5 ms·

Tell HN: It would be cool if a mousewheel momentum scrolled

2 points by graderjs 4y ago

As in had a little flywheel or servo motor in it, and momentum scrolls in sync with whatever screen you're scrolling. As in you can take your finger off and the little thing just keeps on scrollin'. Would be a nice little "haptic" (if that's the right word) ergonomic thing for a mouse to do.

57FkMytWjyFu 4y ago
I'd go with a macro mouse with [Ctrl W], [Ctrl T], [Ctrl Shift T], [Page Up], and [Page down]. (And you still have 7 more shortcuts for whatever.) Pages hiccup on scroll wheel mice, so your 'momentum' gets eaten every time the pagination occurs.
cameron_b 4y ago
I've seen some mice with heavy freewheeling scroll wheels instead of the indexed experience and it took a little time to get used to it. I think you're meaning to implement a simple break to communicate "no more page" which I think would be an interesting addition.
- graderjs 4y ago
  No. I literally mean like, you know how you can scroll swipe on mobile (or trackpad) and the page just keeps running. I think the scrollwheel should too, even if it wouldn't under it's own momentum, it should remain spinning in sync with the page (servo, I guess...?). But I hadn't thought of your thing (the scrollwheel kind of stops and, I guess you mean, can't me moved further, once you reach the end of the page), and I like that idea! :)
  - kbrannigan 4y ago
    If you go to major electronic shops: Better Buy, Stables etc... you can test mice like that. Logitech, Microsoft. They have little flywheels that keep on going
- __d 4y ago
  The Logitech MX Master series has a heavy, (optionally) free-spinning scroll wheel. It's the best scroll wheel I've ever used: night and day better than anything else. Scrolling through a long doc is a flick or two, and it just keeps rolling along, until you touch it and it stops instantly. It allows amazing precision. If only the side-to-side scroller was as good ...
  - Tomte 4y ago
    Unfortunately, it's prone to breaking. There is a mechanism controlling the wheel mode that can mechanically get into a position where the magnetic control doesn't do anything. Sometimes, thumping the mouse hard against your thigh helps resetting the mechanism, but sometimes not. My first one went out within warranty, I've got it replaced, but I'm sure this one will fail in a few months, as well. Logitech probably saved a cent or two there, crippling an otherwise fantastic mouse.
    - nikau 4y ago
      My original MX revolution is around 15 years old and the scroll wheel still works fine. I did have to solder in some new microswitches for the main buttons, but that's not unexpected for the amount of use its had.
      - Tomte 4y ago
        I think the mechanism was new for the MX Master.
        nikau 4y ago
        Yeah mine has a motor that turns a detent ball, newer ones use a magnet I think
logicalmonster 4y ago
Would I like to see this? Yes, of course, it sounds neat. But is there a chance that this could be a really fun toy for about 10 minutes, and then it becomes a bit annoying? Maybe.
ohadron 4y ago
Try out the Logitech MX Master 3 scroll wheel. It's similar to what you describe, and honestly not a huge game changer for me.
btkthrowaway1 4y ago
I've been using the MX Anywhere mouse from Logitech for over a decade now and I think it's had this feature for most of that time.
warrenm 4y ago
I've used mice in the past that had a scroll wheel that would "coast" a little if you pushed it hard And swiping on tablets/smart phones does what you describe So does swiping on my Mac's trackpad
swah 4y ago
Even cheap mice from Logitech has something like this now (SmartWheel)

2 points by graderjs 4y ago

57FkMytWjyFu 4y ago

I'd go with a macro mouse with [Ctrl W], [Ctrl T], [Ctrl Shift T], [Page Up], and [Page down]. (And you still have 7 more shortcuts for whatever.) Pages hiccup on scroll wheel mice, so your 'momentum' gets eaten every time the pagination occurs.

cameron_b 4y ago

I've seen some mice with heavy freewheeling scroll wheels instead of the indexed experience and it took a little time to get used to it. I think you're meaning to implement a simple break to communicate "no more page" which I think would be an interesting addition.

graderjs 4y ago
No. I literally mean like, you know how you can scroll swipe on mobile (or trackpad) and the page just keeps running. I think the scrollwheel should too, even if it wouldn't under it's own momentum, it should remain spinning in sync with the page (servo, I guess...?). But I hadn't thought of your thing (the scrollwheel kind of stops and, I guess you mean, can't me moved further, once you reach the end of the page), and I like that idea! :)
- kbrannigan 4y ago
  If you go to major electronic shops: Better Buy, Stables etc... you can test mice like that. Logitech, Microsoft. They have little flywheels that keep on going
__d 4y ago
The Logitech MX Master series has a heavy, (optionally) free-spinning scroll wheel. It's the best scroll wheel I've ever used: night and day better than anything else. Scrolling through a long doc is a flick or two, and it just keeps rolling along, until you touch it and it stops instantly. It allows amazing precision. If only the side-to-side scroller was as good ...
- Tomte 4y ago
  Unfortunately, it's prone to breaking. There is a mechanism controlling the wheel mode that can mechanically get into a position where the magnetic control doesn't do anything. Sometimes, thumping the mouse hard against your thigh helps resetting the mechanism, but sometimes not. My first one went out within warranty, I've got it replaced, but I'm sure this one will fail in a few months, as well. Logitech probably saved a cent or two there, crippling an otherwise fantastic mouse.
  - nikau 4y ago
    My original MX revolution is around 15 years old and the scroll wheel still works fine. I did have to solder in some new microswitches for the main buttons, but that's not unexpected for the amount of use its had.
    - Tomte 4y ago
      I think the mechanism was new for the MX Master.
      - nikau 4y ago
        Yeah mine has a motor that turns a detent ball, newer ones use a magnet I think

logicalmonster 4y ago

Would I like to see this? Yes, of course, it sounds neat. But is there a chance that this could be a really fun toy for about 10 minutes, and then it becomes a bit annoying? Maybe.

ohadron 4y ago

Try out the Logitech MX Master 3 scroll wheel. It's similar to what you describe, and honestly not a huge game changer for me.

btkthrowaway1 4y ago

I've been using the MX Anywhere mouse from Logitech for over a decade now and I think it's had this feature for most of that time.

warrenm 4y ago

I've used mice in the past that had a scroll wheel that would "coast" a little if you pushed it hard And swiping on tablets/smart phones does what you describe So does swiping on my Mac's trackpad

swah 4y ago

Even cheap mice from Logitech has something like this now (SmartWheel)