3 ms·
Imho if you're ok with the GPL v3, the AGPL v3 is almost always the better choice. The spirit of the GPL is "if you change it for anything other than internal u
by wongarsu 4y ago
Imho if you're ok with the GPL v3, the AGPL v3 is almost always the better choice. The spirit of the GPL is "if you change it for anything other than internal use, you have to distribute the changes", and the AGPL just logically extends the enforcement of this to services provided over the internet.
The AGPL v3 and GPL v3 also contain provisions to make them compatible with each other (resulting in AGPL terms for the combined work, but the GPL parts remain GPL).
The FSF goes a bit more into detail on this: https://www.fsf.org/bulletin/2021/fall/the-fundamentals-of-the-agplv3 https://www.fsf.org/bulletin/2021/fall/the-fundamentals-of-t...
- bawolff 4y agoFWIW, i dont like the ambiguity of what is "configuration" and what is "code". I feel its a bit unclear. I also think its a bit problematic taken in the absolute, sometimes you have security patches you want to deploy and test out for a week before making the issue public, or perhaps emergency patches for sudden (downtime causing) issues.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoI don't think the nitty gritty details of the AGPLv3 matter much in practice. Those details matter most to the sort of organizations that fear lawsuits and consult with lawyers, and such organizations will likely not use AGPLv3 licensed code at all. AGPLv3 is thus a de facto 'hobbyists only' license, and hobbyists by in large don't go around suing each other; generally they just make good faith efforts to respect each others licenses and maybe use social ostracism when somebody steps over the line. Since hobbyists don't take their community disputes to court, the technical legal minutia of the license doesn't matter to most of them.
- bawolff 4y agoI still think details matter because it helps determine what is good faith following the license. Ambiguity also helps spread fud, which makes it harder for big companies to contribute and reuse such software.