3 ms·
And for "all" that we can throw at this kind of program it should be pointed out that perhaps nothing of interest might happen until it scales to energy levels
by defrost 4y ago
And for "all" that we can throw at this kind of program it should be pointed out that perhaps nothing of interest might happen until it scales to energy levels of several of our suns with observations over a scale a little longer than human evolution .. still barely a scratch on the breadth and depth of the universe.
- DocTomoe 4y agoThat's the crux with all kinds of fundamental research, isn't it? Everyone considers it a basically useless wild goose change until sometimes, something comes along that completely restructures our understanding of the universe. I wonder if people made the same argument against funding of research in nuclear fission...
- ogogmad 4y agoThe parent comment is saying that the next scale of actually useful particle colliders might be outside of practical reach. Note that by "useful", I mean capable of discovering new physics. His comment is therefore in agreement with Sabine, and not with yours.
- defrost 4y agoUSofA nuclear physcists certainly made such an argument against pursuing the development of nuclear fission weapons, they said such things were beyond the reach of US industry in argument against the intial pleas to do so from the UK MAUD committee and a following letter from Albert Einstein. They were eventualy persuaded by an Autralian nuclear scientist acting on behalf of the Commonwealth MAUD scientists. The issue with the endless(?) chase after ever more exotic particles is that every iteration levels up by some magnitude of effort, where nuclear fission weapons were once ( just out of | just within ) reach and subject to furious debate is more the case that ever fresh exotic particles expontentially escalate beyond actual resources. Once we ring the circumference of the planet and use all the PetaWatts we can currently generate .. what next? It'll take a while to level up to smashing suns together .. with no guarentee the rabbit hole is halfway plumbed.
- fjfaase 4y agoIt could even be that there is nothing new to be found no matter how high the energy gets. But even more fundamentally, she seem to worry about the fact that there are currently no urgent 'holes' that require you to invent new particles. She points out that the method of inventing new particle that worked so well in the past, no longer seems reasonable, but that nevertheless, the high-energy physists stick to it out of tradition. It seems that the field of high-energy physists have become an incrowd that only continues to exist because everybody pads eachothers shoulders and that people on the outside believe that something must be true about it. It sounds as if she as a person is critized (and not her ideas) primarily because of her pointing this out.