10 ms·
> What makes solar panels expensive is all the exotic materials, What exotic material is needed for crystalline silicon PV (95% of the market)? Silicon itself
by pfdietz 4y ago
> What makes solar panels expensive is all the exotic materials,
What exotic material is needed for crystalline silicon PV (95% of the market)? Silicon itself is extremely mundane; it's the second most common element in the Earth's crust.
- pydry 4y agoI think he's a bit out of date. Some of the hi tech solar panels still use rare earths but since ~2014 they're more the kind of thing you'd put on a space station not a roof. The cheap, grid scale solar panels are all crystalline silicon.
- pfdietz 4y agoSolar panels never used rare earths.
- ncmncm 4y agoRight, the most exotic stuff in (some) solar cells is cadmium and tellurium. The cadmium is nasty but not hard to source, maybe 8 g/m^2. Perovskite cells use a thin film of mostly lead or tin, and maybe some bromine. They should be calling the neodymium and stuff sometimes used in wind turbines "lanthanides", instead, to avoid misleading people about their availability.
- ncmncm 4y agoRight, the premise, "What makes solar panels expensive" is flawed. They are not expensive, they are astonishingly cheap. But maybe he just means that something will keep their cost above zero, which is true. But their cost per watt nameplate capacity will continue on down with the amount of material they need, and the amount of labor going into them. Today they still need a frame, and glass, and are packed in boxes onto pallets and shipped; to be mounted on rails and brackets. But soon enough they will have no glass, and no frame, and be shipped in big rolls to be stretched between posts.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoA few rare earths, precious metals like platinum, copper, etc. It's also why recycling them is a thing.
- ncmncm 4y agoNo lanthanides, no platinum. Copper, silver traces. Ultra-pure silicon. Aluminum frame, glass cover.
- tuatoru 4y agoIt's more the energy cost involved in purifying the refined silicon and implanting the dopants without causing defects that hurt panel efficiency. And the glass covers and aluminum frames. Making them also uses a lot of energy. Roll-to-roll low temperature printed PV (using perovskites on plastic film)[1] potentially has lower production cost for this reason. Put a roll in a shipping container with the controller and inverter electronics, truck it to the site, roll it out on the ground,[2] and hook up the inverter to the grid. Construction costs don't get much lower than that. 1. https://powerroll.solar/unique-solar-film/ https://powerroll.solar/unique-solar-film/ 2. Bulldoze and steamroll the ground first, if you want. Optional.