4 ms·
That's bizarre. One of the links gives more details within [1]: > Hertz manages tens of millions of rentals each year, which makes these 30 or so stories excep
by crazygringo 4y ago
That's bizarre. One of the links gives more details within [1]:
> Hertz manages tens of millions of rentals each year, which makes these 30 or so stories exceptionally rare, but not any less bizarre. The recent claims don't explain how exactly these mix-ups happen, but some of the renters reported switching vehicles, upgrading cars, or reporting mechanical issues before being approached by the law. One driver returned a vehicle for a flat tire and was given another to drive instead, and when the company did not complete paperwork for the second vehicle, the car was reported stolen and the police got involved. Another driver was alerted to an expired registration on her rental but was ultimately arrested before she could even return the car a few days later. Francis Alexander, an attorney who is representing some of the falsely-accused renters, says that Hertz’s computer system has a “glitch” that has led to the company-wide pattern of reporting cars stolen.
On the one hand, I can imagine that with employees not filling out forms/screens right and then clocking out, the manager comes in the next day and a car is missing, how do they know it wasn't simply stolen? Better call the police. Especially since if you wait two weeks to "be sure" the car doesn't come back, your chances of recovering it presumably plummet.
On the other hand... employees mess up all the time, so it seems like there'd better be a damn solid reason to presume a vehicle stolen rather than just the regular employee mixup (like security cam footage). And the idea that a computer system could automatically alert police of supposedly stolen vehicles without needing a manager's triple-verification seems incredibly irresponsible and shocking.
[1] https://www.thedrive.com/news/27976/people-are-being-arrested-and-jailed-due-to-hertz-erroneously-reporting-rental-cars-stolen-report https://www.thedrive.com/news/27976/people-are-being-arreste...
- axiolite 4y ago> the manager comes in the next day and a car is missing, how do they know it wasn't simply stolen? Preferably by checking surveillance camera footage before calling the cops.
- erichocean 4y agoThis is the correct answer.
- FireBeyond 4y agoYup, much as it was a pain in the ass, renting from Hertz at Dulles airport showed that they're quite capable of tracking things. Gates in and out with barriers, cameras, LPR systems. Guy handed us an ipad as we pulled up that already had the plate and info from our car. And similar on return. I don't need every rental place to operate like a busy international airport, but they absolutely can track that effectively.
- SilverBirch 4y agoTo be honest, two weeks or not, if a car is stolen it's probably gone forever. It's not like the police are going to assign a detective track down Hertz's stolen car. They stick it on the system and if it happens to pass an officer they'll stop it. The probelm is, the only way it'll ping an officer is if it's still being driven around the area with the same number plates - ie, the probability of it actually being stolen are minimal.
- brigade 4y agoNationwide, at least 60% of stolen vehicles are recovered. CA, which has a 90% overall recovery rate, breaks it down further that motorcycles have under a 60% recovery rate, commercial trucks have an 80% recovery rate, and everything else is over 94%. I don't think the people impacted are renting motorcycles or commercial trucks...
- bink 4y agoI'd bet that areas with the most stringent parking enforcement also have the highest stolen vehicle recovery rates. That seems more likely to me than the police actively seeking out and finding stolen vehicles.
- loonster 4y agoDont cops have automatic plate recognition? Police are searching for a particular stolen vehicle, but likely find them when driving around. Tow truck drivers likely have similar systems.
- yamtaddle 4y agoGonna go out on a limb as guess you're both right: the recovery rate's decent, but only because a pretty high percentage of stolen cars are simply abandoned (think: stealing cars for joy riding, which is pretty damn common in certain circles) and then found in that state, or used in some other crime or series of crimes and eventually swept up because the perpetrators get caught with the car while doing something else, not because the cops put much effort into actually finding the cars. Considering the magnitude of property crimes I've seen them refuse to put any effort into whatsoever, I can't imagine they put special care into solving car thefts. Except when they can solve them basically by accident, which is literally the only way I've ever seen them solve a theft.
- myself248 4y agoI work for automakers' test and development programs. Most companies have a sign-out procedure that involves the keys kept in an automated kiosk that will not release them until you've done the paperwork and submitted a form, and your manager has clicked OK on the confirmation. It's physically impossible to take the car without the system knowing who has it. If it has issues and you bring it back, guess what, you can't get the keys for the replacement until you've done the paperwork... The fact that a company whose literal job is to keep track of cars, can't manage a similar level of rigor, blows my mind and smacks of negligence. If any harm befell these people beyond an hour's hassle and apologies all around, I wish them all success in the courts. Some rental locations do something fairly similar. At the airports I've rented from, there's sort of a free-for-all on the floor itself, but then as you leave, your plate and paperwork are checked. Can't get over the severe-tire-damage strips until the system OKs you and the operator lowers the spikes. Why some locations lack a double-check, well, I suppose you'd have to ask them.
- SilverBirch 4y agoOk, now imagine that everyone you're working with is on minimum wage, and there's often no manager on shift. Oh, and the technology is from the 90s, because a single technological uplift project will soak up a decade of their profits.
- Tostino 4y agoThen they should be dismantled as a company and parted off to pay for the damages they caused.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nhoughto 4y agoThe reducing customer friction arms race means if you can create a process that gives them the keys earlier or more “easily” you win, so if that process has an edge case where one in few hundred thousand gets arrested that might be seen as a net win, not how id design it but others have different tradeoffs!
- manholio 4y ago> says that Hertz’s computer system has a “glitch” that has led to the company-wide pattern of reporting cars stolen We meet again, my oldest and dearest enemy, SAP.
- idontwantthis 4y agoHow do they know who “stole” it if the paperwork wasn’t completed?