3 ms·
I don't get it. The fuel is still a hydrocarbon. Note the "carbon" in hydrocarbon. When it burns it's still emitting CO2. Where the fuel comes from is not relev
by WalterBright 4y ago
I don't get it. The fuel is still a hydrocarbon. Note the "carbon" in hydrocarbon. When it burns it's still emitting CO2. Where the fuel comes from is not relevant to atmospheric CO2.
Edit: Let's go through this carefully.
1. pump jet fuel out of the ground. Burn it. CO2 goes into atmosphere. Bury plants with an equivalent amount of C.
2. Convert plants with an equivalent about of C into jet fuel. Burn it. CO2 goes into atmosphere.
So, which scenario reduces the amount of CO2 into the atmosphere? Neither. They're the same.
This whole scheme of "sustainable biofuels" is a complete Emperor Has No Clothes sham, to put it mildly.
- manmal 4y agoThe plants used for the fuel would have pulled the CO2 from the atmosphere within the last year or so.
- WalterBright 4y agoHow is that relevant? A C atom from a million years ago is the same as a C atom from today. (Yes, I know Carbon 14 decays, but that's not relevant to this discussion.) A C atom from today is not magically different.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 8organicbits 4y agoThe difference is that carbon from millions of years ago was buried deep underground. Digging up and burning fuel increases atmospheric carbon. Cycling atmospheric carbon into fuel and back to the atmosphere is a one for one replacement.
- WalterBright 4y agoThat's why I wrote burying the equivalent plant C mass, which is a lot cheaper than trying to convert it into fuel.
- manmal 4y agoI‘m not sure transporting plants to a dump site and burying them there is cheaper than converting to fuel and selling it. Excavation would be quite CO2 intensive, too.
- WalterBright 4y agoInstead of transporting them to the fuel conversion site? There are landfills and pit mines everywhere.
- manmal 4y agoJust putting stuff in landfills results in methane production, which would gradually leak out and cause even more global warming than CO2. You‘d need to invest in making things air tight, ideally over hundreds of years.
- WalterBright 4y agoMethane has a half life in the atmosphere of 12 years. Gradually leaking methane is way down the list of problems.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoMethane is one of the top problems and low hanging fruit to tackle. https://www.epa.gov/gmi/importance-methane https://www.epa.gov/gmi/importance-methane > Methane is the second most abundant anthropogenic GHG after carbon dioxide (CO2), accounting for about 20 percent of global emissions. Methane is more than 25 times as potent as carbon dioxide at trapping heat in the atmosphere. Over the last two centuries, methane concentrations in the atmosphere have more than doubled, largely due to human-related activities. Because methane is both a powerful greenhouse gas and short-lived compared to carbon dioxide, achieving significant reductions would have a rapid and significant effect on atmospheric warming potential. https://www.globalmethanepledge.org/ https://www.globalmethanepledge.org/ > In advance of the 2021 UN Climate Change Conference in Glasgow (COP 26), the United States and the European Union jointly launched the Global Methane Pledge, which asked countries to band together and commit to a collective goal of reducing global methane emissions at least 30% from 2020 levels by 2030
- ksaj 4y agoIt's almost relevant, because C14 decays into N14 (which is what we measure for carbon dating). N14 on the ground is a stable fertilizer. But if it is airborne and makes it to the planet's uppermost layers, cosmic rays eventually convert it back to C14 again. It's an interesting cycle.
- avgcorrection 4y agoWhat matters is whether you put new carbon (which was not part of the carbon cycle) into the atmosphere.
- WalterBright 4y agoI understand what you're saying, but it makes no sense. You can take the plant and bury it instead of converting it to jet fuel, and you have a FAR cheaper method of achieving exactly the same atmospheric CO2 result. CO2 is CO2, regardless of whether it came from a new plant or a fossilized plant.
- nosianu 4y ago> CO2 is CO2, regardless of whether it came from a new plant or a fossilized plant. There is a carbon cycle above ground, what we did is inject more and more carbon back into it that had been removed from it by slow natural processes over long periods of time long ago. No. The problem we have is that we added all that carbon that was long ago buried deep back into the above ground carbon cycle. If we had only ever used carbon that already is in the above ground cycle we would not have a problem, we would not have increased atmospheric CO2 by much even if we temporarily - and it would always be just that - turned some more carbon lying around above ground into CO2. By using buried carbon we increased the amounts of carbon in the above ground cycle by a gigantic amount. In addition we burnet most of it directly too, but just that it is above ground, available to various processes including natural ones, would have increased CO2 even if we had not burnt it right away. (disregarding that buried carbon does not only come from buried plants for this sentence) The problem is not that forests burn, it's that ancient long-buried forests burn.
- WalterBright 4y agoUm, but you're burying the same amount of carbon that you're burning in the ordinary jet fuel, which achieves the same CO2 result. Without having to generate synthetic fuels at all.
- avgcorrection 4y ago
- abazeeeeeee 4y ago
- tinco 4y agoI think the implied benefit is that the hydrocarbons could be synthetic. Why they're mentioning that is a bit suspect though. Basically they should be saying "you know those hydrocarbons that are 100 times more expensive than regular fuel? We can now use those for flying jets". It would be a lot less appealing article then. The way I see it there's only two ways we could have sustainable flying. Either using 100% hydrogen, or using some future battery breakthrough. Synthetic fuels are cool, but in my opinion we should be storing captured CO2 in the ground, not releasing it in the air again.
- WalterBright 4y agoSynthetic fuels, if I recall correctly, cost about 5x more than refined oil, which is why we pump oil instead of making synthetics. As you say, there isn't going to be any magic solution for jet aircraft. It's an energy/weight problem, and jet fuel is really really hard to beat for that. For batteries it would not be a little breakthrough needed, it would need to be an incredible breakthrough, and nobody has any idea how that might work. The fundamental issue is batteries, in essence, carry their own "oxidizer" with them, which is very heavy. With jet fuel, you just suck the oxidizer from the air as needed. Any battery that used air as its "oxidizer" would be, literally, burning it, and wouldn't be a battery.
- yobbo 4y agoThis is true. Another one: burying waste paper (and cutting down new trees) instead of recycling reduces both CO² and probably energy use too. I think the argument against this is that these are not mutually exclusive alternatives. Reducing fossil fuels does not prevent us from burying biomass.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThis is not true. https://www.sciencefocus.com/science/is-recycling-paper-bad-for-the-environment/ https://www.sciencefocus.com/science/is-recycling-paper-bad-... > Recycling causes 35 per cent less water pollution and 74 per cent less air pollution than making new paper. Ironically, one vaguely true point was that we used to burn wood waste in pulp mills, which is better than recycling with coal powered electrcity. The fix was to stop burning coal for electricity though, not to stop recycling.
- kjeetgill 4y agoI think the reason everyone down thread is confused is that it was incredibly unclear that you were adding the whole sequester the net equivalent component. It's an interesting thought though I'm curious how all the pieces would balance in practice. Like, What's the cost of digging up the fuel? The cost of sequestering the equivalent. And there's pieces like reducing production reduces how much net sequestration will ever need to be done. I don't think it's so hyper self evident that no hypothetical future sustainable biofuel has a place. No one's selling you a sham solution here, it's research after all. > This whole scheme of "sustainable biofuels" is a complete Emperor Has No Clothes sham, to put it mildly. I think that's unreasonably uncharitable.
- WalterBright 4y ago> I'm curious how all the pieces would balance in practice That's a reasonable thought. Though I find it hard to believe that processing plants into synthetic fuels would be cheaper than just burying it, like into an old coal mine. > that's unreasonably uncharitable It's reasonably charitable because every single article I've ever read about biofuels never mentions my observation, nor have I ever heard anyone else mention it. It's all like "if we burn fuels made from plants, we're not really contributing to CO2" nonsense. People have mentioned growing trees and then stuffing them into coal mines to sequester the C, but never in the context of biofuels. Maybe I can draw attention to this by being uncharitable, which will make it worth while.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoI think you just need better news sources: https://theconversation.com/amp/ipcc-report-biofuels-alone-are-unsustainable-but-can-still-help-combat-climate-change-25046 https://theconversation.com/amp/ipcc-report-biofuels-alone-a...
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThis idea is called BECCS and is covered in detail by the IPCC reports: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bioenergy_with_carbon_capture_and_storage https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bioenergy_with_carbon_captur... It and concepts like it are why we talk about 'net zero carbon' and not just 'zero carbon'. It's generally assumed that some amount of this is required to stay below 1.5C so if this was the best solution for air travel, it would be used. It's not as good as SAF and electrification though, so it's not used here, or for any other current process that has better options available.
- adwn 4y agoWhen you bury plants, they decay and release their carbon as CO2 back into the atmosphere within a couple of years. Reliably sequestering CO2 by burying plants is difficult and inefficient. In addition, converting crude oil to jet fuel is also very energy-intensive; the energy required typically comes from fossil fuel sources, so you'd be releasing much more fossil carbon into the atmosphere than just what is burned in the jet turbines.
- WalterBright 4y ago> so you'd be releasing much more fossil carbon into the atmosphere than just what is burned in the jet turbines The energy efficiency of refining jet fuel is 95.3%. Google "energy efficiency of refining jet fuel" Who knows what the energy efficiency of refining plants into jet fuel is, but I bet it's a lot less than 95.3%. The article doesn't cite what it is.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThe burning during the flight is the same (ignoring some mild advantages for the purer SAF) but from the well to wake there's other factors. One big one on each side is methane escapes during oil drilling (which can be managed but often isnt) and the input for the biofuel being something that was grown on cleared forest. Generally burning the methane and releasing the same carbon is better, and you get some use out of it. Today we do this for "renewable gas" but most land based uses for the output are in the process of being electeified. But we can still use then as GHG-negative feedstocks, or (roughly) GHG neutral fuels in aviation or shipping. https://theicct.org/sites/default/files/publications/Alt-aviation-fuel-sustainability-mar2021.pdf https://theicct.org/sites/default/files/publications/Alt-avi... So this paper estimates Brazilian soy could be better or worse than fossil fuel, depending on land used. US maize would come out almost the same as fossil, while Brazilian Cane sugar would be better and EU Miscanthis grass better again. And even better yet is using waste from agriculture or forestry or municipal Waste instead of something grown specifically for turning into fuel, some of which then make the process carbon negative.