2 ms·
I think Form Energy batteries and that whole category of cheap long term storage that gets turned back into electricity (including, controversially, pumped hydr
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
I think Form Energy batteries and that whole category of cheap long term storage that gets turned back into electricity (including, controversially, pumped hydro) are a dead end.
The random element breaks their already fragile cost justification.
Hydrogen generation makes sense because it's a physical product that you can use for other things if you don't burn it, which acts as insurance. A buffer for your buffer.
Heat batteries can have predictable loads and don't need the return trip to electricity.
Lithium and PV have a daily rhythm of usage which covers the higher price.
And throwing some energy away most of the year if there's no demand can still make financial sense if it's needed for rare peaks.
In general, building more renewables and doing the above is cheaper than trying to store energy and convert it back to electricity (unless you do it once or twice a day to amortise the cost).
This is why the climate change deniers go on and on about storage. They have correctly identified that it doesn't make financial sense to use batteries for that last few percent, but ignored all the other, better cheaper options to focus on that totally unnecessary approach. And also that the other 90% are better, cleaner and cheaper so we have money to burn on solutions if we needed it.
The cheaper renewables get, the less the Form battery sales pitch works. Just build more generation and short term storage.
- ncmncm 4y agoThrowing away energy will probably not be a thing once the factories for hydrogen and ammonia generating equipment and desalination equipment have ramped up. H2, NH3, and clean H2O are so useful there will always be a market for as much as you can produce at zero marginal cost. I.e., once you have the equipment, which you needed anyway, it makes no sense to operate it less than you can afford to, even when the price of those drops to near nothing.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoYou could argue that running those systems at anything less than 100% capacity is just another kind of waste, which would be true. It's all just trade-offs. Generating energy that isn't used, or not using assets to their full capacity is just something to deal with based on costs and benefits. We have plenty of waste and slack in the world today, and renewables seem likely to radically reduce that, so no point getting caught up in worrying about minor inefficiencies. 10 steps forward, one step back is still forward motion.
- ncmncm 4y agoAgreed. Just noting that drawing down your ammonia storage to run ammonia synthesis for sale would make no sense. But an aluminum plant might reasonably burn aluminum powder to keep its furnaces hot, when spot price peaks.