4 ms·
"on the basis of ongoing market prices, without any medium term revenue stabilisation mechanism." This looks clever when market price is 50 per MWh, but when P
by tialaramex 4y ago
"on the basis of ongoing market prices, without any medium term revenue stabilisation mechanism."
This looks clever when market price is 50 per MWh, but when Putin decides to cut off the cheap gas you were using to make a lot of electricity and the market price rises to 500 per MWh, suddenly revenue stabilisation looks very different.
The UK has a bunch of wind farms which are quite old (up to about 30 years), and so even if they were subsidised when built the subsidy has expired but the wind farm is still there and still making electricity (typical design life is 25 years, in most cases as lifespan approaches the owners want to build a taller wind farm). However today the market price they're selling electricity for is far higher, as much as ten times. Newer wind farms have a Contract for Difference as revenue stabilisation, with the actual price they're paid fixed (a "strike price") and of course those strike prices are far lower than today's gas shortage market prices.
So there's pressure for government to agree that old wind farms get a CfD, with a price lower than today's market price but higher, perhaps much higher than future market prices, since now stabilisation is supporting a different government policy (don't let voters starve or freeze to death) rather than the original one (subsidise "green" energy solutions)
The irony is that if a previous UK government had built more wind power in the early 2000s, using more subsidies, that would actually save money today, even though it would have outraged fiscal conservatives at the time who imagined it would never pay off.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> The irony is that if a previous UK government had built more wind power in the early 2000s, using more subsidies, that would actually save money today, even though it would have outraged fiscal conservatives at the time who imagined it would never pay off. Most self-proclaimed fiscal conservatives I cone across don't seem to grasp the difference between spending and investment. When they do understand investment, they want to attract private capital at a cost of 5% yoy, when government could borrow money at 0.1% yoy (Uk Hincley C debacle)
- ncmncm 4y agoIn other words, "fiscal conservatives'" chief desire is to move government money into private pockets at maximum rate in exchange for little or no value. "Fiscal responsibility" is just their smokescreen. They certainly understand the difference between spending and investment. They just want to own the investment part, while government does the spending part.
- jtbayly 4y agoIsn’t private capital the opposite of government spending?
- ncmncm 4y agoNot when it starts out as government spending, sluicing wholesale into a gaping, capacious private-capital pocket. We see this most frequently in military contracts, although NASA and public-works projects often oblige; most particularly nuke plants, of late. Public works and NASA innovate by sluicing to an impressively wide array of smaller yet still gaping pockets.
- jtbayly 4y agoBut that’s basically what is being praised as “investment” here. The question is whether government spending is good, or whether we should let private capital fund it? (If private capital will fund it, but will then want to profit off of it.) The argument was that it would make sense to spend government money in that case.
- makomk 4y agoHah. There's actually an interesting UK-specific quirk that the comment you're replying to has missed: if a previous UK government had built more wind power in the 2000s using more subsidies that wouldn't actually save us money, because those subsidies weren't structured as CfDs. They were just outright direct subsidy payments on top of the market price of electricity which is set by the most expensive generator needed to fil demand (usually gas). So building more back then could actually have lead to higher power bills even though they should be cheaper. Newer wind farms don't have this problem only because we ended up with a big-C Conservative government that restructured the subsidies for new projects sometime around the 2013-2016 period as CfDs at prices which are now substantially lower than the market cost of electricity. That government is generally portrayed as pretty much the archtypical example of pro-austerity, anti-green, anti-investment "fiscal conservatives" who let corporations benefit at our expense. From the news reporting you'd think that they were the ones which structured deals in ways that let energy producers get undeserved windfall profits. The media even let Ed Milliband, who was actually in charge of energy when the opposition Labour party were last in power, blame them for the fact that these windfall profits are happening without challenging him on his own role in those contracts.
- tialaramex 4y ago> that wouldn't actually save us money, because those subsidies weren't structured as CfDs. Ah, maybe I wasn't clear, I'm not thinking about generators who get subsidised, I'm thinking about the effect of the generation landscape on market prices. Even when there aren't enough wind generators to mean we don't need to buy any gas having more wind allows us to get better prices for the gas generation we need. Right now there's about 7GW of wind power online and about 15GW of gas turbines. Lets ignore for now the fact we're just selling most of the wind power to our neighbours, that's 7GW which could otherwise have been supplied by the gas turbines. 7GW worth of higher gas turbine price bids were ignored because (of course) bids for wind power are basically zero. What if it was 15GW of wind and 7GW of gas? The auction still hinges on a gas price, but now it's not the cheapest 15GW of gas, it's the cheapest 7GW of gas. If I built my gas turbine station on expensive land and thus I want higher prices to recoup my mortgage costs, I need to choose, take a loss with a lower bid or risk bidding too high and getting nothing until next auction ? Overall the effect is lower prices with more wind generation. I agree that CfDs are the right mechanism by the way, and it shouldn't be tricky to find me talking about that long before gas prices shot up, and even before COVID, although you might not find it before Putin stole Crimea because I don't think I knew how this worked back then.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThe current blog author has a series of in-depth articles on the current European energy crisis which really dig into this, random highlights: France is not quite ready to accept that nuclear is not the future, so will be subsidizing it for a while rather than building as much renewables as would be ideal for cheaper, more stable energy: https://jeromeaparis.substack.com/p/edfs-woes-are-a-bigger-long-term https://jeromeaparis.substack.com/p/edfs-woes-are-a-bigger-l... > Today, we face a new situation where it’s not just new nuclear which is no longer competitive, but even the much needed refurbishment of the existing nuclear plants in France (“le grand carénage“) is not likely to be cheaper than building new renewable capacity. EDF recently estimated that, after all planned renovations for the 2014-2025 period, the 50-year average real cost of its electricity would be 55 EUR/MWh. In contrast, the recent tenders for offshore wind have yielded a strike of 44 EUR/MWh. These prices directly threaten the industrial strategy of EDF which has tried to keep as much as possible of its nuclear fleet running. There is little awareness of that reality in France. What Germany really did wrong with their energy market: https://jeromeaparis.substack.com/p/how-messed-up-was-germanys-energy https://jeromeaparis.substack.com/p/how-messed-up-was-german... Basically, right-wingers moaning about "subsidies", just at the critical time Germany should have been pushing ahead with offshore wind and costing the country a lot of money as a result as they would have been running by now.
- pyrale 4y ago> the 50-year average real cost of its electricity would be 55 EUR/MWh. In contrast, the recent tenders for offshore wind have yielded a strike of 44 EUR/MWh. As they say on child toys, battery not included.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoYes, neither nuclear nor offshore wind exactly match the demand profile so some kind of storage/demand-response/complementary generation assets etc. is required. Offshore wind does peak in winter along with European demand, nuclear similarly schedules its maintenance and refueling for the summer which helps but both will almost certainly overproduce relative to current demand during the night on a predictable daily schedule if rolled out to any great extent so lithium batteries (in EVs or otherwise) do a lot to integrate their power over the short term as well as the TOU rates France has used for decades to make the most of nuclear power. > EDF advises “The Heures Pleines option will suit you especially if you want to take advantage of price per kWh at the most advantageous to the day (ie 8 hours daily peak)”. Basically if you have a night-storage electric water heater, or storage radiators, then you would be best to choose this option, which provides off peak electricity rates to heat your appliances. See peak and off-peak rates on the EDF website.
- Ekaros 4y agoIt is probable that wind isn't getting those highest rates. As it is in some cases the cause for high prices. When it is windy it is windy over substantial area and thus they produce lot. Meaning that there is lot of power to sell at market at any rate. Thus driving the price at the moment down.
- justincormack 4y agoWe don't have enough wind for that to be an issue, the price is still set by the marginal cost of gas as we never produce enough wind to not need gas https://grid.iamkate.com/ https://grid.iamkate.com/ If we had twice as much wind power this might start to be an issue.