4 ms·
I want to offer an alternative to a couple of commentators bringing up inflation rates: We have identified a real-world, physical problem (look in the big tank
by roenxi 4y ago
I want to offer an alternative to a couple of commentators bringing up inflation rates:
We have identified a real-world, physical problem (look in the big tank, no oil).
The proposed solution here is - and I think this is a fair paraphrase - "well we can print money and people will trade oil for that".
This is an almost absurdly high-risk assumption. Financial solutions might just not work to fix physical problems. That sort of plan is pretty close to an endgame where the US will collapse because it no longer has the energy to sustain complex society. If there is a day where the US needs the strategic reserve - which we haven't seen yet - money will not solve the problem. That is, in fact, the reason why there even is a strategic reserve instead of a JIT strategy.
The accountants might recognise it through inflation or some other metric, but attempting to execute this plan could literally involve hitherto unknown catastrophe in the US, like being invaded or mass starvation. One of those things that is supposed to happen only in other countries.
- seanp2k2 4y agoGood thing, then, that the politicians who engineered this collapse will all be dead and gone by the time their children have to live through it!
- gg82 4y agoI think you are mistaken with how long before this is going to happen. Europe is already experiencing the effects and this winter will feel the full effects of this. The US is probably got a bit more time... but Russia, China, India, etc are working on bypassing the US Dollar for their trade, reducing the amount of trade that occurs in US Dollars. As for reserve currency status, the politicians have also made the US dollar more unfriendly when they froze the Russian Central banks reserves. This will result in other countries reconsidering where they store their wealth.
- bobthepanda 4y agoIf your solution to USD being restricted is to trade in CNY you‘re in for a rude awakening. CNY does not freely flow across the Chinese border, and the government will not hesitate to put strict capital controls to limit inflows and outflows. The government knows that this prevents it from being used as an international reserve currency, but they would rather keep stability in the Chinese economy.
- eternauta3k 4y agoWhat exactly do you mean by "flow across the Chinese border"? It's my understanding that all electronic USD are in the USA, either directly in the central bank or indirectly through another bank which has an account in the central bank. They can't actually flow out of the country, except as cash.
- bobthepanda 4y agoChina controls the use of CNY to buy non-domestic things, particularly foreign exchange. Domestic companies and savers‘ “movement” of the currency is tightly controlled, and the government has immediately tightened the screws on everyone before. USD is not controlled in this manner, which makes it pretty easy to obtain. One of the important features of a reserve currency is easy obtainability and convertibility, but this runs counter to China’s internal stability goals.
- thewileyone 4y agoThat's why China created the Digital Yuan for overseas trade.
- bobthepanda 4y agoDigital Yuan are currently not approved for international use. And they seem to be subject to the exact same Chinese capital controls that traditional CNY are subject to, if I’m not mistaken.
- vineyardmike 4y agoExcept there is plenty of oil all over the world flowing, and sellers eager for USD. The “big tank” can be filled still, with an endless supplies of USD, and it’s no where near empty now. The bigger issue IMO is that over the last couple elections we’ve seen politicians trying to buy votes. Trump cut taxes, then delayed their payment, then wrote stimulus checks, and now Biden forgave student loans and is spending US oil reserves to keep gas prices low until *checks notes* November.
- roenxi 4y agoThat has been true for decades it might not be true right now - otherwise why is the US running down its strategic reserve? Obviously the Americans don't believe they can print money and exchange it for oil - or they would do so. Paper for oil is a much better trade than running down the strategic reserves. Their relationships with a lot of the top 10 oil producers range between highly competitive to low-intensity war.
- vineyardmike 4y ago> otherwise why is the US running down its strategic reserve? Because it keeps domestic oil prices low which keeps an electorate happy. The government can’t force OPEC to pump more oil at a low price nor can they set prices, but they CAN increase oil supply on the market through reserves.
- roenxi 4y agoThat sits in conflict with the idea there are lots of people who want to sell the US oil though, does it not? They don't. The US dollar isn't exciting enough for them to go out and pump oil. It isn't obvious that the US firing up the printing presses would suddenly make them excited at the thought because it isn't like that gives them a better deal. The US has the same capability to get them goods, services and assurances before & after the printing. And unless the electorate are very stupid (an option, I suppose) they will note that at some point they will be paying even higher prices if the SPR is refilled. It'll be even worse than it would be right now.