4 ms·
If they just put that weapon in a bench rest and kept firing, how tight a group would it shoot?
by Animats 4y ago
If they just put that weapon in a bench rest and kept firing, how tight a group would it shoot?
- Alupis 4y agoAt these ranges, wind, heat, humidity and more play huge factors into the bullet's trajectory. I highly doubt even a bench rest would yield anything resembling a group at this range.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoCould you build a smarter bullet that could actively compensate?
- Alupis 4y agoIt's been tried, but I'm not sure how successful they are/were. Modern day military artillery has "smart shells"[1] as well, which can move small deflection surfaces to "steer" the shell towards it's target. I do not know the limits of these systems... and of course they would be exceedingly expensive for your average sport shooter. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M982_Excalibur https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M982_Excalibur
- wahern 4y agoThe U.S. has apparently sent M982 Excalibur shells to Ukraine, according to leaked budget documents: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-09-08/most-accurate-us-artillery-shell-is-quietly-added-to-ukraine-aid https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-09-08/most-accu... AFAIU, Russia doesn't have any munitions comparable to these guided artillery shells or even the guided HIMARS rockets. Arguably these deployments in Ukraine may inch Russia a little closer to resorting to tactical nukes. Their military doctrine relies on tactical nukes as an answer to conventional weapons beyond their own capability, and that's part of the reason Russia has so many tactical nukes deployed (at least at sea).
- topspin 4y ago> The U.S. has apparently sent M982 Excalibur shells to Ukraine, according to leaked budget documents The DOD straight up announced that a recent military aid package included 1000 M982 Excalibur rounds. Another thing the US has been providing is M1156 PGK. It's a kit used to make unguided rounds more precise by adding GPS guidance and it dramatically reduces long range CEP. Anecdotally I have noticed a large increase the frequency single shot artillery strikes on Russian tanks appearing in Telegram videos. Previously it would take a few shots to adjust fire. Now it's often boom! tank gone with no previous impacts evident.
- _kbh_ 4y ago> AFAIU, Russia doesn't have any munitions comparable to these guided artillery shells or even the guided HIMARS rockets. Arguably these deployments in Ukraine may inch Russia a little closer to resorting to tactical nukes. Their military doctrine relies on tactical nukes as an answer to conventional weapons beyond their own capability, and that's part of the reason Russia has so many tactical nukes deployed (at least at sea). What, Russias nuclear doctrine is to use nukes against the threatening of their own sovereignty and borders, not against conventional weapons that are better than theres. What kind of pathetic military has a nuclear doctrine to drop nukes because the other country has modern technology?. It doesn't matter anyway because Russias nukes are just for sabre rattling, Russia knows full well the any use of nuclear weapons, tactical or not in Ukraine will bring an overwhelming response that will likely just straight up end the war in Ukraines favour.
- tempay 4y agoI think you might be confusing tactical and strategic nuclear weapons. As far as I know strategic weapons are only for protecting their sovereignty and the use of tactical weapons is potentially more flexible.
- _kbh_ 4y ago> I think you might be confusing tactical and strategic nuclear weapons. As far as I know strategic weapons are only for protecting their sovereignty and the use of tactical weapons is potentially more flexible. I don't believe their doctrine makes a distinction, because the rest of the world would not make a huge distinction. Im happy to be wrong thought if you could link a primary source.
- randomswede 4y agoThere's also Strix[1], a self-guiding anti-armor mortar round. Not actually sure when it was taken into use, I recall hearing rumours about it being in development in the late 80s, and the Swedish model designation (m/94) indicates it was accepted in 1994. But, 120 mm is a lot bigger than anything I'd be comfortable firing from a rifle. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strix_mortar_round https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strix_mortar_round
- wahern 4y agoSmart bullets exist: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_bullet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_bullet Here's a live-fire video of the EXACTO: https://youtu.be/YoOaJclkSZg https://youtu.be/YoOaJclkSZg All the available information is several years old, now. I figure either the EXACTO (or successor) has secretly been deployed, or it proved impractical.
- Animats 4y agoIt may have fallen into the category of weapons too big to lug around, and inferior to vehicle-mounted systems. That's happened before. About 10 years ago, the USMC was trying out an "automatic mortar". This accepted fire direction like artillery - forward observer designates target, data is passed to weapon, weapon duly clobbers target. Worked OK, too heavy for infantry, and there are vehicle-mounted systems already deployed which can do that job.
- FlingPoo 4y agoAt those ranges you'd likely have to take into account the Coriolis Effect as well.
- kodachrome64 4y agoThe Coriolis effect would be constant and wouldn't affect your grouping.