4 ms·
Yeah, the tone I'm getting from reading this basically boils down to "I was uncomfortable with how he played so I quit". Isn't that part of the metagaming in ch
by smoldesu 4y ago
Yeah, the tone I'm getting from reading this basically boils down to "I was uncomfortable with how he played so I quit". Isn't that part of the metagaming in chess? Poker has always been about unnerving your opponent through stoicism or deception. I don't see why chess can't have the same layer of subtlety, and if it really concerns him then he should be able to wear a visor to block everything but the game board. Otherwise, just take your loss and stand your ground.
- abnry 4y agoI want more of this metagaming in chess. That's one of the things I find interesting about Hans. His interviews suggest he's taking a sort of meta game approach. He suggested once a move of his against Alireza was a bluff because Alireza doesn't like attacking chess.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- squeaky-clean 4y agoThis is extremely common in high level chess. Every chess player will study their opponents history and recent play patterns and practice against that. Hans claimed he studied against Magnus' opening because Magnus had played it a few months ago. It turns out Magnus has never used that opening in a recorded game. The dialog has now changed to "well by move 20 the board state became identical to a previous Magnus game" but Hans didn't say he spotted the similarities at move 20, he said he studied that specific opening.
- roflyear 4y agoMagnus did have the same opening, but not the same sequence of moves (transposition) in several games. So that's just wrong.
- squeaky-clean 4y agoIt only became identical by turn 20, that's midgame, not an opening.
- roflyear 4y agoSo what? What does that matter? 20 moves of prep is not unusual. Also opening/midgame/endgame is not defined by # of moves. This was still very much in the opening, and it was still very much "known theory" as in games have been played in that same line.
- oneoff786 4y agoThat may be part of mind games. It is not part of meta games.
- dgritsko 4y agoI think it boils more down to this: "I was uncomfortable with how he played because he has a history of cheating so I quit" Which is entirely reasonable, if you think that cheating is an "existential threat" to chess itself.
- smoldesu 4y agoIf he didn't want to play against him, he shouldn't have already done it weeks ago and then proceed to agree to a rematch, which he doesn't cancel until the last minute. I find it very hard to believe that Magnus only found out about Hans' history after the first move... unless he had someone assisting him in realtime.
- jbaczuk 4y agoit was just part of the rules you can't resign until you play 1 move
- smoldesu 4y agoWithdrawing attendance is also an option, which Carlsen himself says is a possibility he acknowledged. If he wants to follow through on this, we better see some damning evidence. If this entire hubbub was for nothing, the chess community as a whole is going to have egg on their face.
- jbaczuk 4y agoExcept it's impossible to prove non-existence, so it will never reach that point
- unethical_ban 4y agoThe best time to do the right thing is yesterday, the second best time is today. Perhaps a person knows they should have done more sooner, but still chooses to do what they think is right when they make a decision.
- 4y ago
- deanCommie 4y agoBasketball, hockey, and football players are expected to perform under the roar of tens of thousands of fans AND those that hate them. Tennis players and Chess players are expected to be granted absolute silence. Is that an inconsistency? I don't think so. It's part of the expectation of the sport. Sport is in general a weird type of impure competition. Sponsorships, TV contracts, etc, all contribute to mixed priorities. So no, I don't think it's appropriate to equate Poker and Chess in this regard. Their best practices can be evaluated on their own measures.
- Tenoke 4y ago>Poker has always been about unnerving your opponent through stoicism or deception As much as TV would make you think so that's mostly a myth. It was probably more so the case in the past but now it's at most a very minor part of the game, and most (typically all) of your edge comes from better card playing. A huge river bluff is viewed in the lens of 'I've represented a range which includes strong hands, and I make money if I get a fold X% of the time while increasing the call chance by Y% when I do have a good hand in this spot' and not 'I'm going to unnerve him by throwing money to make a bad decision'.
- tehnub 4y ago>I don't see why chess can't have the same layer of subtlety You think the players being uncertain whether or not their opponent is cheating is a good thing for chess? The game would crumble.