4 ms·
Crypto is an option here. Seems like a pretty good fit for what the sex workers need.
by roenxi 4y ago
Crypto is an option here. Seems like a pretty good fit for what the sex workers need.
- LinuxBender 4y agoAn immutable record of who paid what sex workers sounds like it has the potential for machine learning to map who did what and with whom. Could this information be abused?
- takoid 4y agoThere are cryptocurrencies besides Bitcoin. Monero seems like an appropriate choice for this use case.
- ethotool 4y agoCrypto has been such a proven failure yet people still say these things on the regular.
- x86x87 4y agoHere is one thing you can do with crypto that you cannot do with a credit card: use your money how you would like. There is no payment processor to decide that you are not allowed to send or receive money.
- mrguyorama 4y agoMeanwhile walmart still won't let me buy snacks with bitcoin
- x86x87 4y agoEveryone believes that's an edge case/oddity until they or a business they care about gets banned by the payment processor gods.
- ceejayoz 4y agoSure, unless you need a mortgage, a car loan, or any number of other financial products.
- dymk 4y agoOr groceries
- ceejayoz 4y agoThere are a couple debit cards that'll let you spend out of crypto holdings. I do suspect they've still got a KYC process involved, though.
- dymk 4y agoGuaranteed that if they're interacting with a bank or card network, there's KYC involved (in the US and most western countries). So that defeats the whole "fully anonymous" bit. I still don't understand the "anon" value prop of crypto. We've had anonymous payments for goods (like groceries) for a long time - cash.
- mrguyorama 4y agoI would not consider cash anonymous in a grocery store anymore. They're tracking you through other means, including using the bluetooth in your phone, hiring facial recognition companies, and other bits of data to try and have some form of identifier for you that they can put all your purchases on.
- dymk 4y agoThat’s true, I mean more for transactions on e.g. Craigslist or a farmers market.
- mrguyorama 4y agoCraigslist has logs of your conversations, which they will definitely share with police when asked (which likely happens all the time) and then the police can buy your phone location data from whoever and track what happened. Nothing is anonymous without extreme and CONSTANT effort. Any second you don't have perfect opsec, you should assume you are perfectly tracked. This is independent of any laws congress makes, because the policing apparatus does this itself. The only way to change this is make it illegal to track transactions for anyone, including police, but the second we do that we will see significant sanction busting, money laundering, spam, scams, online casinos, fraudulent businesses etc. All crime involves money at some point, and if you want to allow the police to fight that you have to allow money to be tracked. You don't get both options. I think making money untraced is not useful, and instead, we should be fighting for a government that is free enough to allow your entirely tracked transactions to do what you want. Buying some drugs or sex? Whatever, just pay your sales tax. The government knows what you do, that's the modern reality, so build a government that allows you to do things that don't harm others.
- kingkawn 4y agoCrypto is not a good option for anything, as it’s lack of irl uses other than Ponzi schemes make clear.
- jrm4 4y agoThis is a weird and easily disprovable objection. The numbers are not as high as the scammers for sure, but there are a not-insignificant amount of people using crypto to move real money for its exact intended purposes today.
- thehappypm 4y agoIt’s really good for crime.
- x86x87 4y agoYou know what is also good for crime? Dollars! Everyone takes then. Even worse they are harder to trace. Do you see anyone wanting to ban the dollar or claim that it's good for crime?
- thehappypm 4y agoMaybe I should have been more specific: cyber-crime. Ransomware is a perfect use case for crypto.
- x86x87 4y agoYes! CYBERcrime! Those criminals are so dumb that they cannot figure out how to ask for money any other way. Let's cherrypick one thing and throw the baby out with the bathwater. Also CC fraud that impacts all of us is done using crypto. Silly me.
- thehappypm 4y agoYou seem passionate about crypto. What real non-illegal use cases interest you?
- TheCowboy 4y agoMind explaining why you think this? It seems like a public database isn't a good use case for something so stigmatized.
- roenxi 4y agoThey could use one of the private ones.
- mschuster91 4y agoCrypto is even worse, for both customers and sex workers. A wad of cash is virtually untrackable and can be protected, crypto asset flows are by definition completely public, and the government already has the tools (both legal frameworks and the technology) to associate crypto accounts with identities.
- ChadNauseam 4y agomonero and tornado cash are crypto, but payment flows through them are pretty difficult to trace.
- mschuster91 4y agoMoney in, money out. The US government most definitely has the capability to do correlation tracking, not to mention you will have to exchange any kind of token into ye olde fiat currency at some point, which can and will be tracked. As for Tornado Cash, anything that passes (or passed!) through mixers can be tracked and sanctioned as well. In case of doubt, always assume that the US government has an ability to at least collect all traces of data, and that sooner or later it will make itself an opportunity to, as TC proved even retroactively, seize your assets or make them worthless with the stroke of a pen on a court order. And to make it worse, unlike a wad of cash that you can construct a reasonable parallel way on how you acquired it, you are automatically committing a crime by interacting with a sanctioned entity like TC. Sex workers have already precarious lives as it is, there is no reason to entice them to even more risks.
- fulafel 4y agoIt not the case that cryptocurrency flows are necessarily public, it's just a typical feature of blockchain based cryptocurrencies.
- mellavora 4y agoWait-- you are saying that crypto is a good option to avoid financial regulations. the regulators might view that as criminal.
- throwing_away 4y agoThere's two things in play here: * What the law allows * What the payment processors allow Some industries, like sex work and cannabis sales, can be both legal and rejected by payment processors. The law says they're legal in some places, and local authorities agree. But payment processors still want to protect themselves and their investors, so they decline to do business with such industries. The moral hazard in this case is not that crypto may be used to avoid regulations. The hazard is that a handful of private companies serve as de facto regulator and enforcers for all commerce. You can tell it's a hazard because some people view any alternative payment system as possibly illegal. You may think crypto should be criminal, but cash should be legal, based on the average age of this forum. But the younger generation has only ever used cash for illegal transactions, and there should be no surprise that governments would prefer a cashless society. If you believe that crypto, cash, gold, and any other non-banking solution for payment remittance is likely to be viewed as criminal by regulators, then I have to wonder who the regulators are really protecting.