3 ms·
If you look at all the top airlines listed, they're basically all carriers that focus on long-haul, international destinations (I mean, Singapore Airlines isn't
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
If you look at all the top airlines listed, they're basically all carriers that focus on long-haul, international destinations (I mean, Singapore Airlines isn't exactly flying domestically...)
With these routes, you have travelers that are less penny-pinching cost conscious, with lots of business travelers and wealthy travelers that can pay more for better service. Plus, many of these airlines (like Qatar) have relatively cheap labor costs.
With American carriers, I'd assume the lions share of their traffic is domestic, where you have a family traveling to grandma and grandpa's house, who'll get a ticket for 5 dollars cheaper even if it means you have to pay extra to use the bathroom. And since many of these flights are in the 2-4 hour range, a lot of travelers feel like they'll "suck up the pain" for a discount if the flight is that short, vs. someone on a 12 hour transatlantic flight.
This isn't just a US issue - think of the European carriers who primarily fly within Europe. Nobody has great love for Ryanair, besides the fact that it's so damn cheap.
- dwater 4y agoLet’s see a list of the best air passengers as well. I guarantee Americans aren’t at the top. The US carriers cater to their customers. We get treated like cattle for good reason.
- nathanaldensr 4y agoAnd the people who aren't cattle tend to avoid the stock pens.
- gumby 4y agoI agree with the reasoning, but then that begs the opposite question: why are cheap flights so much cheaper in Europe and Asia? I think the answer is competition: there are few airlines in the US and they operate as a cartel (consider United threatening to pull out of JFK). As with so many things the US seems to have an air system that is both shitty and expensive.
- gernb 4y agoI've never had an issue on Air Asia which is cheap. International is not the issue. Flying between countries in Europe is not much different than flying between states in the USA. Singapore has tons of countries within 1-2 hours so like flying from SF to Vegas and people do it all the time taking weekend trips. Examples: Malaysia, Indonesia, Thailand, Vietnam, Cambodia, ... The reason USA airlines suck is because, in general, the USA has a culture of poor service. Many USA employees have an attitude that can best be described as "this job sucks, I hate my job, I hate these customers for existing and therefore making me do my job"
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoTBH, for all these posts saying that US airline employees are rude and provide poor service, I wonder if the issue isn't on the other side of the conversation. I've certainly experienced what I'd perhaps call "curt" service, but even then it's usually the case that the employee just has a ton of shit to do and is trying to move along the line quickly. The vast, vast majority of service I've received has been kind and courteous. To be clear, I've certainly had horrible airline experiences (e.g. getting stuck on a tarmac for hours), but rarely if ever is that the fault of an individual front-line employee. What I've seen far more often, especially since the pandemic, is travelers acting like they were born in a barn, sometimes to the point of outright abuse towards employees. I can certainly commiserate with travel frustration, but so often I see people that take it out, rudely and unfairly, on employees who aren't empowered to do anything about it.
- Ekaros 4y agoMaybe this could be solved if tipping was expected on the flights. Have some money collection when boarding or off-boarding.
- jahewson 4y agoThis is the wrong take. US airlines’ profit per passenger is typically 3x that of European airlines, so Americans are paying far more to get treated worse. The reason is that US airlines are larger and more consolidated and so can easily hold monopolies on routes. Unfortunately such consolidation has been happening in Europe too in recent years.
- sologoub 4y agoAir France is on that list at number 8 and they do a lot of flights both domestically and EU-wide (which is basically domestic if you compare to say US, especially west coast to east coast flights). Flying in US is much more unpleasant than in EU and even at top tickets (first/business) you don’t event get the lounge access in US. Express lanes are questionable and any security benefits require pre registering with TSApre or whatever. Even Air France’s low cost partner Transavia is pretty great and very price competitive. Their upfront product includes fast track airport access and only costs a little more.
- plugger 4y agoQantas doesn't fit the long-haul international only carrier description