6 ms·
I have the reverse... Unless you have a thinkpad or some other popular hardware, you'll find Linux barely works at all out of the box, and even with hours of f
by londons_explore 4y ago
I have the reverse...
Unless you have a thinkpad or some other popular hardware, you'll find Linux barely works at all out of the box, and even with hours of fiddling around, you'll still have to live without some features.
For example, power saving features, sleep and hibernate, screen brightness controls, fingerprint readers, keyboard hotkeys and backlights, etc. rarely work. Prepare for broken external hdmi ports or USB stuck at USB 2.0 speeds. Have fun with the fan stuck on either max or zero, or the CPU stuck at the lowest clock speed.
There are still lots of things you have to go hunting for the right old firmware version for.
I think Linux is only great if you have whatever hardware distro developers have, because that will be all that works out of the box.
- ssivark 4y agoBut isn’t that basically “good enough” if you know you want Linux and can either afford the latest thinkpads or are okay with a slightly bulkier older Thinkpad? Seems not worse than different from needing Apple hardware to use Apple software… (though in practice there is a significantly wider array of hardware that has very good support for the software)
- trelane 4y agoYes, running Linux on Windows hardware is often a recipe for misery, or at least dealing with obscure kernel parameters. Which is why I've said and will say again: slapping Linux on Windows hardware is a mug's game. Buy it preinstalled, from a company that supports it. We actually have that option these days, and it's amazing. Some days, I swear the smartest thing Apple ever did was prevent users from slapping OSX on commodity Windows hardware.
- jahewson 4y agoWhat is “Windows hardware”?
- codewiz 4y agoHardware sold with Windows preinstalled, by vendors who won't support anything else than Windows. I simply avoid them.
- pessimizer 4y agoOr just look up your "windows hardware" before you buy and check compatibility. Companies that sell laptops with preinstalled Linux are far more often than not just selling rebranded "windows hardware." The benefit is that you get a support number, and that they have paid attention to the Linux compatibility of the models in their range.
- trelane 4y ago> Companies that sell laptops with preinstalled Linux are far more often than not just selling rebranded "windows hardware." What examples do you have of this?
- p4bl0 4y agoDell did that.
- trelane 4y agoWhich models did they do that with? I'd heard the xps with Linux was pretty good, at least for a while.
- p4bl0 4y agoYes, most XPS and Latitude laptops.
- trelane 4y agoWhat were the equivalent white box vendors and did they ship with the same firmwares? Citation to read up in this?
- p4bl0 4y agoI don't understand what you mean by "white box". Just look for yourself it's really not hard to find: https://www.dell.com/en-us/lp/linux-systems https://www.dell.com/en-us/lp/linux-systems
- onetimeusename 4y agoThat has been my experience too. Even then if you get a next generation thinkpad that is slightly newer than what has been "blessed" by the community, there is a good chance that a lot of essential hardware won't work. Fortunately, in the case of Lenovo they do actively track issues with hardware and issue new bios versions that fix compatibility but even having to install new firmware when you are using Linux can cause major headaches and worries.
- marcodiego 4y ago> but even having to install new firmware when you are using Linux can cause major headaches and worries. I thought lvfs ( https://fwupd.org/ https://fwupd.org/ ) had fixed that.
- onetimeusename 4y agoya that service has been very helpful and tracking issues is great, but there can still be issues when installing. For example, I am dealing with a bug found in this list of issues: https://github.com/fwupd/firmware-lenovo/issues https://github.com/fwupd/firmware-lenovo/issues on one of my laptops.
- Mikeb85 4y agoFrom everything I've read, ThinkPads (IBM/Red Hat devs seem to use them), Acers (have pretty standard parts, nothing funky), Dells and HPs (both have Linux dev laptops) all seem to run pretty well. The worst seem to be gaming laptops, non-Lenovo Chinese brands, Asus, etc...
- mod 4y agoI have an HP gaming laptop. Zero issues running ubuntu. Detects my SD card reader and everything.
- chickenchicken 4y agoThinkpad T400 G2: the fan keeps running in full speed randomly.
- Mikeb85 4y agoI mean, that's getting near the age where it's a miracle it even turns on any more...
- vetinari 4y agoI had the original T400; the issue was Intel Turbo Boost. At the time, the workaround was to disable Turbo Boost, but as far as I remember, it was fixed eventually and the workaround was not needed anymore.
- wolfram74 4y agoCorroborating this on the asus, I got one back in 2020 when my laptop gave up the ghost. Tried trudging through but I couldn't get comfortable with opensuse, things like on boot the mouse not responding, spontaneously rebooting when I tried to change volume, wifi card being throttled or just useless. All of it failing just enough I never quite trusted it.
- bee_rider 4y agoRecent Asus zenbooks seem to have a decent reputation.
- jolmg 4y ago> Unless you have a thinkpad or some other popular hardware, you'll find Linux barely works at all out of the box Well, I can share that it works out of the box with Panasonic toughbooks, at least.
- odysseus 4y agoI had a Thinkpad with Ubuntu and still had many of the problems you mention and more: - Barely ever waking from sleep, especially with external monitor connected - Screen brightness keyboard controls didn't work (needed to use a CLI tool to control gamma as a hacky workaround) - Had to power cycle repeatedly to get to a desktop when booting - Not working reliably in clamshell mode - Randomly forgetting external monitor scaling - Accessibility features like screen zooming are very poorly done compared to Mac's Ctrl-MouseWheel (which zooms entire screen without crashing) Things actually got worse as I upgraded to newer kernels. The wake from sleep problem is the #1 productivity killer I had. I had to leave the machine running all the time just to do my job. A good post on why Linux has so much trouble waking is: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25386605 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25386605
- bee_rider 4y agoSleep has become less of an issue recently, at least in my experience. Modern laptop CPUs idle in such a low power state. I just set up my built-in display to disable when the lid is closed. Seems sufficient.
- londons_explore 4y agoIf you leave it anywhere in a bag not plugged in, then you have to be constantly thinking 'I only have 30 hours left till the battery dies and I lose everything I had open'. Not a great feeling.
- bee_rider 4y agoI'm not 30 hours away from electricity very often, to the point where it wouldn't be a big deal to just save and shutdown, since it is a rare occasion. But I live a very predictable lifestyle, I guess if you are exploring London you probably end up in unexpected situations often.
- akvadrako 4y agoI've also had a recent Thinkpad X1 with Ubuntu and had several major issues, for example no working microphone for the first 6 months.
- teawrecks 4y agoI've been running manjaro on a dell xps 15 2-in-1 without issue for about 3 or 4 years. The only oddity is that it has the intel kbl-g gpu, so sometimes you have to manually choose which gpu to use if the app is badly behaving and you don't want it to suck your battery dry in an hour.
- ratherbefuddled 4y ago> Unless you have a thinkpad or some other popular hardware, you'll find Linux barely works at all out of the box, and even with hours of fiddling around, you'll still have to live without some features. I've had it work first time, perfectly on: - Tongfangs, 3 different models - Lenovo, many different models - Clevos, 2 different models - Asus Zenbooks, 2 different models - Too many Dells to count - Asus Zen2 desktop I have yet to find a device it doesn't work on. I've never had to mess about with the kernel params or do anything clever with fans except install the sensors package and run it. The only shortcoming I've noticed is it the fingerprint readers were hit and miss, but this is mostly because the device manufacturers didn't bother with drivers.
- bee_rider 4y agoI've got a Zenbook flip, I'm really impressed with the Linux performance. It even doesn't suck too badly as a tablet, which exceeds my expectations.
- jll29 4y agoAfter 20 years of luck with Linux on many laptops, I couldn't get any Linux to Microsoft Surface 3 Laptop.
- tomrod 4y agoAren't those just surfaces with a keyboard -- like, same bespoke hardware and similar?
- maxbaines 4y agoI have been using this on Intel SL3 works great https://github.com/linux-surface/linux-surface https://github.com/linux-surface/linux-surface Also works on AMD but did get crashes sometime and sometimes need to boot into Windows to reset audio….
- hutzlibu 4y ago"I've had it work first time, perfectly on" In my world, running perfectly means, runs at least as good as windows. Same battery life and performance. No glitches with suspend, hibernation, etc. And I doubt that. Not because windows is so awesome, but because hardware manufacture write and optimize their drivers for windows. And linux is a way smaller market and one with intentional no stable driver ABI (to force the vendors to open source their drivers). That is the situation. And it sucks, because I do not like to use windows, but I need my mobile devices to be reliable.
- just_boost_it 4y agoI got a Lenovo and it worked with no issues with pop os.
- chickenimprint 4y agoI slapped Arch Linux on a new HP 2 in 1 and everything except for the fingerprint reader worked out of the box, including the stylus. Not even a single controller of my weird Chinese 10-port USB-C dongle refused to work.
- danjoredd 4y agoI have an Acer Aspire and a self-built PC and both of those work just fine with Linux. All the hardware drivers work on both of them no problem. I didn't even build the desktop FOR linux, it just works when I run it.