4 ms·
We are free to pick and choose what we think is worth preserving or adopting.
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago
We are free to pick and choose what we think is worth preserving or adopting.
- Kye 4y agoBut maybe let's avoid things that are dependent on violent overthrow of competing ideologies. If a way of life only works by crushing other ways, it's a bit garbage.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoSelf reflection and discipline is garbage?
- Kye 4y agoThose are features of many ways of life, not ways of life in themselves. What those terms mean depends on the backing ideology. They don't exist in isolation. This thread is discussing Puritanism.
- yuuu 4y ago“dependent on” != “associated with”
- Kye 4y agoWell, the topic is Puritanism. That's what I was talking about.
- yuuu 4y agoAll aspects of Puritanism are “dependent on violent overthrow of competing ideologies?”
- Kye 4y agoThese were people who fled Europe because they considered the Catholic church of the 1500s/1600s too liberal. How well do you think they got on with their neighbors? I've seen firsthand how effective an eliminationist ideology can be even without overt violence growing up in Baptist country.
- yuuu 4y agoIt’s unclear what you’re trying to say. All aspects of Puritanism are bad because some people did violent things, historically? Nobody’s arguing with the latter, and the comment you originally responded to was, “We are free to pick and choose what we think is worth preserving or adopting.”
- smoldesu 4y agoYou are definitely free to associate with whoever you choose, just as others are are free to judge you for associating with those people. I'm someone who likes to give most ideas a fair shake, but I'm also not going to entertain a defence of fascism that highlights the decline of animal cruelty under Hitler. Most people who aren't me would probably walk away as soon as you bring up Orthodoxy.
- starkd 4y agoThe comparison to fascism is not even relevant here. Fascism is a corporate/government collaboration to achieve a specific end. Puritans were not talking about this. They were about self-reflection and self-improvement. The overzealotry of Puritism was based on populist uprisings. The failed collectivist experiments of the 20th century took a far greater toll on humanity than the Puritans ever did. By far.
- yuuu 4y agoYou have a good point. I tend to not entertain ideas based on overused strawman comparisons with Hitler and Nazis.
- aliasxneo 4y agoI've read a majority of the Puritan works available to us (at least a couple of dozen), and while I don't necessarily agree with them on all points theologically, they certainly perfected the art of soul care. In particular, Richard Sibbes is poetic in the way he addresses brokenheartedness (his work, The Broken Reed, probably sits at the apex of this). They also had a significantly higher view of pastoral care, one that I wish had not been lost in our modern age. I try to read the Reformed Pastor at least once every few years as a reminder (contrary to popular belief, this has nothing to do with reformed theology).
- starkd 4y agoAlso contrary to popular belief, it was not that the Puritans genuinely thought themselves to be better than everyone else. Their writing indicate they were all too acutely aware of their sinfulness. They knew of the difficulties in steering clear of it. When you are starving and you find bread, it is only natural you want to inform others how they too can find it. This is probably the root of their overzealousness.