6 ms·
Researcher shows how to "friend" anyone on Facebook within 24 hours
- JonnieCache 15y agoI miss the good old days when I could only send friend requests, not receive them. I guess clicking ignore every time isn't so hard. It was better back when people simply could find the "Add Friend" button though, there wasn't any risk of them being offended.
- RandallBrown 15y agoWhen could you not receive them? I remember getting friend requests when I first joined Facebook in 2005.
- rhizome 15y agoFacebook friendships have always been symmetrical.
- rhizome 15y agoVotes seem to be fluctuating on this, so I'm just going to add qualifications of "possibly not when it was University-only (i.e. before my time)" or "until recently" as they've moved to subscription connections and wall propagation for unconfirmed friendships.
- tryke 15y agoI was surprised to learn that Facebook has a "3 trusted friends" method for recovering your account without the original email or security question response. EDIT: tried to find a better source for that, came up with https://www.facebook.com/notes/facebook-security/national-cybersecurity-awareness-month-updates/10150335022240766 https://www.facebook.com/notes/facebook-security/national-cy... Looks like the feature is still being rolled out, and the attacker doesn't get to choose which friends he trusts.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- JonnieCache 15y agoRight. Does this mean that me and two of my friends can just decide to stage a coup on any of our mutual friends' accounts? EDIT: Yeah, apparently it does. Sweet. Time to scour /b/ for some truly horrible shit to plaster peoples' profiles with. Also highly recommended: changing their birthday to tomorrow.
- X-Istence 15y agoDon't I have to set up these three trusted friends? All I can find in Facebooks documentation is that I would need to specify these three to five trusted friends but I can't find anywhere to set this up.
- sp332 15y agoHm, this link has different screenshots: http://www.hackersonlineclub.com/hack-facebook-account http://www.hackersonlineclub.com/hack-facebook-account Any 3 "friends" who put their codes in can get access to your account.
- scott_s 15y agoNo, it does not: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3297075 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3297075
- gbelote 15y agoThat surprised me too. When trying myself I wasn't able to reach that method. I could be "doing it wrong", it could be no longer active, or may not work with an account tied to gmail. Has anyone else been able to do it?
- noahc 15y agoI just tried this on my brothers account. It lets me guess at his security question and then kicks me to a page that basically says that they currently don't support password recovery without knowing the answer to the security question.
- cannibalbob 15y agoI need more enemies! I want to try this out!
- 1010100101 15y ago"Privacy is a matter of social responsibility." Privacy is a matter of not using Facebook.
- veb 15y agoNo. Privacy is what you make it to be. If you don't want someone to know you like to rub lettuce over your face, don't tell anyone. The same principal works for real life too.
- 1010100101 15y agoWhat if someone wants to tell a few friends about something but doesn't want to tell all the people working at Facebook, all its clients and potentially any other Facebook user?
- scott_s 15y agoThen don't tell them through Facebook. If you don't mind Facebook knowing what you said, you can send a private message. That may not be a solution that people like, but it's what I do, and I think it's what we will all end up doing eventually.
- 1010100101 15y ago"Then don't tell them through Facebook." And that's the point. If a current offering such as Facebook is "not a solution that people like", then that creates an opportunity for a solution that people _do_ like. Will that opportunity be exploited? If not, why?
- scott_s 15y agoI don't think any large, online social network used by lay-people can allow the kind of privacy control that you (and many others) want. The system just becomes too complex, and information leaks. I think that we will eventually adapt to this constraint.
- huggah 15y agoA little melodramatic. My father logs into Facebook about once a month. How can you guarantee that he'll friend you within 24 hours?
- iy56 15y agoYou can't, really, but if he checks his email more often than once a month, he may act on the message that says "xxx has added you as a friend, please confirm."
- tokenadult 15y agoThe first thing I did when I saw this story was check Google to see if any other news sources had picked it up. I chose the researcher's name as a highly distinctive Google search term. I didn't find any source but Ars Technica just now that reports this finding. I noticed that there are websites that appear to belong to the Brazilian researcher, but I guess the moral of this story is that those websites may all be fake [sigh].
- rhizome 15y agoArs has not been a good website for some time now, at least a couple of years. They have squandered their future, but I dunno, I haven't checked but were they acquired by Gawker at some point? It would explain a lot.
- anorwell 15y agoThere seems to a lot of confusion, both in the article and in the comments, about the "3 trusted friends" password recovery. You have to manually select your trusted friends [1]. A fake account mimicking one of your friends will not be a "trusted friend" unless you make him or her one. Furthermore, this is an opt-in feature. [1] https://www.facebook.com/help/?faq=119897751441086 https://www.facebook.com/help/?faq=119897751441086
- bproper 15y agoYou need to trick an account into accepting three fake friends, since those users will receive the code to change the password. Hardly seems like obvious security flaw, more like a long, complicated piece of social engineering. Which is what all hackers do.... http://www.hackersonlineclub.com/hack-facebook-account http://www.hackersonlineclub.com/hack-facebook-account
- anorwell 15y agoYou need to trick an account into adding three fake friends as "trusted friends", a feature that most people do not know about or use. This is much harder getting someone to friend three fake accounts.
- dgreensp 15y agoKind of a stretch, an elaborate ploy all to merely "friend" someone. Like, "Car thieves who want to steal your car can construct an exact replica of your street, house, and garage, so that you're actually parking right in the thief's carpark, security researchers reported today."
- falcolas 15y agoYet unlike building said exact replica, this could conceivably be automated and executed against an untold number of users at once.
- baddox 15y agoIt sounds like you're equating basic social engineering to an elaborate, large-scale, nearly impossible architectural trick. Are you trying to discount the effectiveness or feasibility of social engineering? Social engineering requires far less effort that your proposed analogy. I doubt if it took this guy more than half an hour to do the "hard work," which is just duplicating a profile and cross-referencing friends from two social networks. I agree that accidentally friending a fake account probably won't lead to much further online problems: the trusted friends example used in the article is far-fetched (and other HN comments indicate it's complete bogus), and they're not going to get your credit card info or account passwords. However, it's still a privacy concern. Anyone from an estranged ex-lover to a private investigator could get information like home address, vacation times, etc.
- scott_s 15y agoHowever, it's still a privacy concern. Anyone from an estranged ex-lover to a private investigator could get information like home address, vacation times, etc. Only if you put information on Facebook that you're not comfortable sharing with the whole world.
- baddox 15y agoI'm not sure what you mean by that statement. Are you saying that Facebook's internal security is weak, and therefore you shouldn't trust it with data that you explicitly make private? To my knowledge, Facebook's privacy concerns are more related to the tracking of users on other websites, having insensible privacy defaults, and having confusing privacy controls. I've never heard any concerns about Facebook ignoring your settings and leaking your content (that was just meant for your friends or a certain group) with the whole world. Are you singling out Facebook, or just referring to web services in general? Would you also say that you shouldn't have data on Gmail that you're not comfortable sharing with the whole world? What about online banking? All of those things are probably vulnerable to social engineering.
- D_Drake 15y agoI would be wary of anyone calling him/herself a "web security expert" who tolerates a presence on multiple social networking sites. It speaks of a mindset not nearly paranoid enough.
- andrewfelix 15y agoI deleted my Facebook account about 3 months ago Security was one of the big issues for me. My brothers account had been hacked, and the hackers managed to get some cash out of some of his friends. But I digress, and this off topic, but I don't miss FB at all. I still maintain genuine relationships outside of FB and find I have more time for proper conversations with people via Skype and email. FB to me was crack, I hated to love it. Now I love to hate it. Does anybody out their maintain genuine relationships through FB? (Serious Question) Why are we using it? Is it an addiction?
- aMoniker 15y agoCorrection: you _deactivated_ your account. Facebook keeps your data.
- noahc 15y agoNo, deleted and deactivated are two different things on Facebook[1]. You may disagree with the definition, but as it is currently used on Facebook he is being accurate. Facebook doesn't make it clear about what types of data they do and don't keep beyond saying they disassociate you from the information, but retain some for 'technical' reasons. I can't really imagine what those would be. [1]http://www.facebook.com/help/?faq=125338004213029#What-is-the-difference-between-deactivation-and-deletion http://www.facebook.com/help/?faq=125338004213029#What-is-th...?
- fl3tch 15y ago> but retain some for 'technical' reasons Probably the thing about databases getting fragmented, so they delete large swaths of data and optimize all at once, rather than piecemeal when the users delete it. It's well known that when you "delete" a photo from Facebook, if you save the direct link to it first, you can still access it (go ahead, try it). But the one time I tried it, the photo did finally disappear after about a week (although I have seen some people claim that they could access deleted content via direct links for up to 6 months).
- andrewfelix 15y ago