is a loss-leader except the free tier. Also, if your workload is small and you don't need to hire cloud ops folks, you can come out ahead on TCO.
- pwinnski 4y agoSo we have gone from a categorical "not cheaper" to "almost always not cheaper," except for two circumstances, no, three. Progress! At my last company, providing SaaS for the education market, moving from a datacenter to AWS saved almost 70% year-over-year. In the datacenter, we ran machines to cover our peak load, which only happened a few times a year. In AWS, we scaled way down and auto-scaled up during those peak weeks. Is the entire education market "exceptionally bursty?" I suppose it could be considered so. Bar exams and midterms and finals certainly don't happen every week. I'll wait for people to tell me how AWS was the wrong solution, and how we did everything wrong before that, but the bottom line is we saved a lot of money, accelerated our development schedule by building all new functionality using the so-called "serverless" stack, and succeeded so well during the pandemic that another company acquired us... which is why it's my former company.
- jstanley 4y ago> The whole idea that since they have economies of scale, they must pass those savings on to you is a misunderstanding of how companies work. Your parent comment wasn't saying that AWS is necessarily cheaper than running hardware yourself. It was saying that AWS is not necessarily not cheaper.
- JohnHaugeland 4y ago> The whole idea that since they have economies of scale, they must pass those savings on to you is a misunderstanding of how companies work. You're responding to someone who said "can," not "must." What they said was "there's no requirement that cloud costs more than traditional hosting. Their scale allows them lower fundamental costs. They could outcompete traditional hosting on cost if they wanted to." There's no misunderstanding of how comapnies work in what parent poster said; in reality they are 100% correct, and this is the path that CloudFlare is beginning to follow with services like workers and R2.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoR2 and workers are absolutely not cheaper than doing it yourself. They are cheaper than AWS, but both of those services are "value-added" from AWS, and as such have a 20-100x markup.
- JohnHaugeland 4y agoR2 is radically cheaper than doing it yourself It's a CDN, not a filestore. CDNs mean hundreds of locations.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoR2 is an object store. It is literally a drop-in replacement to S3. Cloudflare is a CDN, which, like all of its competitors, is a lot cheaper than doing it yourself because CDNs are a competitive market. There are at least 10 (if not more) CDN providers out there that have footprints in several thousand datacenters, and the product is completely undifferentiated. In a competitive market, you have to charge related to your costs, because your competitors will cut prices to their costs. In other words, in a competitive market, economies of scale get passed on to consumers. In monopoly and oligopoly markets, that is not the case. Object stores are becoming a competitive market, with R2, B3, and Wasabi entering the game, but buying your own machines and using Ceph is still cheaper. You still pay for "value adds" like not having to manage the machines yourself.
- aetherson 4y agoThere is plenty of competition for AWS, so we would, in terms of economic theory, expect that AWS charges you mildly more than it costs them to provide the service, unless they have any particular economies of scale that people like GCP and Azure (and the other less-known cloud offerings) do not have access to. Which seems unlikely to dominate the costing. AWS may be able to charge a surcharge for being the biggest and best-known cloud offering that most people have expertise with, raising the de facto cost of switching.