5 ms·
Ok, but what does that actually mean? The reality is, unless the Iranians themselves replace the Ayatollahs, it would require a foreign sponsored coup or outri
by lazide 4y ago
Ok, but what does that actually mean?
The reality is, unless the Iranians themselves replace the Ayatollahs, it would require a foreign sponsored coup or outright invasion to meaningfully change the status quo there.
- amir734jj 4y agoIt means: 1) publicly condemn the government 2) recognize that this government doesn't represent the people of Iran 3) don't give money to this government.
- lazide 4y agoAnyone giving money to Iran already gets sanctioned by the US, no? And the gov’t is already pretty isolated, except for ‘persona non grata’ countries like North Korea or Russia anyway. And I doubt those folks are going to change their mind over what’s going on.
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoI think point 3 is this, no? >I am worried this tyrannical government succeeds in putting down this movement and then the western governments sign another nuclear treaty which means sanction relief and more money for the regime
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> already gets sanctioned by the US Iran trades with Turkey, Pakistan, the U.A.E., Germany, India, Kuwait and Qatar [1]. [1] https://oec.world/en/profile/country/irn/?flowSelector1=flow0 https://oec.world/en/profile/country/irn/?flowSelector1=flow...
- mdibaiee 4y agoWe are not asking for foreign countries to "replace the Ayatollahs" for us. What we are asking, is ending their diplomatic relations with this government, or at least severing it, instead of trying to strengthen their diplomatic relations. A deal between this dictatorship and the west will only strengthen them, leading to more oppression. A weakened dictatorship due to foreign pressure will make it easier for the people of Iran to replace them.
- oliwary 4y agoI am genuinely curious - are there any historical examples where ending diplomatic relationships and imposing sanctions on a country has improved the situation for people living there?
- weatherlite 4y agoSouth Africa
- lazide 4y agoIt's not clear how much of South Africa's Apartheid collapse was due to external pressure, and how much was from internal problems. They had widespread and growing internal rebellion for a long time, with independent internal discussions and controversies going on about the unsustainability of Apartheid - both from a moral and economic perspective. Hell, they even tried Mandela for Treason in '56 and spent 27 years in prison after he started the revolutionary group in '61. Apartheid didn't end until the early '90's. Saying external sanctions caused it, is a bit like saying the USSR collapsed because of embargos. They definitely weren't helping make it stay, but it's hard to say those where why it collapsed.
- lazide 4y agoThat’s already been happening for decades. Has it made any difference?
- ghufran_syed 4y agoWell, there was pressure, until the Obama administration released $50 billion back to the regime https://www.factcheck.org/2019/03/obama-didnt-give-iran-150-billion-in-cash/ https://www.factcheck.org/2019/03/obama-didnt-give-iran-150-...
- largepeepee 4y agoAnd economic pressure means nothing to a theocracy that governs over a poor population. That is in fact their bread and butter. Look no further than Afghanistan to see how resilient they can be. They even withstood decades of occupation. Hard power alone wouldn't have worked and who knows whether soft power could have worked either since there were so many saboteurs both internal and external like Saudis/Israeli lobbies killing the project in its infancy.
- jokowueu 4y ago>would require a foreign sponsored coup Won't be the first time
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- case0x00 4y agoI do wonder on the feasibility of such events. I don't know a huge amount about pre-revolution Iran, but I don't think the Shah had an exceptionally powerful security force (I could be wrong). But now at least, the IRGC makes a revolution/coup very difficult.
- PraetorianGourd 4y agoThe Shah had a very powerful secret police, the SAVAK[1]. Prior to the overthrow of Mosaddegh, there wasn’t a comparable security force.. but I think something about gaining power in a coup makes one incredibly paranoid about being a victim of a coup. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/SAVAK https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/SAVAK
- Alir3z4 4y ago> Ok, but what does that actually mean? 1. Sanctions: check 2. International isolation: ~check 3. freezing foreign assets: check 4. Bringing freedom to Iran by liberating them (successful operations like Iraq, Syria, Afghanistan, ....): LOL, never gonna happen