6 ms·
Two things going on here: 1. First, I'm a bit baffled by some of the responses along the lines of "Amazon should just own their mistake". Sorry, but in the rea
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
Two things going on here:
1. First, I'm a bit baffled by some of the responses along the lines of "Amazon should just own their mistake". Sorry, but in the real world, "finders keepers" rarely applies (unless you're talking about crypto, but I digress...). I would certainly want a bug corrected if it were in my favor, and if a bug went the other way, I might need to re-evaluate my company satisfaction based on my new comp, but I have literally never seen a case of "sorry, payroll system made an error, but never mind you can keep it". It literally never works like that in any case, e.g. I work in fintech and if a bank accidentally deposits money into your account and you spend it, you can go to jail [1] - the bank doesn't say "whoops, our bad".
2. Many people who joined the workforce after the Great Recession have never had to deal with falling stock prices, and basically have just come to expect that the equity portion of their compensation should be like cash. The whole point of equity compensation is for it to be variable based on the success of the company. I get it, I wouldn't be happy with my compensation falling either (and I've certainly been there, in the .com bust), but I don't have much sympathy for folks who are just discovering that the variable component of their compensation can, in fact, be variable in the negative.
[1] https://abc13.com/spending-cash-bank-error-teller-error-can-you-spend-money-in-your-account-thats-not-yours-what-happens-if-a-check/553519/ https://abc13.com/spending-cash-bank-error-teller-error-can-...
- Closi 4y agoYes, absolutely number 1! There is a huge precedent for companies not paying for compensation calculation mistakes, which is also supported by law (in the UK at least where I am from - but assume it would be the same in the US). Amazing how many comments in this thread are acting like this standard practice is a completely new thing with zero precedence.
- tomrod 4y agoPAYWALLED, else I would RTFA. You'd be surprised how many people follow the adage: "what is right is not always popular, and what is popular is not always right." In this case, a verified compensation item given to an employee should be respected on principle, as this isn't a one-time "whoops we overpaid you," it's a months-long process that affected many people. AMZ should write it off as a bonus and move on.
- idunno246 4y agoThere’s a difference between variable and a new hire at my current level would get literally double my current comp as a person at the company for five years
- alistairSH 4y agoa new hire at my current level would get literally double my current comp as a person at the company for five years That's not unusual. Well, 2x salary might be, but it's well established that job hopping is the only way to guarantee your salary stays close to market.
- staticautomatic 4y agoTo add a data point to this, I recently interviewed at a large tech company. As part of investigating the comp, I ran a linear regression on data from levels and the results indicated that you should deduct a few grand for every year of tenure.
- jonfw 4y agoWorth considering the biased data. Levels will only have data from job seekers- which would imply that they either have A) recent offer or B) salaries from employees who are considering jumping ship (biased towards employees who are underperforming or in underperforming business units) There is probably a missing category of employees who have been successful, gotten raises, and aren't shopping for jobs
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- imwillofficial 4y agoLevels is garbage data. How is this not obvious?
- 4y ago
- travisjungroth 4y agoThis is not finders keepers. The article is slightly vague, but my takeaway is that employee got raises. Those numbers went through a bunch of people. The pay went out for months. Then, they realized they miscalculated the raises. “Whoops, we didn’t mean to offer you $150k, but really $140k.” 1. I think they have no chance at getting back the pay from before. This isn’t a banking error, this is regret. As an employee could you be like, “whoops I messed up my budget. I wouldn’t have taken this job at $150k. Please backpay me to bring it up to $180k”. 2. It’s well studied that losses hurt more than gains feel good. People hate having their comp lowered and the stock has already fallen. May be better to leave the comp where it’s at. I mean, it’s not like it was 10x or something. The numbers were reasonable enough for this to be super wide spread and people to not notice for months.
- __derek__ 4y agoFrom what I've heard, this timeline is incorrect. People with approved Q3 promotions received Personal Compensation Statements (PCS) telling them that they would get a raise starting in October. They were never actually paid the increased amount, and the time between erroneous PCS and correction was on the order of days, not months. Some folks didn't even get their erroneous PCS because their manager was slow to share it.
- travisjungroth 4y agoThank you. That seems less serious. Still a bummer to experience getting your comp lowered.
- __derek__ 4y agoRight. It's not a great employee experience by any means. Mocking references to Strive to be Earth's Best Employer abound.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rurp 4y agoRegarding 1, I have seen this happen. I used to work for a govt agency that made a mistake and overpaid a number of employees, who were allowed to keep the extra payment. I'm not saying that's the norm, but it affected a number of people and I have heard of it happening other times as well.
- mikeryan 4y agoThe web is littered with people telling their stories of getting overpaid in comp, frequently around bonuses, and having the company ask for their money back. They're always disappointed to find out that they do, legally, owe the company the extra pay back. Good companies will work with the employees on this. Other's can be a bit shitty about it. Big caveat that this is a US-centric view.
- patrick451 4y agoWhen I was in gradschool, this happened to me all the time. I had the university ask for a couple hundred dollars back probably 6 times in 5 years. Whoever ran their payroll must have been woefully incompetent.
- brigade 4y agoPractically, clawing back overpaid compensation from an uncooperative former employee requires a lawsuit with a chance of the employee winning, and has the potential to be more expensive anyway than however much could be recovered. But, continued employment is easily dependent on recovering the overpayment one way or another. Usually by taking it out of future paychecks.
- kazinator 4y agoWhen I was 20 something, I had an extra zero added to a severance payment. I randomly called some law firm asking if I should just keep that. The lawyer dude plunged his arm into the telephone line and slapped me silly.
- SoftTalker 4y agoI wonder if you'd be safe just sticking it in a savings account until they asked for it back. I mean, is it your responsibility to point out their mistake? And after how much time might they lose their right to demand it back?
- bombcar 4y agoThe general consensus seems to be either leave it in the checking account until it is pulled back (and it almost always will be unless the amount is "small or reasonable" and therefor not caught in an audit) or directly contact the company immediately. Moving it to a savings account is tricky because the automatic clawback will pull from whatever account it was sent into. Once the company issues a W2 or 1099 the next year that covers it, I would consider it relatively safe to keep.
- bloak 4y agoThere's a third option for when the sum is really huge, like more money than you'll ever see in your life: find a good lawyer who can arrange transferring the money into some kind of trust fund, perhaps in a different country, that benefits your children, then wait for the knock on the door, expect to go to prison for a bit, but your children may be allowed to keep the money, and they might support you when you come out of jail. I think I read about a woman in New York successfully doing something like that with an accidental transfer from the United Nations, though I might be misremembering.
- bombcar 4y agoIf it's a company or other body at that point you're trying to figure out what will let them settle their books - perhaps prison time for you will do so. But other groups I'd be a bit more worried about them being willing to go to extra-judicial means to if not get the money back, at least get "revenge".
- michaelt 4y ago> Sorry, but in the real world, "finders keepers" rarely applies If Bob signs a contract for Alice to paint a fence for $800 and a copy-paste error transfers her $1000 instead, yes. But if the copy-paste error happened before the contract was signed? Leading to Bob promising Alice $1000 and signing a contract promising it? Then in all probability, Bob will end up paying the contract amount.
- ajross 4y agoCompensation for at-will employees does not constitute a contract. That's what "at-will" means, basically. In the breakdown of good faith interaction, the remedy (for both sides) is largely limited to the ability to walk away. But yes: if these were contractors Amazon had hired it would be very different.
- puffoflogic 4y agoThis is nonsense, possibly triggered by a misunderstanding of what the word "contract" denotes. An at-will employee and their employer contract that for each hour of work (or each ~week salaried) performed by employee on instructions from employer, employer will pay to employee $X. Just because such a contract doesn't contain any term indicating the length of time an employee will work doesn't make it less of a contract. As further evidence, if at-will employment were not a contractual agreement there'd be no recourse for the employee to recover unpaid wages. And yet unpaid wages are recoverable.
- ajross 4y agoThat's getting needless sticky about definitions, and harming understanding of the point, potentially leading people to think that these Amazon workers are going to get their raises, which they clearly won't. Let me be more concrete: am employer presenting you with a plan for future compensation[1] in an existing employment relationship does not constitute a contract. They can pay you what they want to pay you. [1] Your back wages argument doesn't apply here. These people never got paid at all.
- ghaff 4y ago>basically have just come to expect that the equity portion of their compensation should be like cash. Not just like cash. Like cash that may be worth 50% or more money by the time it vests. Hopefully, it won't get that bad for large public companies but there are probably people out there today who are banking on their total comp being $400K (and making decisions on that basis) when it's actually more like $200K or less.
- paganel 4y agoI’m out of the loop here and too lazy to check, but let’s say those people were to apply for a mortgage, would the bank only look at the “fixed” part of their income when considering one’s application? Or it will also look at the “variable” part? (i.e. the part of the comp that will vest at some point in the future). If the answer to this last question is “yes”, how does the bank “compute” that future/expected income?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> would the bank only look at the “fixed” part of their income when considering one’s application? Or it will also look at the “variable” part? Should be both. To the latter, it depends how it’s structured. But typically by looking at a few years’ compensation.
- throwawaygog6 4y agoNormally, they will look at two years of stable(typically W2) income (Salary + RSUs) from one company before they make decisions. However, in bay area, some mortgage lenders have started excusing people who jump companies, because, well jumping companies in bay area is common. They now have to tweak their models. Source: Recently went through the mortgage
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoThis depends, if we sign a contract saying saying compensation is £X, i cant later lower your compensatuon claiming I made a mostake. It would be my responsebility to check befire signing.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoWhy all these hypotheticals that aren't relevant? That (signing of a binding contract where work was done and then the employer reneged on payment) manifestly did not happen in this case.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe proof is if, due to a bug, a person was undercompensated or money disappeared from their bank account, the person would absolutely expect to be made whole. BTW, I've had stock options that were never above water.
- sk5t 4y ago> stock options that were never above water That'd be most stock options in private companies, though.
- wyager 4y ago> I work in fintech and if a bank accidentally deposits money into your account and you spend it, you can go to jail So do I, and it depends. There was a whole case recently where chase (iirc) accidentally sent tens/hundreds of millions of dollars to a lender, and the lender chose to interpret it is an early loan repayment, and was allowed by the courts to keep the money.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y ago> the lender chose to interpret it is an early loan repayment, and was allowed by the courts to keep the money. No. The appeals court smacked them silly in a unanimous opinion and the money was returned to Citi [1]. From the appellate judge: > In a separate opinion, Circuit Judge Michael Park called the lawsuit a “straightforward case that many smart people have grossly overcomplicated and that we should have decided many months ago.” > “Put simply, you don’t get to keep money sent to you by mistake unless you’re entitled to it anyway,” Park wrote 1. https://www.bankingdive.com/news/citi-wins-appeal-500-million-revlon-loan-blunder/631536/ https://www.bankingdive.com/news/citi-wins-appeal-500-millio...
- wyager 4y agoAh, I did not see this update! Tfti
- zeruch 4y agoYour second item is so unbelievably on point, it hurts. The failure of so many to look at even a cursory sense of history would know that this industry has always had volatility baked in, and that affects not only "disruption" of business verticals, but disruption of vesting cycles :)
- pyuser583 4y agoAmazon recently added “being the best place to work” as one of their core values. If the “best place to work” made an error like this, they would figure out a way to let the employee keep it. Most places wouldn’t. But if I was in charge of a FAANG, an error like this happened, and I was committed to making the FAANG the “best place to work”, I’d cough up the change. Does Amazon want to be the best place to work, or not?
- dapithor 4y agoI'd say, Banque Worms ruling as we've found out can always be at play. Cough $900,000,000.00 accidentally transferred a couple years ago from a large bank to lenders.