2 ms·
Not exactly on topic, but a good moment to think - are mortgages even fundamentally desirable? The price of a house is always going to be exactly savings + mort
by roenxi 4y ago
Not exactly on topic, but a good moment to think - are mortgages even fundamentally desirable? The price of a house is always going to be exactly savings + mortgage, if nobody was taking out mortgages the prices would adjust and people would end up in the same house as before.
It is interesting to ask if mortgages should be rare. It isn't obvious why everyone needs to pledge years of their life to the wealthy in order to own a home. I can imagine alternative scenarios where I own a home without agreeing to give large amount of money to bank shareholders.
Mortgages are the entry point to a world of debt that doesn't make sense. The market keeps trying to draw down debt with financial crisis after crisis and the people in control of the monetary system keep making sure it comes back.
- the_mitsuhiko 4y agoFor as long as society thinks home ownership is fundamentally desirable so will be mortgages as most people won't be able to afford a place otherwise. Generally speaking life is so fast and unpredictable for people, that home ownership for many is probably individually a lifestyle choice but a fundamental risk. So I think if you want to question mortgages, it's better to question the entire idea of everybody being forced into home ownership.
- roenxi 4y ago> For as long as society thinks home ownership is fundamentally desirable so will be mortgages as most people won't be able to afford a place otherwise. Why not? Who do you think would end up owning the houses & how would you expect the market to be structured? Why, fundamentally, would it look much different from today?
- sph 4y ago> For as long as society thinks home ownership is fundamentally desirable I'm in favour of challenging that assumption only iff we make private renting illegal. No one except the public (i.e. the state) should be able to extract payment upon the unlucky masses that do not have or can't afford their own home.
- justsomehnguy 4y ago> taking out mortgages the prices would adjust and people would end up in the same house as before You already can end up in the same house as before without mortgage. Just 20 years later (and in a 20 years older house).