2 ms·
Life in Bangladesh has completely transformed even since I lived there in the mid 1980s. My dad laments that it’s too crowded and kids in his village don’t know
by rayiner 4y ago
Life in Bangladesh has completely transformed even since I lived there in the mid 1980s. My dad laments that it’s too crowded and kids in his village don’t know what it’s like to take a boat to school anymore during monsoon, but progress has happened rapidly.
Energy is the critical thing. We don’t have space for wind mills and solar panels. I’d love to see Pan-Asian cooperation on nuclear. Regrettably, I think all that will have to happen through alignment with China. The west is captured by Malthusian thinking, and their solution is “less brown people,” not “more energy, more infrastructure, more production.”
- foobarian 4y ago> and their solution is “less brown people,” not “more energy, more infrastructure, more production.” Sadly (or ironically?) the solution might be "less people" through "more energy infrastructure and production." I.e. development for whatever reason seems to drive population growth down, to the point where most of the west is losing population.
- ElevenLathe 4y agoThis is the absolute best-case scenario for humanity: advancing technology allows us to develop the poor parts of the world with green energy and stabilize population voluntarily rather than through a series of apocalyptic wars and famines. As far as nature goes, the market will clear one way or another (unless we destroy the biosphere entirely and turn Earth into Venus).
- prottog 4y ago> The west is captured by Malthusian thinking It's been almost 200 years since Malthus's passing and the human population has octupled since then, so you'd think that most people would give him less credence, but you're right those ideas seem more popular than ever. I keep on repeating on this forum that the way out is through, with better technology allowing us to consume more energy per capita, not less. There is no freezing or turning back the clock without the suffering of billions.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoRead A Farewell to Alms. Malthus's thinking was objectively correct up to the time of writing. He just made & recorded the observations at almost exactly the wrong time, right before the trend reversed, during the industrial revolution. I'm not claiming that we have reached a new era where - once again - growing population = worse living conditions. But there are a lot of good arguments WRT to limits on fossil fuel extraction, physical limitations on technological progress, etc... Light bulbs can't get much more efficient. Neither can electricity transmission. Energy generation still has a healthy amount to improve. Maybe there's enough progress left to be made for the population to double again. But the idea that the population could be near infinite on this planet and that would only lead to more progress and better living conditions is laughable. There's clearly some limit. My crystal ball isn't working. I don't know if we've passed it, or are even close to it...
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThere's lots of room to improve electricity transmission. Local generation is more efficient than remote generation. This is especially important in poor rural areas. Build somebody a natgas generator and they're dependent on you for fuel. Build them a nuclear plant and they're dependent on you for experts. Give them a solar panel and now they independent.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoAssuming they don't need electricity at night or when it's cloudy and they only need one solar panel's worth of electricity and they don't live in a condo where they have nowhere to put it...
- Manuel_D 4y agoEnergy demand is concentrated in population centers. In practice, renewables result more remote generation: https://www.vox.com/videos/22685707/climate-change-clean-energy-high-voltage-transmission-lines https://www.vox.com/videos/22685707/climate-change-clean-ene... I'm always amused when people talk about a decentralized grid as though it's a positive. It's a liability, since energy demand is centralized.
- tarakat 4y ago> The west is captured by Malthusian thinking, and their solution is “less brown people,” Ironic then that brown people is the only group still growing in the west then: America’s white population declined for the first time [..] Meanwhile, there was significant growth among minority groups over the last decade. - https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/aug/12/us-2020-census-white-population-declines https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/aug/12/us-2020-cens...
- enraged_camel 4y ago>> The west is captured by Malthusian thinking, and their solution is “less brown people,” Not sure why you believe this. Antinatalist and child-free movements have exploded in popularity in the west.