3 ms·
This is a story about a classic software supply chain attack, and relevant given today's events. The US got the USSR to run modified software that caused pipel
by hedora 4y ago
This is a story about a classic software supply chain attack, and relevant given today's events. The US got the USSR to run modified software that caused pipeline to run over pressure, causing simultaneous ruptures.
Nord Stream 1 and 2 failed in a similar way. I wonder if it could have been a software attack, and what sort of resources would have been required.
- anigbrowl 4y agoVery good find, and reminiscent of Stuxnet. One of the architects of this scheme wrote about it for the CIA's internal 'trade journal', which article has since been declassified. It adds an interesting additional dimension. This is very old-fashioned classic spycraft in some respects, but I'm surprised and impressed that the idea of a slow-burning software fuse was deployed so early. https://www.cia.gov/static/887689795bd91ed08ca926a2f6278ee4/The-Farewell-Dossier.pdf https://www.cia.gov/static/887689795bd91ed08ca926a2f6278ee4/...
- Test0129 4y agoI'd imagine an explosion of the size measured by scientists wouldn't have been caused by running overpressure. I can't find the article at the moment but I recall it being equivalent of some undersea depth charges. Those aren't normal-grade pipes underwater. They are concrete reinforced. Unless something ignited the gas then I have a hard time believing it was a software attack. Those pipes are usually purged of oxygen as well meaning ignition would be...surprising. Moreover I've been reading that the pipes were empty anyway. Do they keep those pipe pressurized all the time? Whoever did it most likely used an explosive by my estimation. Special forces dive teams are capable of the depths needed and wouldn't be detected by submarine searches. Further, it would make no sense for the US to sabotage the pipeline because the LNG supply chain from the US to Europe is by boat. Frankly I wouldn't be shocked if Russia did this to declare a sort of "official" separation. A false flag is possible too just given the situation Europe is in I find it hard to believe NATO would do that. Usually with a false flag there is some, even seemingly inconsequential, motivation.
- Arnt 4y agohttps://nitter.it/BergAslak/status/1574694467197579264#m https://nitter.it/BergAslak/status/1574694467197579264#m If natural gas from Norway is disrupted, all bets are off.
- gruez 4y agoSeems sort of expensive to bomb your own pipeline just to send a message that you can bomb pipelines.
- xg15 4y agoI do think there is some motivation for the US or another western state having done it: The situation in Europe is far from stable and it might be possible that our strategies for the winter are not sufficient and we'll experience shortages or outages. In that situation, politicians may come under extreme pressure to reopen the pipelines. This might have been an preventive "intervention" to make such a "relapse" impossible. Of course it might just as well have been a russian false flag with exactly the aim of strengthening the "the US is secretly controlling Europe" narrative.
- gruez 4y ago>Special forces dive teams are capable of the depths needed and wouldn't be detected by submarine searches. Why would there be submarine searches? Are these pipelines patrolled 24/7 by submarines? >Further, it would make no sense for the US to sabotage the pipeline because the LNG supply chain from the US to Europe is by boat. I don't follow the logic here. Presumably the US's motive is to disrupt europe's gas supply from russia, so russia can't use it as a bargaining chip. I don't see how the US -> europe gas supply being LNG contradicts this.
- Test0129 4y agoUs -> Europe gas supply is LNG via boat. It can take up to a month to deliver something like that from the US to the shores of the UK/France/etc. Then distribution needs to occur. Yes, the US can profit HUGELY off this but it seems stupid to hurt their ally considerably for the sake of stopping bargaining (which may avoid a world war). Given that the US can't supply immediate relief the profit over winter is severely limited and Europeans will suffer even with the shipments. I just can't see the US doing such a thing because it would certainly mean being driven out of NATO, and potentially Europe going to war with the US.
- xg15 4y agoDoesn't seem very comparable to me though. The original supply chain attack was to supply a manipulated control software which changed turbine and valve configurations so that the pipeline was running with unsafe levels of pressure. Eventually the pressure was too much and the line burst. The manipulations were subtle enough that personnel couldn't easily distinguish them from normal operation - which is why the attack went undetected until the explosion happened. In the current case however, the pipeline was already shut down and the pressure levels where monitored on the european side (and probably on the russian side too). A cyberattack would have to turn the turbines back on while also rigging the monitoring stations on both sides in such a way that everyone still believes the pipeline is off. (And hope no one physically present at the stations wonders why turbines for a pipeline that's supposed to be off are running at full speed) I think Ockham's razor would favourite the submarine hypothesis here :)
- rurban 4y agoThe pressure level was still 150 bar, which is insanely high for such a long and wide tube. So I would not rule it out. "Under pressure" could just be 5 bar to keep it at a sane level.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoWow a lot was made of the Natanz Stuxnet attack as the first ever major cyberattack as a military weapon. I just read a book that questioned the risks to society after these 'new' types of weapons. I had no idea that it was predated by this by decades. It looks like it's pretty recently released information too. In 1982 the only 'computer'-like electronics most people would have had would have been a Nintendo Game & Watch. Even 8-bit home computers were only just emerging. Pretty eye-opening history lesson for me.