3 ms·
"Negative externalities" should never be a license to abridge individual liberty. What about the "negative externalities" of smoking, drinking, listening to pun
by InclinedPlane 15y ago
"Negative externalities" should never be a license to abridge individual liberty. What about the "negative externalities" of smoking, drinking, listening to punk music, homosexuality, or reading subversive literature?
No thanks, you can keep your nanny state to yourself. I may not approve of my fellow citizens feeding their children happy meals but by god I will defend their right to do so just as strongly as I'll defend anyone's right to love who they desire, listen to what they want, read what they want, and say what they want.
- Anechoic 15y agoI completely disagree with what you wrote, but yon don't deserve to be downvoted. You don't believe that the "negative externalities" of smoking or drinking should be addressed in any way? Even through (say) taxes/surcharges on said products?
- InclinedPlane 15y agoIf there are indeed "negative externalities" then there are almost always better ways to address them than limiting individual liberty. I wasn't joking when I mentioned listening to punk music and homosexuality as also having negative externalities. Almost every behavior has some negative externality, even breathing. If we are to use the excuse of control of "negative externalities" as a lever to modify individual behavior then that lever becomes almost trivial to use to create a police state where every behavior is within the realm of the government to regulate.
- r00fus 15y agoYou must really hate that new $600/yr insurance premium for all smokers, right.? When industries are powerful enough to ignore markets and regulation they ARE governing you with their choices.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoIn what way does what I said imply that?