4 ms·
Man, I feel this. I worked for a corporation that was so change-averse, that we needed to buy our development systems on eBay. They actually had a point, and
by ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago
Man, I feel this.
I worked for a corporation that was so change-averse, that we needed to buy our development systems on eBay.
They actually had a point, and it was hard to argue against, but I found it absolutely infuriating, as the solution was to plan for change, and establish a process to be constantly evaluating and refining for new developments.
Instead, it was "Wait until we can't bear it any longer, then have a huge screaming match meeting." A new budget would be approved for new machines (and, thus, new operating systems and development tools), processes would be updated, and that would sit, until it was no longer new.
As I said, it was hard to argue against, because it was a 100-year-old company that had been successfully delivering really high-end stuff, since Day One. They did that by being so conservative that they hadn't discovered fire, yet. Measure 300 times, cut once, etc.
When there was a problem, it escalated quickly (and was used as fuel to tighten things down even more), as the company was held to standards that are probably up there with NASA.
Speaking of NASA, I can't help but notice that this rather plucky little outfit, called SpaceX, seems to be running circles around them. They seem to have figured out how to "fail fast," yet also deliver insanely high Quality stuff.
Might be worth ignoring their CEO's tweets, and look at what they are doing...
- pclmulqdq 4y agoSpaceX shows the success of using modern, commodity hardware rather than purchased-by-government contract obsolete components for space applications. The same is true for the cubesat revolution. I honestly think the idea of "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" is pretty silly as applied to large, engineered systems. If your system is more than 1000 lines of code, I guarantee you have a latent bug somewhere. Even if you don't have any bugs, the ecosystem around you changes so fast that you eventually will.
- Gibbon1 4y agoSpaceX shows the advantage of not allowing aerospace lobbyists and congress to design things. That's how you get the SLS with it's inane H2/LOX first stage and solid propellant boosters.
- mgbmtl 4y agoI'd be curious though, in 20 years, what kind of technical debt SpaceX will accumulate. I mean, as vendors, part of the debt we inherit is that of our customers. Then our customers switch to something else. As vendors, how do we support both the past and the future? By making changes opt-in if possible, but still, that technical debt is there, and requires devs and other support staff. I don't work in anything rocket-science, but I stopped asking clients if they want to upgrade. We decide when to do it for them, and we take the blame if something goes sideways. I still prefer to have something break, than lose a client because they didn't realize they could upgrade instead of opting for another product (and they probably silently grew resentful at the lack of features of the old version).
- soperj 4y ago> I'd be curious though, in 20 years, what kind of technical debt SpaceX will accumulate. They're already 20 years in. Wonder if there's anything left from the beginning (or if it all got blown up).
- Beached 4y agoI mean falcon 9 is the tech debt. they are no longer working on it, only maintenance mode. their goal is to get a new stack of tech working, before falcon 9 becomes too out dated. falcon 9 had such. ahead start, that it is still better than everything else in it's class. but it won't be long now until it because just another rocket in the market. I give 5 -10 years and it isn't special anymore. SpaceX is betting that starship will be larger and cheaper and working by then.
- izacus 4y agoI mean it's pretty clear - the early Teslas all had dying onboard computers due to flash wear which they even refused to fix because the warranty has passed. Those aren't companies that build anything lasting or environmentally friendly. It's just all throwaway toys.
- Spooky23 4y agoDon’t fix what isn’t broken is tough, because broken is debatable. Is your stable Univac mainframe application broken? Operationally, probably not. But your business cannot adapt becuase it relies on a platform for which everyone who knows it is dead.
- Beached 4y agonasa also doesn't have the luxury of picking their own direction, or tech stack, or doing whatever they want. nasa is burdened by Congress dictation what rocket to build, even if it isn't the rocket nasa wants. look at the river program though, nasa still does cutting edge stuff with cutting edge hardware, at really high quality. just don't look at sls or iss
- bbjJqJmxFNbAcg9 4y agoNASA hasn't really had the proper funding to do... anything... in a few decades. And if SpaceX had gone to space before NASA it would probably look like NASA could run circles around SpaceX... "Fail fast" is great when the only thing at risk is your own money but when you throw human life into the mix not so much. How do you think their fatality rate will compare to that of NASA?