8 ms·
This is a good summary of a specific motif in The Wire, but I think it misses the larger message of the show: that there is no institutional or even individual
by woodruffw 4y ago
This is a good summary of a specific motif in The Wire, but I think it misses the larger message of the show: that there is no institutional or even individual difference between the two recurring groups in the show (Baltimore's police and drug dealers).
In the show, both groups of individuals are subject to their institutions: power figures come and go (and bring changes that superficially alter the state of affairs), but the game fundamentally remains the same. This repeats itself in every explored institution: industry, schools, news, &c.
In other words: there is no avoiding "corruption," only moving it around. The show's few "good" characters are characterized primarily by the ways in which their personal corruption does or does not affect the corruption of the larger institution they belong to (Daniels' FBI investigation, for example, or Kima's personal descent.)
- d23 4y agoMan, I need to give the wire another shot.
- jwlake 4y agoThe first season is slow but it really picks up.
- jeffbee 4y agoI don’t see how anyone could watch the opening scene of The Wire and not be compelled to watch the rest of it.
- lupire 4y agoThe show is extremely dangerous to mental health, if you care about living in a good world and can't handle the impossibility of it.
- jeffbee 4y agoSimon's previous TV show, and his book, revolved around the rape and murder of an 11-year-old girl. I feel like that was already enough to squash hopes of living in a good world.
- lostlogin 4y agoThere is some excellent comedy in it too though. Dark for sure, but very funny.
- jamiek88 4y agoNigga, is you taking notes on a motherfucking criminal conspiracy?
- Godel_unicode 4y agoI love that scene, it’s such a great example of cargo-culting.
- UncleMeat 4y agoIt really is a stunning scene. As a big fan, I do wish they cut out a little of McNulty's repetition to the audience so they understand the slang but the final button on the scene is just so good it is impossible to really complain.
- mayormcmatt 4y agoFWIW, I restarted it last week after falling off years ago before finishing the first season. It was my problem, not the show's: I wasn't paying attention, my attention span was awful. This time, I'm paying attention and have trouble not watching three or more episodes per night. What a riveting show!
- JackFr 4y agoFunny - the first time I tried it didn’t catch. Felt ‘meh’ after 1.5 episodes. Then went back and tried again and have watched the entire run twice and consider myself a big fan.
- chrisweekly 4y agoIt's a slow burn for sure. But so worth the investment.
- MobileVet 4y agoIt is daunting at first, if for no other reason than the shear number of characters. It probably takes 3 episodes just to understand who is who, despite the amazing acting. There is no show that I have seen before or after The Wire that puts such a lens to American culture in the inner city. It is a masterpiece of story telling. The writing and acting are just spot on and the story... it's brilliant.
- lostlogin 4y agoThe re-release has upped the quality. I’m not American and struggled with the accents for a few episodes, but it’s absolutely the best show I’ve ever watched.
- pphysch 4y ago> there is no avoiding "corruption," only moving it around. American culture, and to a lesser extent Western culture in general, encourages this kind of corruption. If your culture elevates individualism and freedom above social responsibility and harmony, then your institutions will be systemically corrupted by selfish individuals. So yes, given a culture that prioritizes individualism above all, corruption is unavoidable. In other news, a former CCP top government minister was just sentenced to death for corruption. Incentives at work.
- spywaregorilla 4y agoIs that why all the local governments are collapsing under their off the books debts?
- woodruffw 4y agoWell, I don't think the intended message of The Wire is "adopt the CCP's anti-corruption measures." That's editorialization on our part as viewers. I also don't think the show has a particularly anti-individual message: individual police officers and drug dealers are repeatedly shown as struggling within a collectively dysfunctional system, and individual members of each group are shown as themselves corrupt while being protected by the collective. The show is more nihilistic than proscriptive, other than the small handful of "successes" that occur (like Hamsterdam).
- pphysch 4y agoThe Wire is radical, but not quite radical to the point of openly questioning the foundations of modern American culture. That would be crazy in ~2002.
- woodruffw 4y agoRight. The show is even conservative, by some measures: the police are generally shown deference by the show's writers (even when individual cops are openly characterized negatively).
- 4y ago
- jonnybgood 4y agoI think the exception is Omar. I don’t see Omar as corrupt. I think many people see him as one of the “good” ones, relatively speaking. He didn’t move around what he was and what he was about. He stayed completely true to it. He didn’t have a larger institution as you say. He was his own institution.
- kahrl 4y agoOmar comin.
- dredmorbius 4y agoThe Cheese stands alone.
- jfengel 4y agoAnd I saw that phrase on a poster in a Baltimore takeout joint just the other day. It resonates powerfully still.
- woodruffw 4y agoOmar doesn't fit as easily into the mold, but you can see ways in which his amoral characterization establish his roles in the criminal and LEO institutions: he's an opportunist, stealing from those who can't go to the police to report crime. He's his own institution, but he isn't above his own drives for vengeance and thrill: later seasons characterize him as depressed by his own infamy, driving him to seek out new criminal targets to keep the heat up.
- Aerroon 4y agoOmar would also realistically fizzle out. He would either get killed or end up killing innocents by accident. There's only so many times intimidation works without serious incidents.
- UncleMeat 4y agoAnd yet, after his death he is replaced.
- ep103 4y agoMan, this is NOT the main message I took away from the show. The main message of the show, as I viewed it, was: The drug trade is fundamentally an outgrowth of a society that thinks in individualist terms, but lacks either the social collective and moral knowledge or the social collective and moral willingness to think outside of those individualist terms and individualist responsibilities sufficiently far enough to fix the issue. This is because everyone in the show is acting as a rational agent following their own personal incentives. And in aggregate, these personal incentives become social forces that guide the actions of the institutions these people create in order to further their pursuit of these personal incentives. These are collectively referred to as "the rules of the game". The show goes to extreme length to show, over and over again, that so long as everyone is following their individual incentives, IE following the rules of the game, it is NOT possible to solve the drug trade. The drug trade is itself a natural outgrowth of following personal incentives. (Why hamsterdam fails, why jimmy can't solve all crimes, why cedric can't reform the station himself, etc) The show then makes very, very overt points to show that we all still have individualist responsibility, and our individual choices can and will make positive and negative impacts on the wider community and the people within our sphere of influence. It then goes further and shows that by making the correct moral choices, by looking outside of our own individualist incentives, you CAN change the rules of the game for the people within your sphere of influence (Carter teaching humane police work, or opening a gym in a bad neighborhood). Similarly, doing the opposite and doubling down on personal incentive more ruthlessly will likely make the drug trade worse, but may personally benefit you more in the short term (Marlo, the journalist). Phrased another way: if the drug trade could be solved by individual action, it would have been so already. The issues that plague Baltimore are issues that result from individualist thinking, and not being able to see outside of that. The only person who really sits in a position of power large enough to successfully change the rules of the game, while acting solely as an individual, is the Mayor. But he is also very strongly incentivized NOT to do this, as doing so will require him to self-sacrifice his personal career as a politician. (He refuses to raise money from the suburbs, which are a voting block he would need to run for state Governor. He assumes that the suburban voters would punish him for that, even if he spent the money on Baltimore schools, due to their focus on their self-interest). So again, because he chooses to think in terms of personal incentives, the issue will not change. The show, therefore questions why America and Americans act this way. The show is hoping that the reason we act this way is because we lack the knowledge about how everyone only thinking for themselves results in "the rules of the game" and puts everyone in this situation. It HOPES that if a show like The Wire exists, and teaches everyone this fact, then the individual characters in the show might look up for a moment, and demand, collectively, that the rules of the game change, by thinking outside of their own personal station in life. You will notice meaningfully absent from any character in the show is any type of character that actively attempts to do this, perhaps by organizing a social movement for meaningful social change, collectively, at the community level. This is what the writers talk about when asked "what should people do." The show fears that people don't know, because they don't care. That people are fine with the pain and suffering that comes from the drug trade, so long as they get to pursue their individual incentives. To counter this, the show tries to point out that the characters that go the first path, and make the conscious choice to benefit their local community by thinking outside their own situation (the boxer guy, carter, bunny) all wind up happier and with better lives, than the ones who "succeed" at the game on individualist terms (marlo, barksdales, sobotka), in the long term.
- pelasaco 4y agothe article has no meat, so empty, that we prefer to focus in "The Wire" :)
- floxy 4y agoIsn't the morally ambiguous protagonist the American TV/movie trope?
- woodruffw 4y agoIt is indeed: American audiences love characters that are basically just conduits for "does the ends justify the means"-type plots. I think The Wire is a bit better than that, though: the moral ambiguity in The Wire seldom boils down to justifying the means: plenty of characters are just bad in an individual capacity while doing good in their professional capacity, or vice versa. The Omar character is probably the most straightforward in terms of the trope, but even he does not act for the sake of the ends: he does it because it's all he knows.
- Upgrayyed_U 4y agoSure, it is now, but was that the case 20+ years ago when The Wire first aired?
- woodruffw 4y agoI think it's become more common, but the subgenre of "surveillance" media has always had elements of this. Compare The Conversation (1974)[1], for example. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Conversation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Conversation
- floxy 4y agoHan shot first. Also, like every movie starring Clint Eastwood?
- spiderjerusalem 4y agoI believe David Simon said somewhere that one way to think about The Wire is they took Greek mythology and replaced the gods with institutions.