3 ms·
The only attack this is preventing is corrupt or confused mobile network customer service representatives issuing a valid SIM card to an attacker so that the at
by mschuster91 4y ago
The only attack this is preventing is corrupt or confused mobile network customer service representatives issuing a valid SIM card to an attacker so that the attacker can intercept 2FA SMS messages, but any larger-ish company should already have a corporate phone plan with clearly established contact points to do any kind of change.
So what I don't really get is, what is the actual advantage? And besides, Cloudflare will have to run as an MVNO if they're rolling their own SIM cards / eSIM keys, which almost always means lower quality of service in congested network areas - there is no requirement for equal treatment of MVNOs I'm aware of, and even here in the EU you can clearly see that providers discriminate even between premium post-paid contracts and pre-paid contracts. Switching from Telekom's own MVNO Congstar to Telekom proper was night and day.
- cr3ative 4y agoThe attack you describe (somewhat dismissively) is extremely common.
- mschuster91 4y agoAgainst private phone contracts, yes indeed - but as I said, large companies (which CF targets here) already shouldn't be vulnerable. For private phone contracts, we should kick the arses of our politicians and the regulatory agencies to finally do their job.
- staticassertion 4y ago> but as I said, large companies (which CF targets here) already shouldn't be vulnerable. Only if you're willing to trust the reset process. The whole point of this is to remove that trust. Further, as noted, this doesn't just protect against that attack. It also allows for filtering at the data layer, so you can remove malicious traffic. And it also gives SIM a stronger identity, so if you're using a heuristic for identification (as you always are) it becomes a much more powerful entry.
- vinay_ys 4y agoThe same attack can be mounted against your corp IT admin in charge of your Cloudflare account.