6 ms·
Tim Cook: 'No good excuse' for lack of women in tech
- theandrewbailey 4y agoThere's no good excuse for the lack of women bricklayers, plumbers, mechanics, and loggers, but no one's worried about that.
- nathanaldensr 4y agoRight. Who would've thought that different people have different preferences? Why this insane push to try and treat all people as fungible economic units? (I already know the answer)
- olliej 4y ago..because women are specifically paid less for the same job? equivalently qualified women applicants are more likely to be skipped, and when they do get offered they are given less favorable terms. No one is _forcing_ women to enter tech, the issue is that if a woman does want to have a tech job it is harder for them to enter the industry, and they get lower compensation for the same job. This has been found across every single study of the industry. To believe that there isn't a significant problem with sexism and gender oriented harassment in tech is delusional at best.
- trafficante 4y ago> This has been found across every single study of the industry. Would be highly interested in a link to one of these. Specifically one that directly tackles the “less pay for the same job with the same hours” issue.
- olliej 4y ago
- _-david-_ 4y ago>because women are specifically paid less for the same job? Not true when looking at education level, continuous years of job experience, hours worked, etc. When you take those into consideration women make comparable income.
- Ekaros 4y agoOnly difference between same work I have heard is that men push harder in negotiations. But I think that explains rather small difference. Otherwise the compensation is pretty much the same. And likely desirability of minorities is used as leverage too, but without asking.
- xupybd 4y ago> .because women are specifically paid less for the same job? That seems to be changing. https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20220415-why-young-women-earn-more-than-men-in-some-us-cities https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20220415-why-young-wome... >To believe that there isn't a significant problem with sexism and gender oriented harassment in tech is delusional at best. I don't think anyone is arguing that... I think the point is there are more significant factors such as gender based preferences.
- AnnoyedComment 4y ago
- randomdata 4y ago> and they get lower compensation for the same job. Okay, so let's assume that instead of $250,000 per year that a male makes they are offered $200,000 per year for being female. In response they choose a $50,000 per year job in healthcare instead?
- Traubenfuchs 4y ago> In response they choose a $50,000 per year job in healthcare instead? …where they‘d also get paid less than men, if you want to continue the paygap meme.
- randomdata 4y agoWhich suggests that pay disparity isn't the source of their decision making. After all, if they are simply trying to spite tech for not paying them as much as men doing the same job then they would do the same in healthcare where you indicate men are also paid more.
- olliej 4y agoThey are, it's just that the place where you can look at objective and comparable data (graduation vs job offers, salaries, terms for initial offers, etc) at scale is business, tech, etc and other similar industries. For press coverage it's also a matter of what the big industries of the era are. Currently it's tech, in the 80s it was things like the mining companies - Apple is also one of the single largest companies in the world so when its CEO says something that's always going to get press coverage.
- kiwih 4y agoTired argument, redirecting the topic. It's possible for more than one thing to be inequal at once. Also, the National Association for Women in Construction [0] and the women in auto care organization [1] would disagree on your first points. Lumberjacks slightly different, but even there I've found axewomen which is an organization/family promoting female lumberjacks (lumberjills as they call them) as a career [2]. [0] https://www.nawic.org/ https://www.nawic.org/ [1] https://www.autocare.org/networking-and-development/communities/women-in-auto-care https://www.autocare.org/networking-and-development/communit... [2] http://axewomen.com/index.html http://axewomen.com/index.html
- mixmastamyk 4y agoBuddy of mine just got his RN, was one guy in a class of 30.
- ksaj 4y agoAnd the same thing occurs in teachers college.
- isitmadeofglass 4y agoApple is not a bricklaying or plumbing company…
- dragonwriter 4y ago> There’s no good excuse for the lack of women bricklayers, plumbers, mechanics, and loggers, but no one’s worried about that. Yes, actually, people are worried about that even if people whose attention is more focused on tech may not see it as much: https://www.constructionnews.co.uk/agenda/inspire-me/percentage-of-women-in-skilled-trades-shows-little-change-in-a-decade-18-03-2022/ https://www.constructionnews.co.uk/agenda/inspire-me/percent... https://www.theguardian.com/careers/careers-blog/2015/may/19/where-are-all-the-women-why-99-of-construction-site-workers-are-male https://www.theguardian.com/careers/careers-blog/2015/may/19... Etc.
- Ekaros 4y agoDoes the USA army have 50-50 split in combat roles? Shouldn't they aim for that by forcing enough females there so that eventually those can build career and enter officer ranks with 50-50 split too?
- jmpman 4y agoThere’s no good excuse for lack of women in tech in their freshman year of college. But the reason there’s fewer women in tech in their sophomore year in college can be traced to the number of women in tech in their freshman year of college… keep working backwards through the pipeline. The problem I see with programs like First Robotics is that the female participants I’ve interacted with are typically children of female engineers. It doesn’t seem that they’re dramatically increasing the funnel to pull in female engineers who wouldn’t have normally gone on to the STEM fields. Start surveying Jr High female students?
- olliej 4y ago> There’s no good excuse for lack of women in tech in their freshman year of college. Have you seen how woman in CS departments are treated? The amazing amounts of creeper behaviour and stereotypical nerd crush BS? Those are actually really good reasons for not being in those departments. There's also the standard roll model and ability to look at what research groups look like that act as good signals to anyone starting out that they aren't welcome.
- Siddarth1977 4y agoI've seen this claimed online, generally by people with no actual connection to university CS programs who are just repeating what they read on Tumblr/Twitter/etc, but I've never witnessed it in real life. Sometimes I wonder how much faster we could end the gender gap if instead of giving a megaphone to everyone who had a bad experience at some point, we instead told girls in middle school and high school the uncomfortable good news that they'll probably never have discrimination impact them in any significant way and that literally every single school, scholarship, corporation, conference and governmental organization is trying to recruit more women, and that their resume will always go immediately to the top of the pile, they'll win every "tie" against a male candidate and any deficiencies in their resume/CV can be made up for by diversity goals. If you want more women in tech, maybe step 1 is telling pre-college girls "you'll have a good life if you pursue a career in tech" instead of constantly indoctrinating them with the doom and gloom? It seems like we could simultaneously fight against sexism if it happens around us, without discouraging the next generation by making the problem seem more likely to impact them than it really is.
- ohiovr 4y agoI was thinking that there is a strange lack of Women composers and conductors. Tons of women virtuoso musicians, and quite a few song writers. But movie scoring??
- ksaj 4y agoI googled "female classical composer" and was blown away at how many there are. A lot. BUT other than the first two being married to male classical composers everybody has heard of in modern times, you'll probably never learn anything about any of the rest of them in music class at school. Or anywhere else unless you look specifically for them. So they do exist. They're just hidden from view.
- ohiovr 4y agoI'm going to find some of these compositions and try it on my new product called "Scott's Music Box" which is a a full orchestral suite renderer.
- ohiovr 4y agoThey do indeed! Have a listen to Clara Schumann: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zWvnznUFagY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zWvnznUFagY
- learn-forever 4y agoI'm with you Tim, I've tried yelling "THERE IS NO EXCUSE FOR YOU TO NOT BE IN TECH" at every woman I've encountered for the last ten years but they just aren't joining the ranks
- Proven 4y ago
- Slava_Propanei 4y ago
- bergenty 4y agoThere is a good reason. In countries with genuine gender equality women naturally gravitate to certain fields and tech isn’t one of them. It’s probably biology but we can’t be certain.
- AnnoyedComment 4y ago
- theonemind 4y agoI think it takes a kind of ideology-fueled willed self-ignorance to ignore that men and women have different aptitudes and preferences and to completely neglect it as an explanatory factor. Men clearly have a greater affinity for systems than women, women clearly have a greater affinity for people and living things, although one shouldn't exaggerate it to caricature and dichotomizing. Additionally, men have a higher variance on intelligence, which means that you will have more very smart men at the cost of having more very dumb men, and so you have two barriers that more men that women will tend to get across--a high intelligence floor compared to many professions, and an affinity for systems over people. The caricature statement to avoid there is "men are smarter than women"--not the case, only that it seems like you'll get a larger pool inclined to the profession out of men by the way the distribution of intelligence works. Not that rolling the latest CRUD app is rocket science, mind you, but it'd be silly to pretend that intelligence doesn't make a difference, and that intelligence distribution doesn't make a difference with sex concentration in the field.
- strikelaserclaw 4y agoin 20-30 years we can tell if it is nature or nurture.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tobbob 4y agoWhy do women need an excuse? We have free will, we can all pursue the careers we choose.
- Pinegulf 4y agoI've been involved in few recruiting processes for tech field. For whatever reason number of male applicants vastly outnumbered female ones.
- ksec 4y agoIf this was submitted during US working hours it would have a huge discussion on the topic.
- dusted 4y agoI don't even think we there need to be an excuse for the fact that there are less X in Y.. Maybe an explanation would suffice? My pov, not that it matters: I went to public school, roughly 50% of what looked superficially to be female (these days, you must not assume). We had LAN parties in our spare time, no girls, they were invited, they were told about it, they didn't think sitting up all night in front of a computer sounded like a good time, fine, whatever. After public school ended I went straight on to technical college, first day: 0 people who didn't somewhat resemble the male gender, at least superficially. There were no events in between, no females or female-like people ever applied. Third school experience (university college) was the same, only female interaction outside the secretariat was one of the teachers. No females ever applied. They weren't rejected, excluded or harassed or anything, they simply were never there to begin with. It's almost as if the females chose to do something else..
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoExactly my experience - Elementary school roughly 50% of girls - High School / Vocational school (electronic engineering) 0% of girls - University 1 girl in the class of 50, so 2% of girls. Thus nobody can expect to have 50% of girls at the job life, when high school and college were complete sausage party. On the other hand, things like teaching (pedagogic universities) and nursing (medical schools) are almost always only girls.
- Ekaros 4y agoI feel that only reason tech is called out is that it is seen as clean and very high paying thus desirable field. As there is lot less discussion of more traditional gendered-fields from construction, war, nursing and so on.