7 ms·
Feelings of guilt may signal leadership potential (2012)
- bingu 4y agoThe problem is that people with a lack of guilt are the ones who usually end up in leadership positions.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoEmpathy deficiency and psychopathic tendencies seem to be strong enablers of rapid management ascent. https://www.sakkyndig.com/psykologi/artvit/babiak2010.pdf https://www.sakkyndig.com/psykologi/artvit/babiak2010.pdf https://hbr.org/2015/09/empathy-is-still-lacking-in-the-leaders-who-need-it-most https://hbr.org/2015/09/empathy-is-still-lacking-in-the-lead... https://hbr.org/2015/04/becoming-powerful-makes-you-less-empathetic https://hbr.org/2015/04/becoming-powerful-makes-you-less-emp...
- TheSpiceIsLife 4y agoAll virtuous people / groups are swiftly overrun by those who would act in their own interest. This has been going on for at least some time, and likely confers at least some evolutionary advantage.
- jamesgreenleaf 4y ago"The behavior of any bureaucratic organization can best be understood by assuming that it is controlled by a secret cabal of its enemies."
- diordiderot 4y agoWho said this? It's hilarious
- maze-le 4y agoRobert Conquest, a British historian specialized in the history of the Soviet Union.
- Bakary 4y agoWhere do you think 'virtue' comes from, and why do you think we value it? It's an evolutionary advantage like any other.
- TheSpiceIsLife 4y agoThat's a good point. Virtuosity tends to extend less than self-interest, which seems to be approximately boundless. Having said that, I guess ones perspective on that particular duality is Hugo influenced by ones mood in any given moment ;)
- Bakary 4y agoLooking at this from another angle: even though our self-interest is strong, we live the majority of our lives under social rules that promote virtue (or rather, virtue is defined by the social rules). The number of humans who can actually pursue their self-interest in any real way is limited. Most of us have to work for many years, and surrender most of our lives to the broader world. In fact, true psychopaths never seem to occupy more than 1% of the population. They are the self-interest pros because they do not feel fear or stress the same way we do and can make the most of it. But at the same time they find themselves limited by society even if a few of them succeed enormously. All this to say, I'm not sure virtue is that limited. These are competing forces that have reached an equilibrium but most of the fabric of our lives IS virtuous.
- ericmcer 4y agoI remember my first boss who is now a higher up at >100 person company used to pick his nose just blatantly while talking to you. I had a number of interpretations of it lol.
- bigDinosaur 4y agoReminiscent of LBJ dictating to aides while on the toilet. A power play.
- mushufasa 4y agoHe was a busy guy
- gernb 4y agoI don't know really anything about LBJ but different people come from different backgrounds. My father was raised that it was not important to close the door while pooping and he didn't. It wasn't a power play. It was just normal to him. Both his parents did it.
- bigDinosaur 4y agoIf you don't like something, but tolerate someone doing it because they're your manager, then it's really a manifestation of power whether or not that manager is aware of it. The alternative between equals is that they either viscerally disagree or they decide to not associate with each other.
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y agoOr they tolerate it. I have a friend who breathes heavily when he eats. I fucking hate it. But he's been my friend since I was 16 (I'm now over 40). Is my friend exhibiting a power play, am I being subservient, or is it just two humans getting along with each other? Not everything is power politics.
- michaelwww 4y agopsychopaths are in a class by themselves and only a small percentage thank goodness
- sethammons 4y agoWhy "thank goodness?"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ycombinete 4y agoI strongly suspect that this is based on the size of the company. I've seen this over the shoulder of my corporate friends; but in small companies I think these kinds of people have a harder time hiding their negative attributes.
- leaflets2 4y agoYes, and for countries too: most large countries are controlled by psychopaths, eg Putin, Xi, Erdagon, Bolsonaro, Trump if the coup had succeeded (maybe next time). Whilst smaller countries are more often somewhat well functioning democracies. The more layers of power one has to climb to get to the top, the more beneficial it is to "be able to" happily manipulate, step on and destroy others
- Herodotus38 4y agoI can identify with this article. It also reminded me of this post from last month which did a deep dive into shame (and how it’s different than guilt). It’s a long read but worth it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32497194 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32497194 I am in healthcare and never wanted to be in administration. For complicated reasons, I keep getting more leadership responsibilities even though I typically think of myself as conflict avoidant. I do pride myself as being a role model for helping people and “taking the extra step” to help people when it may be something others would delegate. I think in my case it more has to due with lack of competition and such but I definitely fit the bill for someone who feels guilt. I can see also how guilt that is felt with respect to the entire group can lead to decisions that are better for the group (but may cost an individual more).
- Aloha 4y agoBeing conflict avoidant is a great way to get into leadership. People like pleasant people.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoThis sounds like a study that wouldn’t replicate.
- TotoHorner 4y agohilariously poorly constructed study + confirms your initial priors = tons of media attention.
- chadlavi 4y agowow turns out I'm an excellent leader
- eyelidlessness 4y agoThe guilt/shame distinction is good. I’m hardly a leader in any sense that scales and I have very few illusions that’s gonna change, but I definitely recognize I’m more fit for the role of making decisions when I take my responsibility personally rather than taking my perceived or real failures personally. It’s been hard for me to learn and even hard to navigate in the past day. But I’m much better for regretting my failures and seeking to correct them, when I’m focused on how I could have been better helping and serving the people around me, than when I’m licking my wounds after I didn’t serve myself well.
- tootie 4y agoAs a guilt-prone leader this rings true. I think company leadership tends to be a mix of these types and the shameless users who know how to capitalize on people like me.
- michaelwww 4y ago> “Guilt-prone people tend to carry a strong sense of responsibility to others, and that responsibility makes other people see them as leaders,” > Although “guilt” and “shame” may seem quite similar to most people... Whereas someone who feels guilty feels bad about a specific mistake and wants to make amends, a person who’s ashamed of a mistake feels bad about himself or herself and shrinks away from the error. Both of these make so much sense to me that I'm surprised I didn't think of them before. People tell you not to take care of other people ("mind your business") but it seems that an appropriate amount of that is a great strength.
- germinalphrase 4y agoI've also heard it phrased: guilt is felt when you don't live up to your own expectations while shame is felt when you don't live up to the expectations of others.
- rootw0rm 4y agoAn even simpler way to think of it, based on a TED talk I saw (sorry, can't think of who she was ATM): guilt = i did something bad, shame = i am bad Guilt can therefore be considered necessary for self-improvement, whereas shame just doesn't do anybody any good. edit: It was a talk by Brené Brown, not sure which one
- 6stringmerc 4y agoThis is a constructive way to split them I think - also what helped me was the notion of “good” and “bad” being smoothed out by a counselor years ago who helped a lot. We make so many inconsequential decisions in a day and week and month that sometimes it’s just big picture reactionary. No good or bad in what type of sandwich, or where to get gas, which leaves time to think about goals (ex: make time to exercise). Also on a long enough timeline what was a good choice at the time can later take on negative association due to circumstances, and occasionally there’s no right answer in the first place. Just takes making a decision other than to stay put.
- anonymouse008 4y agoThis study uses one behavior 'guilt' to correlate to a sense of duty to others, as it appears to be the differentiator between guilt and shame - and to that end, I accept and agree. However, I believe there is a misconception with the shared definition of guilt in some cultures - one that followed me in the circles of SV I knew, playfully called "Catholic Guilt." I've come to learn what the true driver of 'the guilt' is, and it has helped me in my leadership in profound ways. The heart of the misconception from others is that the ultimate perfection of 'guilt' is martyrdom. In the SV circles I ran I exhibited such through the seeking of reducing oneself to elevate others. And so without the keel in knowing the origins of one's beliefs, one can easily adorn that alternative definition as truth, as I did. -- Forewarning: this gets religious, but it is only to help those who have experienced the same things I have. There is no 'best religion' or teaching insulated below, for I, too, am still a fool. This is just one humble person's perspective -- To those who feel that an ultimate sacrifice is martyrdom, I would direct you to read the Passion from the Gospel of John. In the time of Christ's death, only one apostle remained with Christ at the foot of the cross - the apostle John. To those who know the story, John is the disciple to whom Jesus references to Mary when saying, 'woman behold your son.' What becomes interesting about John, in addition to the sole apostle in attendance at the crucifixion, is that he did not suffer martyrdom as all other apostles did. So perhaps interpreting guilt as a symptom of not honoring the ultimate sacrifice, is the correct orientation. Meaning that Honor, if allowed to be defined as duty over self, is the desired 'behavior,' sought in this study and to be lived in all aspects of life as a 'Christian.' And to reduce one's guilt through the pursuit of Honor, rather than desensitization and liberation of 'the guilt,' is what one needs to plainly emphasize. In my experience, it sheds the air of 'Catholic Guilt' over those misunderstood actions in a fortifying way.
- schubart 4y agoWhat does "SV" stand for?
- GameOfFrowns 4y ago"Silicon Valley" most likely.
- 4y ago
- travisgriggs 4y agoBow down to your supreme leader fellow HN’ers. If HN karma points were guilt points, you’d all elect me in an instant.
- AceyMan 4y agopaper from 2012, fwiw
- thejackgoode 4y agoThe longer I live, the more it seems that no extreme behavior, "good" or "bad", is possible without a preceding crushing trauma. It's the supercompensators that will get us to Mars, folks.
- TheFattestNinja 4y agoSometimes you have to Suffer a little in your youth To motivate yourself To succeed in later life Do you think if Bill Gates Got laid in high school Do you think there? d be a Microsoft? Of course not You got to spend a long time Stuffed in your own locker With your underwear Wedged up your ass before you start thinkin' ? I? m going to take of the world With computers! You'll see, I? ll show them? -underwear goes inside the pants by lazyboy
- paganel 4y agoI personally think the over-emphasis on (in the majority of cases individual) trauma is just an easy way out for society as a whole to intrinsically "forget" about its implicit "tasks", such as taking care of its constituent members. It's easier to instil in someone the feeling of "you're depressed because you have been abused as a child, and if you don't remember the abuse itself it doesn't mean it isn't there, otherwise you wouldn't have been depressed", than to solve real societal issues that are more likely causes for said depression, as I've heard almost no-one say "we'll cure mass depression by making housing more affordable or by providing free child-care".
- pessimizer 4y ago> "we'll cure mass depression by making housing more affordable or by providing free child-care". We don't have time for that, we need to hunt down potential abusers and yell "shame on you" at them in public, and get other people to yell "shame on you" at them. If we broke up the banks tomorrow, would that end racism?
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y agoAnd as a child of abuse myself, I hate these attitudes. The deed is done. You can't un-pregnant that woman, nor can you un-abuse that child. Declaring that the abuse shouldn't have happened in the first place does fuck-all for the child who has been abused.
- renewiltord 4y agoPersonally while I believe that this field has a massive replication crisis, I find studies that make me look good are really good science.
- kypro 4y agoIn an ideal world maybe. And even then it would probably be one of the least important traits in modern leadership roles. In reality I suspect it's quite hard to have high levels of guilt and be a leader. At least recognising one's mistakes and taking responsibility for them is something that doesn't tend to be rewarded in the corporate world. It's probably better to have low guilt and be better at reframing mistakes as small set backs. To not do this risks looking incapable. But anyway, good social skills and extraversion seems to be by far the most important traits for leadership positions. You also need to have a elevated self-confidence in your own opinions, at least this is true within a lot of corporate environments. But I guess I never really understood the leadership thing. I think it would be better to replace the whole concept of "leaders" and replace them with "orchestrators" of teams. Good "leadership" decisions in my opinion are really about good delegation and organisation of a team's resources, you shouldn't really be taking "lead" in any actual decision making, you should just "lead" the orchestration. Decision making should be done by the most equipped individuals of a team. Leadership goes wrong when a leader makes too many decisions, it doesn't really matter if they feel guilty for making a bad decision if they shouldn't have made them in the first place.
- cdaven 4y ago> Good "leadership" decisions in my opinion are really about good delegation and organisation of a team's resources, you shouldn't really be taking "lead" in any actual decision making You're not talking about leadership, you're talking about "decision-making high-ranking (?) managers in the business world". A good leader is someone who you want to follow, because you trust that they will do their best in guiding you (the team) towards your goal. Wouldn't you rather follow someone who would feel bad/guilty for letting the team down?
- kypro 4y ago> You're not talking about leadership, you're talking about "decision-making high-ranking (?) managers in the business world". I don't think I understanding the difference. Are "high-ranking managers" not classed as "leaders"? Could you give me an example of a leader as you understand it? > A good leader is someone who you want to follow, because you trust that they will do their best in guiding you (the team) towards your goal. I guess I don't want to follow anyone? I just want be able to have input where I am able to offer value. Similarly when I'm in leadership positions, I don't want to dictate, I want to understand how we as a team can make the best decisions. Sometimes I might be the best person to make a decision, but that's rare, and even then I still want to confirm my decisions with my team to ensure everyone approves and understands the decisions being made. I think seeking approval is both an important step to getting the team onboard and receiving any needed feedback. Any "leader" who didn't do this would be a bad leader in my opinion. This is often where I see things go wrong at companies, if I as an expert in some field object to what I or someone else is being told to do and I'm overridden without a very good explanation that gives me red flags. I'm INTP though and we tend to struggle with hierarchies. I find it hard to believe that people are best utilised as unopinionated "followers" of all-knowing leaders, but I suppose I would think that given my personality. > Wouldn't you rather follow someone who would feel bad/guilty for letting the team down? Well yeah, but I'd also feel annoyed that this person let the team down if the decision could have been made better as a team. If a single person is accepting guilt for an entire team then something is probably wrong. Ideally I'd want the team to be feeling guilty, because I'd argue it's the team as a whole that should have been responsible. I know as a team member I always take fall responsibility for mistakes made and would never delegate my guilt to my manager. I could have always have done more. We all can.
- motohagiography 4y agoWhen people ask, I describe leadership as the effect of being followed. The way you become followed is by having clarity of vision and direction. That clarity of vision and direction tends to be a moralized intention. Someone who "feels guilt" (a really coarse interpretation) could fall into the set of people oriented in a moralized direction, but guilt is neither sufficient or necessary to lead. Leadership, that is - to be followed willingly - is an effect of having moral clarity about where you are going, and then taking others there with you. Someone without moral clarity about their direction can manage, judge, be an authority figure, drive change, govern, influence, and lots of other means of using power invested in them, but they are using the reflected clarity of the authority that invested them with their powers, and they are not the origin of that moral clarity like someone with first hand knowledge, competence, or physical experience. This natural leadership doesn't always prevail either, and it's even not always ethical, but if you want to talk about leadership, it's not something that can be faked until you make it or affected for very long, as it's the effect of being followed willingly. You are followed, or you aren't.