8 ms·
Stop overcomplicating it: A simple guidebook to upping your management game
- 972811 4y ago
- leetrout 4y agoTwo things stand out to me: 1. I have had a string of bad managers at both good and bad companies. 2. I want to set direction and work with people but I do not want to be a line manager. Now I need to figure out how to find somewhere with good leadership that will invest in me growing the way I am interested in growing building teams instead of tech or I need to build my own company the way I want it to be where people are first and the tech is second. No smart jerks, etc etc.
- dubcee349 4y agoBecome a SR IC at FAANG. You get to set direction and work with people but don't have to manage them.
- hn_go_brrrrr 4y agoExactly this. I'm TL for a large team. I get to set strategic and technical direction for our entire org and manage no one. It's fantastic. If I had more time to write code, it would be my dream job.
- higeorge13 4y agotl==tech lead, not team lead right? Yeah tech lead is a great role, assuming you have the space and freedom to actually execute a tech roadmap.
- hn_go_brrrrr 4y agoYeah, tech lead.
- 0xcoffee 4y agoWhat is SR IC
- jamesmunns 4y agoI'm guessing: "Senior Individual Contributor". It would be someone experienced, who is still responsible for technical contribution (writing code, planing architecture, etc.)
- naqeeb 4y agoWhen you interview for your next role, you should request an additional conversation with your new manager and get their thoughts on: 1. What is their philosophy on team development? (Ask for examples) 2. What is the career ladder look like? When was the last person promoted to a Sr role? In addition, you should lay out growth areas you'd like to focus on. A good manager should be able to work with you and chart a path forward. On a side note: There are other online communities to help you level up while you are in your current role. DM me for recs.
- Firmwarrior 4y agoWhat kind of growth areas do people look for anyway? I'm like 15 years into my career, and I've grown, but none of it was necessarily intentional on my part. I've mostly grown when I was faced with an insurmountable challenge and my team/org/company would be screwed if I didn't surmount it, so I figured it out. I think it's safe to say that it was "the hard way" though
- groby_b 4y agoIf you are interested in building teams, line manager is the way to get there. And if you think building your own company somehow lets you get around being a line manager... Unless you have a trust fund, I don't think that'll work. Pretty much no startup can afford to outsource people leadership until you've grown a good bit. If you go the "tech lead" route in FAANG, you have some input into the building of the team, but you should be aware that's limited. Ultimately, the person doing the day-to-day leadership (the line manager) is the person who has the strongest voice in how the team is shaped.
- bergenty 4y agoI’m going the opposite. I’m only good at managing people and don’t like to deal with the technical details anymore.
- dasil003 4y agoThis is so generic as to be useless. A great manager can read this and nod along to most of the ideas. A terrible manager can cargo cult everything here and claim to be doing a great job. Broadly speaking, there are two reasons managers fail: either A) they don't do a good job representing the work of their team sideways or upwards or B) they don't do a good job representing and cascading the strategic direction from leadership. While there are many specific modes of failure, they all essentially boil down to one (or both!) of those gaps. The article talks about the Peter Principle where ICs are promoted without management skills, but the flip side of managers who only studied management with no practical expertise is a greater peril. It's obvious when the former is failing, whereas the latter can spin a web of bullshit long enough to continuously fail upwards.
- gundmc 4y agoI don't disagree with your observations of common failure modes, but I actually found this article quite concrete and actionable compared to much of the "productivity porn" that gets posted here.
- achow 4y agoThat is very transactional PoV. Almost like manager being seen as a middle person and a translator. Lack of coaching, culture building, career planning are something that would also lead to failures.
- dasil003 4y agoI acknowledge the reductiveness of what I'm saying, but it's absolutely not transactional. To the contrary, understanding and distilling broad contexts from which you have only partial visibility is incredibly difficult work and easy to get wrong. Influencing without direct control requires sustained learning, relationship building and self-reflection. My point is that all the nuance and subtlety of management is easy to get lost in (especially if you go straight into management without strong baseline work experience). Coaching, Culture Building, and Career Planning are all important components, but you will not do a good job at them if you don't understand A) the work and B) the business context and strategic direction.
- ur-whale 4y agohttps://archive.ph/gef1r https://archive.ph/gef1r
- koonsolo 4y agoI hate it when people mix terminology together. For me: a leader is the one that sets the direction. A manager is the one that supports the team so they can do their job. Those are 2 different responsibilities. Sure, they can be combined into 1 person, but don't have to. So for me it's always weird to read articles where they interchangeably use "manager" and "leader", as if it's the same thing. No it's not! And there the problem starts where companies think that a "manager" == "boss". NO! A manager is at the service of their team!
- agumonkey 4y agoI always thought a manager was an emotional buffer so people could talk about the overall planning and team spirit.
- bronzecarnage 4y agoSlight detour, but I believe it's the same issue with politicians around the world.
- lejohnq 4y agoFor what it’s worth, the book this article is based on explicitly talks about these two different responsibilities and why a manager (by title) will always have to do both in some capacity. And the amount of each responsibility a manager holds varies depending on level, like a “Director of Engineering” will be more on the “leadership” side setting direction but they still need “management” of their direct reports (other engineering managers or managers of managers), whereas an “Engineering Manager” will likely spend more time in “management” at the service of their team of IC engineers.
- koonsolo 4y agoI fully agree with you on this one.
- watwut 4y agoLeader and manager being different person is quite rare. Mostly because it is unstable setup - the leader will be out of touch, the manager will dethrone the leader. Unless the leader has some additional power. Also, manager that has not have sufficient power over decisions is just secretary.
- arnvald 4y agoOne big reason I see why managers are failing is because nobody really helps them to become good managers. When you move from a developer to EM position, very often all the support you get is "good luck!" and a pat on the back. I've worked at a 1,000-people software development company where there was 0 training or even proper onboarding for managers, there was no community for EMs so that they can help each other, there was absolutely no effort to help managers improve. As a developer it was much easier for me to improve my skills - I worked with other programmers, saw their code, they reviewed my code, we programmed together. When I was a mid-level dev a single pairing session with a principal developer opened my eyes to so many things. As a manager I lack such opportunities, and employers ignore it.
- roenxi 4y agoThe funnel for promotions has started to get thin at this level, and leadership positions select strongly for people who like being promoted. Individuals might perceive the situation more collaboratively. As a body though this is a group where every individual is competing and unlikely to spend time educating others who are, effectively, rivals.
- c-linkage 4y agoManaging people is a specialized skill. Both employees and employers should require that those in management positions have the necessary training and credentials to perform the task. This means either taking a specialized management curriculum at university or being put through a comprehensive management training course. It takes four or five years of education at a University to get an engineering degree, yet businesses somehow find it acceptable to make anyone a manager regardless of whether they have been trained.
- alexanderbenoit 4y agoI completely agree with this. I've always been curious as to why so many other roles get proper training but not the role of manager, which arguably has an even larger impact. I'm figuring out a way to change this: https://larsen.ai https://larsen.ai
- fooblat 4y agoI have been an engineering leader for over 10 years and in all this time I received almost no training or coaching. I was pulled up from my role as an engineer. For the past 6 months I have been working with a remote leadership coach and it has been incredible! My coach is extremely experienced and alternates between prompting me to solve my own challenges and sometimes just telling me what to do in a given situation. I highly recommend it to anyone in a leadership or management role. edit: typos
- chiefalchemist 4y ago> Why are managers failing? Simple. Failing leadership (further up the stream). Full stop.
- osigurdson 4y agoA great tech founder can scale a business to a few hundred employees while still contributing on an individual level. The typical middle manager, on the other hand, seemingly requires 100% time to manage < 10 people. Why is this the case? My theory is founders are leading with a crystal clear, easy to communicate vision. That is the kind of management that scales.
- torginus 4y agoAnd curiously, when they go on a vacation, their absence is rarely felt, except when encountering some administrative stuff that needs to be rubber-stamped.
- gmays 4y agoFounders are also incentivized to invest much more time energy into their businesses than a middle manager. Founders also shape their org structure to something that suits them, while a middle manager has to work within the constraints of their organization, which are often stifling with significant overhead. Even basic things take inordinate amounts of time for middle managers. You could ignore them, but that often has secondary impacts like not taking care of your team (promotions, good reviews, training, etc.) or not getting your team the visibility it needs.
- osigurdson 4y ago>> getting the team the visibility it needs Visibility to whom? It seems like an anti-pattern that a team should have to fight for visibility in an organization. I believe this must be related to overly centralized control structures.
- gmays 4y agoYes, exactly. Large organizations are full of anti-patterns that middle managers must navigate. The gist of my comment was that middle managers have to wrestle with inefficiencies that founders don't. Said another way, founders define structure and middle managers inherit it.
- jksmith 4y agoI read a bit of this, and it struck me as some more generic fast food consumption, so I got bored. I've consulted for 5 F500's now, and by far the biggest issue with managers at these companies is that they still focus on managing people and not managing the flow of value.
- propogandist 4y agohow does a people manager move to managing the flow of value?
- mixmax 4y agoThe people are the vlue
- taftster 4y agoIn some ways, I think that's what the article is saying. I think the article takes the position that people are valuable and that investing in their success therefore creates value.
- torginus 4y ago> “We tend to select managers either based on their tenure or because they were the best individual contributor on the team,” he says I wish that were true. But in my experience, the people who seem to be promoted are the 'climbers' - the ones who are looking for opportunities to get ahead, and are less interested in actually performing well at their jobs. Promoting the highest performers would be actually a great idea - imo, one of the key properties of a good hierarchy is buyin from subordinates - seeing someone get promoted who is more experienced or a better coder than me signals to me that I should give that person's opinion more consideration, and if I improve my craft, I'll be eligible for promotion as well. Instead usually the people who get promoted are the ones who suck up to their (likewise incompetent) bosses, say yes to every harebrained scheme coming from up above, rather than pointing out the flaws, and demonstrate 'leadership skills' by posting '5 ways to supercharge your code'-style articles in the group chat. Once these climbing yes men start getting promoted, they show a preferential treatment to their own kind, and the organization's days are numbered. That's why 'non-technical manager' is a contradiction in my humble opinion.
- dominotw 4y agoYes I've seen the opposite. They are reluctant to promote you if you are a really good IC because they will lose a solid contributor.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoAlso known as the Dilbert Principle
- vsareto 4y agoThe leetcode grind is playing a game in some respects, and I don't see this as any different. Management was doing this before leetcode was a thing though. >Once these climbing yes men start getting promoted, they show a preferential treatment to their own kind, and the organization's days are numbered. I don't think so. If there were actually company-ending consequences, you'd see this stuff around a lot less. I see a lot of preferential treatment for stuyding/passing leetcode interviews as well. There's also a counter-culture to it which has preferential treatment for people who don't like leetcode. To me this just seems like company culture in America and instead of ending the company, it keeps it going.
- taftster 4y agoThis is a great tl;dr - I'd still recommend reading the article though: > ... a list of three specific management behaviors most closely aligned with employee engagement. * Direction: Good managers ensure that every member of their team understands exactly what is expected and when it is expected. * Coaching: Good managers coach their people towards both short and long-term success, helping them understand what they should continue to do and how they can improve. * Career: Good managers invest in their people’s careers in a way that considers their long-term goals and aspirations beyond the four walls of the current company, and certainly beyond their next promotion. Love this, very well said.
- Ava4312 4y ago