8 ms·
For historical reasons, ACH is approximately as fast as airmailing someone money. When all the stars line up correctly, it is as fast as Fedexing money. Credi
by patio11 15y ago
For historical reasons, ACH is approximately as fast as airmailing someone money. When all the stars line up correctly, it is as fast as Fedexing money. Credit cards are like emailing money (and Paypal was, very explicitly,about emailing money). Dwolla is based on ACH.
There's probably a lot that can be done with cheap, user-friendly ACH in an API, but I don't know if folks really understand the "Your transaction takes 100 hours to settle" bit.
- djb_hackernews 15y agoIsn't that the problem Dwolla is really trying to solve? Making ACH much quicker than it is now?
- praxeologist 15y agoI think so. I know they have a "big announcement" in 15 days, so I expect it to be related to this. Previously there has been some news about a service I think was called "CU link" where credit unions can offer Dwolla as a sort of service and the ACH is accelerated. I sent an email to my CU bugging them to get this and they gave me an answer like, "we pay attention to what is going on". My CU has some sort of ties to Members Group and I use Dwolla for online payments so my fingers are crossed.
- wmf 15y agoBut Dwolla is not in a position to either fix or replace the ACH system.
- djb_hackernews 15y agoI see differently. They have a good sized network of credit unions as guinea pigs and are already masters of ACH.
- Tuna-Fish 15y ago> But Dwolla is not in a position to either fix or replace the ACH system. On the contrary, based on the little PR that they have made, I feel that replacing the ACH system is their primary desired endgame. They are actively selling their payment network as an alternative to ACH for their member institutions.
- pitdesi 15y agoYup. Further complicating things, ACH isn't truly settled for a 6 months! ACH's can be charged back for 180 days and there is no adjudication process, like with credit cards. If an ACH gets charged back, you lose the money, that's it. The other major complication with ACH is that most Americans use credit cards for the credit (70% hold a balance). That is something that won't be solved. Others like the benefit of rewards (miles, dollars, whatever). To get payers on board, you need credit, rewards, and exclusivity (i.e. is this the only payment method available at somewhere where I want to shop). The last 2 meaningful companies were paypal and discover card. PayPal had millions of Ebay sellers using PayPal AND they initially paid people to become members. Discover card started the cashback movement and was the only electronic payment option at Sears (largest retailer in the world at the time). More details and discussion in a previous article: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3238880 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3238880 ACH's are essentially free - there are some costs but Dwolla is part-owned by a credit union which probably helps lower the costs. They have major fraud-related costs, but given that fraud under $10 should be very small, their costs aren't much
- thinkcomp 15y agoDwolla is not part-owned by a credit union. It has an investor that has credit unions as customers. From what I can tell, the company has encouraged this false impression to escape regulatory scrutiny. ACH is also not free.
- torontos 15y agoIt seems quite clear in multiple locations that Dwolla does in fact have a credit union as an investor, what is your source that it doesn't? http://www.chubbybrain.com/companies/dwolla/investors-funding-history#axzz1fJOFMKdl http://www.chubbybrain.com/companies/dwolla/investors-fundin... https://www.veridiancu.org/ https://www.veridiancu.org/ http://kb.veridiancu.org/veridiancu/consumer/kbdetail.asp?kbid=8830&SearchType=advanced&status=&rfield=&sortmethod=datemodified&usertype=&formaction=search&subcats=True&start=1&match=or&catid=58 http://kb.veridiancu.org/veridiancu/consumer/kbdetail.asp?kb...
- noahc 15y agoI think they try to get around this by allowing you to 'preload' your account. What they've built is an electronic checking account. I only write checks to pay my rent and I don't carry cash. If I had to get cash, I couldn't. I don't know the pin numbers to my debt or credit cards. This is something I would use if I knew more people accepted it and I didn't have to divide transactions between a credit card and this. I'd miss the cash back on the CC side though.
- mixmastamyk 15y agoCCs are convenient but the dark side is that every transaction you make is being recorded, with a certain probability of being held against you at some point in the future.
- wiredfool 15y agoNACHA records are held for 7 years.
- puredanger 15y agoI organize conferences (Strange Loop, Clojure/West). I pay at least $10 per person in credit card fees (multiply by 500-1000 people). Personally, having the transaction clear a few hours later is hugely unimportant to me vs paying $10 less per transaction.
- jrockway 15y agoBut aren't most of your attendees traveling on their company's dime, meaning they need to use their corporate credit card in order to pay? If so, this wouldn't work.
- smackfu 15y agoIn fact, American Express's big market share in the corporate card market is the main reason it is accepted anywhere, given its higher merchant fees.
- djb_hackernews 15y agoI'd imagine once they have ACH on lock they'd start issuing their own plastic.
- 1010100101 15y agoBecause it is tied to the checking system, where checks were routinely flown across the country from bank to bank before they could be settled? (Even after we had electronic systems that should make this unnecessary?)
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]