8 ms·
Starlink now over 1M user terminals manufactured
- Stevvo 4y agoNot something to be proud of when you have less half a million customers. Literally half the terminals are e-waste because you can't pause service or pass the terminal on to someone else to use.
- gordon_freeman 4y agoStarlink is definitely filling the niche market of providing internet connectivity in rural and sparsely populated areas where firms with traditional business models with fiber-optics based network are not incentivized to provide. The real question is: will Starlink become profitable by in turn finding a big enough market itself to be able to cover the Billions of dollars of cost of manufacturing, launching and maintaining these satellites? Elon Musk seems to be open to separate Starlink business from SpaceX and list it publicly in future (he tweeted something in that regard previously [1]) so it seems like he definitely thinks Starlink can become a profitable business in near future. [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2022/06/07/spacex-starlink-ipo-elon-musk-says-offering-is-3-or-4-years-away.html https://www.cnbc.com/2022/06/07/spacex-starlink-ipo-elon-mus...
- seltzered_ 4y agoI hope those dreaming of this consider theres knowledgeable engineers and astronomers that think their growth plans are an ecological disaster: https://twitter.com/mxshift/status/1563561387649298432 https://twitter.com/mxshift/status/1563561387649298432 (Edited my comment from initially having a more polarizing tone.)
- brtkdotse 4y agoI read an opinion piece somewhere that Starlink is just busy work to keep SpaceX launching rockets, but because gestures at Google I can’t find it. This Twitter thread nakes this theory plausible.
- WHATDOESIT 4y agoWasn't that exactly the plan publicized by Musk?
- wmf 4y agoIt doesn't make sense to lose money on every rocket launch but make it up in volume. It's more accurate to say that reusable rockets and a LEO satellite constellation can form a mutually-reinforcing flywheel that will lower costs for the eventual Martian fleet.
- aardvarkr 4y agoWhy can’t it be both? It absorbs excess capacity, allowing spacex to expand their capacity and achieve economies of scale that are unmatched in the modern world of rocketry while also setting up an exciting new revenue stream that will move them away from relying on government contracts. It also helps them win support from republicans as it serves rural communities and is an example of business innovation that the GOP can support which should help them win more govt contracts. Lots of win-win-win opportunities here
- modeless 4y agoStarlink is absolutely a way to keep SpaceX launching rockets, but that doesn't make it busywork. It's revolutionary and immensely valuable. And, any theorized environmental impact has to be compared to the existing natural process of space dust falling into the atmosphere, and measured against the saved costs worldwide of wires and cell towers and travel not needed, especially as capacity increases in the future. Which is practically impossible to measure, but failing to account for difficult-to-measure costs is a classic error people make when evaluating things like this. And of course there's the extra benefits of coverage over oceans and poles and to ships and planes that you can't get any other way.
- Seanambers 4y agoIf one assumes that all terminals are in use by paying customers @ 110[1] per month that gives 1.3 billion a year in income. Plus 0,5 billion usd for the hardware. So far there have been 62 Starlink launches - assuming an average price of 67m usd[2] that gives a total launch cost of 4.15 billion(real launch cost is lower as SpaceX does it at cost. Life expectancy of the satellites are between 5 - 7 years so excluding R&D cost I'd say Starlink is already cashflow positive and will generate huge returns in the future. I'm sure there are some commercial / military contracts in the mix which alone will add a couple of B's to the income number. 1 & 2- https://www.cnbc.com/2022/03/23/spacex-raises-prices-for-launches-and-starlink-due-to-inflation.html https://www.cnbc.com/2022/03/23/spacex-raises-prices-for-lau...
- frankjr 4y agoStarlink's prices now take into consideration the buying power of each country. For example, it costs ~$55 in Czechia and ~$41 in Hungary.
- tuatoru 4y agoOf course SpaceX would use differential pricing. Once the satellites are up there orbiting, they might as well be earning income for as much of each orbit as they can. Zero marginal cost to do so. So SpaceX's prices in each market will be low enough to be competitive in each market. The caveat to that is that they're still taking a large loss on each user terminal, so they have to make that back over the expected life of a contract.
- hef19898 4y agoYou forgot on-going operations, maintenance and so on. Also, you assume all terminals are in use and paid for every month.
- Seanambers 4y agoYeah, thats why I started with "If one assumes.." :) But good point, I did not consider overhead and operational costs in this.
- leke 4y agoLol, I read the headline as... Starlink now over. 1M user terminals manufunctioned.
- naveen99 4y agoYou don’t need to go rural or sparsely populated for low cost living… places like india have low cost housing, food, internet, and labor. I would think the market for internet in sparsely populated areas is by definition negligible. But, if all cell phones can access starlink in cell phone dead zones, that might make it economically viable, as the market expands to 5 billion plus users.
- seizethecheese 4y agoThat’s some funky reasoning. Most Americans will not move overseas to get lower cost of living, so rural areas are a good substitute. Likewise, cost is not the only consideration, also quiet and privacy.
- tuatoru 4y agoThe world is around 60% urbanized, so there are still 3 billion people in rural areas. Quite a stretch to call that number negligible.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoPerhaps. But another way to look at it is, now you could live anywhere. Pardon the cliche but Starlink might a game changer, a paradigm shift. I don't disagree with you per se. But in this case the future might be different than the past. We'll have to wait and see.
- palata 4y agoBecause the only thing preventing you from living anywhere is the Internet connection? What abouy access to water, food, infrastructure, social life?
- chiefalchemist 4y agoYou mean homesteading? Or RV'ing? Yes. That's being done now. However, it's safe to presume some don't want to be completely isolated. There's the safety aspect. There's also, as you noted, the social aspect. Truly ubiquitous internet is not what we have now. And because of that fact we can't presume the future will simply be more of the past.
- NelsonMinar 4y agoRelated: Starlink Speeds Drop Significantly in the US Amid Congestion Woes https://www.pcmag.com/news/starlink-speeds-drop-significantly-in-the-us-amid-congestion-woes https://www.pcmag.com/news/starlink-speeds-drop-significantl...
- anonporridge 4y agoSurprising absolutely no one who understands networking. The ludicrously high speeds that were praised during the limited beta really seem like they were designed to be a bait and switch to get people on board with completely unrealistic expectations for a full fledged satellite internet service.
- NelsonMinar 4y agoIt seems to be surprising Starlink; they're still telling customers they should expect speeds far above what we're getting in practice. Their service description is a fiction. https://www.starlink.com/legal/documents/DOC-1002-69942-69?regionCode=US https://www.starlink.com/legal/documents/DOC-1002-69942-69?r...
- ceejayoz 4y ago> they're still telling customers they should expect speeds far above what we're getting in practice That's Musk's MO, isn't it? "Full self driving", Mars by 2022... They certainly do some genuinely cool stuff, but meeting promises like this isn't one of them.
- panick21_ 4y agoYes its amazing that a company that is deploying more infrastructure every week thinks that the capacity of their infrastructure will go up. Crazy that they think that.
- zizee 4y agoYou make it sound like they are being extremely misleading, and yet the page you linked to has this text in bold: > Stated speeds and uninterrupted use of Services are not guaranteed. Actual speeds will likely be lower than the maximum speeds during times of high usage. Starlink may temporarily reduce speeds if our network is congested.
- retrocryptid 4y ago1m user terminals manufactured and yet we still don't have one 18 months after paying for it. (Actually, I canceled my order a year ago. But my brother, who also paid the full $600 still doesn't have his. And they keep delaying it.) Three years ago we both signed up for a terminal, paid the $100 deposit and got on the list. Eighteen months ago I got an email saying I should log in, pay the additional $500 to have the terminal shipped to me. After three months of waiting nothing had shown up. There's no way to contact customer support so I had to ask a friend who works at SpaceX who I should talk to. Two weeks later I got an email from someone I'm guessing is part of their support group saying i was in the queue for delivery in late 2021. Late 2021 comes and goes and no terminal. I ping that same person. Now I'm in the queue for a late 2023 delivery. I ask if I can get a refund, they say yes. They credit my card for the second $500 charge but not the original $100 which they claim is unrefundable. My brother, the true believer, is still waiting for his terminal and his cybertruck. I know that Elon is a minor deity on hacker news and peeps are going to downvote the heck out of this comment, but from my perspective, dude's a ripoff artist who survives only because the government is paying for his rockets and ev subsidies.
- completelylegit 4y agoIt’s been my thinking for a while that the majority of people who interface with Musk ventures walk away happy. They must, right? Customers are the most important fans. But if for some reason one of the cogs in the big machine fails you - you are screwed. There is no real recovery beyond tweeting @ElonMusk on the day once a year has his heart reinserted to legally be considered alive. I’m sorry to hear your situation - mine was different, more positive. The line that separates us is one broken cog. Musk customer support is the worst and I’m sorry you can’t enjoy what has been a life changing product for me. Hang in there, it (Musk venture customer service) sometimes gets better.
- retrocryptid 4y agoHow long have you worked for Mr. Musk?
- retrocryptid 4y ago
- terafo 4y agoI wonder how expensive they are to produce now and have they managed to break even. Gwen Shotwell told the press that their costs were around 1300 with some updated model that was released in early 2021, she said that in April. Since then there was second gen antenna made, that is, I presume, cheaper to produce. And there was leaked email of Musk in late 2021 that was talking about need to get v2 sats working so amount of terminals they are ordering could make sense(email was about their need to fix Raptor 2 production in order to do this). Then they upped their prices in March of this year and IMO this could be a sign of break even point(not sure though).
- pmorici 4y agoI’d guess that the fact that they are allowing service you can pause now means that they are probably at break even on the user terminal hardware cost. 1 million terminals shipped means roughly $1 billion a year in revenue. Some customers are paying substantially more than $100 a month depending on the tier of service.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xnx 4y agoWould love to see websites start optimizing for low-bandwidth high-latency connections. Page sizes have continue to increase even with the increase in usage of [typically] slower mobile connections, so I'm not holding my breath.
- dj_gitmo 4y agoMaybe HTTP/3 with QUIC would help since there are less round trips?
- palata 4y agoOne thing that has always been true is that we always put as much crap as possible while not getting unusable. Computers got infinitely more powerful, but websites are not faster to load because they are much bigger. QUIC won't change that, it would just allow for more crap.
- sam0x17 4y agoAnd each one they deploy seems to decrease the average bandwidth https://telecoms.com/517598/starlinks-download-speeds-have-declined-over-the-last-year/ https://telecoms.com/517598/starlinks-download-speeds-have-d...
- Smoosh 4y agoInteresting that they can have them manufactured at high volume when everyone else is claiming that they are struggling with supply chain issues.
- sidcool 4y agoLove him or hate him, Elon Musk knows how to productionize things.