4 ms·
I think there's something missing here. Is that the price per unit stored, or the price per unit of capacity to store? Batteries cost $120/kWh of initial capac
by ben_w 4y ago
I think there's something missing here. Is that the price per unit stored, or the price per unit of capacity to store?
Batteries cost $120/kWh of initial capacity, but they can be recharged between hundreds and multiple thousands of times before significant degradation, depending on the specific design? Picking x1000 arbitrarily, that adds 12¢ to the cost of electricity that goes via a battery today (a lot to be sure, but significantly less than the average domestic cost here).
I think hydrogen electrolysis is about 60-90% efficient, so 1/0.9 to 1/0.6 times the electricity cost to make as gas (assuming the hardware cost is amortised to the point of being negligible), but that isn't as high as $1/kWh even for domestic electricity prices here in Germany. Square cube law implies large scale storage will be much cheaper than small scale storage, so I'm still expecting that to be lower than $1/kWh as delivered, though I can believe it might cost that to build the capacity.
- ncmncm 4y agoBattery cost is on the same downward trend as everything else, with new chemistries subtracting step functions. (Watch iron/air, zinc/bromine, antimony/calcium.) But for bulk storage, there are still cheaper technologies that cost only per MW to store or extract, not per MWh stored, like batteries. Tankage is cheap. The per-MW cost is for motor-generators attached to hydro turbine, air compressor, or winch; or for nitrogen liquifier and turbine; or for electrolyser and fuel cell or combined-cycle turbine. Storing in transportable tanks affords extra revenue opportunities.
- ben_w 4y agoI don't think that answers my question. I think the stated prices may mean something other than what they look like they mean.
- ncmncm 4y agoCost for motor/generators is not changing, but the tech is extremely mature. Costs for electrolysers and fuel cells are both falling fast. Air compression and liquidation are both mature technologies, but might respond to a massive increase in usage by getting cheaper. A survey of storage technology pilot projects show people doing much more expensive versions of each than will be deployed. The incentives for pilot projects favor over-complex systems based on over-complex processes described in papers that had to be that to get academic attention as novel, and grants likewise. When civil engineers get involved, systems will get radically simpler and cheaper. Probably designs will trade off efficiency, as the cost for a little extra power is much less than for complexity.
- pfdietz 4y agoThe $1/kWh is per unit of capacity to store energy. That cost is then amortized over the number of charge/discharge cycles to get the per unit of energy stored cost. Hydrogen storage in underground solution mined cavities is just that cheap. This is the huge advantage hydrogen has for very long term or very rarely used energy storage over batteries. Storage of a combustible gas underground is already done on a massive scale. Natural gas is already stored, by the millions of tonnes, in just these kinds of caverns. The cost is cheap enough that the entire NG consumption of a region's winter can be stored. Now, hydrogen also has power related costs: cost/W of electrolysers, compressors, and turbines or fuel cells. But for very long term storage this becomes small compared to the per energy capacity costs.