3 ms·
The best apple pies are made with crab apples. Most crab apple trees are almost inedible since they aren't bred for flavor, but there are some really good crab
by bryanlarsen 4y ago
The best apple pies are made with crab apples. Most crab apple trees are almost inedible since they aren't bred for flavor, but there are some really good crab apples out there.
Eaten raw, most crab apples are too tart even for pies, so you want to find one that are edible raw. It'll probably still be considerably tarter than a Granny Smith, but there should be great flavor behind the tartness.
Add more sugar than a normal apple pie, since you're getting less from the apple.
The resulting pie is sweet & tart & flavorful with great texture.
- bastardoperator 4y agoI have to disagree. The best apple pies use a range of apples. By adding different types of apples you add different texture and flavors to your pie. I will typically use 2-5 different types of apples and I bake apple pie all the time. I'm certainly no authority, just feedback I've gathered personally as the apple pie maker in the family. The reality is most people can cut up apples and add sugar. The hardest part is the dough, the apples might not even matter, if the crust isn't good the entire pie fails.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoI'm sure you make good pie, but have you actually tried a crab apple pie?
- giraffe_lady 4y agoThere's no botanical difference between crabapples and "normal" apples per se it's the same plant just crabapples are allowed to let the wonky apple genetics deal do its thing. So what kind of crabapple you get is just random, some taste better than anything you can buy, most are hard sour and astringent. Apples are also like this if planted from seed and left alone. And because of the size they have a higher skin-to-flesh ratio which does make them a little bitter but also more complexly flavored if you balance it out. And for the same reason they have more pectin and cook up thicker, which is good for pies once you account for it and ideal for jams. So yeah overall I agree, people should taste the crabapples around them and see what they can score. It's one of the most easy/fun/accessible/practical intros to urban foraging for sure.